[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
http://www.shatteredisles.com • High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my! - Page 4
Page 4 of 4

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Posted: Thu Sep 18, 2014 1:28 pm
by
Swamp Ape wrote:Hah! What's wrong with that? I am always right, agreeing with me is the only logical thing to do. ::nods solemnly:: Would you mind sharing that wine?
Barefoot Riesling is dangerous and goes down like fruit juice. I guess I can be magnanimous and share, though. But where it takes me one glass, it'll likely take you the rest of the bottle!

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Posted: Thu Sep 18, 2014 1:37 pm
by
Does popcorn go with Riesling? If not, I have some mulled cider.

Re: High Priests, Archmages, and Bears - oh my!

Posted: Thu Sep 18, 2014 1:55 pm
by
Malaki33 wrote:Hi everyone,

As I have been reading through this thread I have to say that I was quite surprised by it. Because I see loads of conflict in the game. Have you all ever been to a Conclave meeting and watched the dynamics? Have you ever watched the dynamics at a peddle? I have found that within the game most of the conflict is personality driven not race or religion driven and it is my own personal opinion that is a good thing. Like has been pointed out by many of the people posting here, there are different sides to each religion so it by itself should not be driving RP in any way. I also feel the same about race. I belief it takes a combination of things to create conflict. And I think there is quite a bit of it. Just one guys opinion
I missed last night's conclave meeting, but the kind of person to person conflict outside of religious conflict is a good kind of conflict for games, but SI is supposed to be this grand, imaginative world based on 6 different elemental religions, 15 races, and 13 classes (some of which - like mages, arcanists, diviners, and the clergy - have their creation-roots steeped in lore). The idea here is to foster a base of conflict around lines of religion and race that the creators used to define their world.

That is why I do think religion and race should be drivers of RP in SI because the very fabric of the game's lore is built around it. It shouldn't be the only driver; P2P interactions are what flesh out our RP, evolve it, and make it fun. Conventions will be bent, shifted, and overcome. And as Nikolas said, this RP where our characters have overcome the norm or have made enemies where there should be friends, should be a journey and not the default mentality at roll. I don't think we can simply ignore the lore the creators have given us and still honor the world they built, and that we are guests in.

As was said before, this doesn't mean that all our characters have to be cookie cutter images of their race and religion pages, but we as players should carefully select the race and religion that best suits our character's primary beliefs, actions, and back story, and then grow our character from that starting point based on the P2P interactions they encounter along the way. Religion and race should inform our RP choices, not dictate them.

That's why I really wanted to open this thread. I wanted people to comment on how they saw and understood their character's views of their own race and religion, and how that was a filter to view others'. How a human might worship a god compared to how an Argali would. How Pyresians might view Tetherians, who aren't necessarily enemies from their past, but would definitely have differing views on the cycles of creation and rebirth. How people see the lingering effects of Itzal's magic and shattering, how it affected their home isles, and how you as a player used those rippling effects to help inform how you see and crafted your character.

Staff needs to supply more lore, sure, but they also invited us to give our input, and it feels more like we've simply thrown out their guidelines instead of embrace and build on them.