Page 4 of 4
Re: cooking recipies
Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2015 5:59 pm
by
Shadowbane wrote:For the most part, though, it's relatively easy to gather materials and it's not anywhere near as risky, if it's risky at all, as it is to go hunting. That's why hunting and killing things that could very well kill you pays better, because of the increased risk. I think that's a fair system. It wouldn't be fair to benefit as much from easy, risk-free work as someone does from going out and hunting and risking character death at worst, or a steep repair bill at best.
Hopefully the upcoming crafting fix will straighten a lot of things out.
I agree completely, I'd just like to see some kind of varying risk factors. I wouldn't mind risking jail time, some fines or confiscations if it meant getting to earn a bit more. I could see other trade skills being created like smuggling or bribery.
Plus it would be fun to see wanted posters with familiar faces on them or having to bribe corrupt officials or escape from jail.
I'd also like to see the use of tools and equipment. Right now i can sculpt stone with my bare hands, and that is nuts.
Re: cooking recipies
Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2015 6:26 pm
by
Skinning is unique in that it is a gathering skill that mixes with hunting. While you are unlikely to die from squirrels or gophers, the wolves of both types can and will kill you. You also get the benefit of getting three types of materials though off many animals. This would be fantastic if the markets for these 3 materials were functioning at a basic level. The reason I can be a full time bone collector is because one PC is fairly generous with payments and because I carve a little.
Eventually we'll probably have monsters and things like elephants that are really killer and can be skinned. Those insects are definitely coming at some point.
Really though I'd make tons more hunting monsters. It's more that I enjoy slaughtering animals. I never get tired of it the way I do monsters.
Re: cooking recipies
Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2015 6:52 pm
by
As I said before, the crafting update should fix instances that involve bone and skinning, as it does rely on hunting. Usually. And with hunting, you can get three types of mats (as you said) with minimal risk if you know which animals to go after. I'd think the risk in hunting animals (over, say, foraging or mining) is balanced by the fact you get a better variety of material back for your efforts. Thus, more money. (Or practice, if you use it yourself.)
Re: cooking recipies
Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2015 9:10 pm
by
More thoughts....
Snaek Says:
You can still bundle store bought materials and still craft with them, but you won't be able to sell raw materials anywhere.
So, no more selling caught fish, or hide, fur etc. ... I think ALL drops in game should sell for Something. it's weird to have
something in my inventory that has Zero worth. Every item in game should be sell-able for at least 1-2db ?
In other games , like WOW, if you are say, a tailor, you can craft items useable only by YOU, or that have an advantage over
items dropped. I'd like to see something like that here.... a bone carver can craft a... 'carved bone knife' ... that may only sell
for 2db, but has the AR of a sword, while only using the STAM of a dagger, and cannot be repaired , and breaks rather quickly,
and mebbe has a 2 sec rt?... This might make a market for people who could buy such daggers to PT with from a bone carver.
anyways, the crafting update should be fun, and i don't mind fishing, i even enjoy it, but if they take away the selling
of raw mats, i hope they will make it easier to use them, and a lil more profitable?
::p.s. will there be some IC RP when crafting changes?.... a ship from kalesia dumps a ton of salt in Rum village and prices drop etc? ::

X.
Re: cooking recipies
Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2015 9:38 pm
by
I don't really agree with the statement that hunting isn't risk free. I absolutely cannot die in the crypt. Wren cannot die in the crypt. You cannot die in statues. Anyone under hunting cannot die in their hunting area unless they try to die. Most of the mines in the game have mobs in them. And most people under hunt because it's more efficient with very similar earnings. I think it's sad that a gatherer cannot make even half of what someone makes underhunting. If under leveled mobs stopped giving uses and money to people who were far over their respected levels, it might make sense to say there was actual risk in hunting. But until then, it's not true.
Re: cooking recipies
Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2015 10:30 pm
by
I might not be able to die easily in statues, but I have a hell of a repair build by the time I have to go sell. Crafting does not result in repairs. Not only that, but until recently, the only place characters with only parry as a defense could hunt effectively without a group was broken hill or the manor. Now I can hunt trogs when I feel the urge. There is risk in hunting, and there is cost. The only cost crafters have at this moment, largely, is time.
Re: cooking recipies
Posted: Mon Jan 19, 2015 1:10 pm
by
I never said anything about crafting. I was talking about gathering not being worth the time for the sole purpose of trying to sell the goods gathered. Also, it's your choice to hunt with the best weapons and armor if you are doing so. Hunting with steel is very affordable and using lower grade weapons does not bring a large repair cost. Your characters mechanical failings shouldn't be considered when dealing with the economics of the game. I'm sure the update will help, and if you're hurting trogs, then you're making good money despite the repair costs. Again, just so there's no mistake, my comments were about gathering materials for the sole purpose to sell and why something like a farmer's market isn't going to work. This is from a pure economic standpoint. Please remember that.