Page 4 of 5
Re: Temple Defense
Posted: Sat Jun 11, 2016 12:25 am
by
Not every skill that IS magical needs to be listed under spells, either.
Re: Temple Defense
Posted: Sat Jun 11, 2016 2:12 am
by
No point in having a spells command if it doesn't list your magical abilities.
Re: Temple Defense
Posted: Sat Jun 11, 2016 2:43 am
by
Well, I haven't tried many things in SI... I've just one character, and that is an Air Mage, but I would like to make this suggestion... what if we differ the techniques that are under the Spell listing as magics that deal with the elements, meanwhile the magics that deal with other things such as Disguise that deal with aura and appearance, listed... somewhere else? X'D And so, magic could have a wide cope, but then Spell would specifically refer to magic that involve manipulation of elements... that are owned by our six God and Goddess.
Once again, I don't know whether this magic-classifying based on whether it involves elements or not could be used for all class... but I'm just trying to suggest something here. :')
Re: Temple Defense
Posted: Sat Jun 11, 2016 4:18 am
by
I think we should keep everything as it is. Disguise is a skill and lightning bolts are spells and divine shields are prayers. Makes perfect sense to me!
And now for the meme of the day:

Re: Temple Defense
Posted: Sat Jun 11, 2016 8:26 am
by
Just because an ability doesn't possess a spell command doesn't mean it isn't magical. I'm not sure how you don't get that the very world itself is steeped in magic. Without it, players would have stripped mines and forests and farms bare a year ago. Gophers would be extinct. There is a sun and and moon because of magic. No one sails beyond the isles because they all vanish and never return, that is magic and the world may as well be flat. The weather is insane and unstable because of magic. Nydine breathe underwater because of magic, sylph and dragons fly because of it, wyvern eat it to sustain themselves.
It's a fantasy game in a world based on magic. If you want things that can be explained by logic and reason and science, you're in the wrong place.
Re: Temple Defense
Posted: Sat Jun 11, 2016 10:21 am
by
It's all well and good to blame magic for everything.
Don't mean it is truly at fault.
Logic and magic are not mutually exclusive.
In fact, I daresay that magic is quite logical... unto itself.
But no one has the time or inclination to define the laws of magic.
I don't believe I ever said that this is not or should not be a magical world.
Don't put words into my mouth just so you can have an easy argument to counter.
Besides, he magicalness of the world has no effect on logic.
Logic is not mine alone, it is a standard that the civilized world has come to agree upon.
It is the methodology of deduction.
Learn to love it.
Logic and reason are the same thing.
Science is just the explanation of the world around us deduced by logic.
Much of what used to be magic has since become mundane with the more science our culture develops.
Re: Temple Defense
Posted: Sat Jun 11, 2016 11:13 am
by
Then there's just no answer for you, sorry. The game world is pretty much stuck in a time period that's a mix of the post-columbian era and general fantasy. What's available has been given to you, even by staff. If it's still not enough, well, maybe you can write your own treatise on it for us plebeians to educate ourselves with.
Re: Temple Defense
Posted: Sat Jun 11, 2016 11:17 am
by
You can only educate those who actually want to learn.
And there should be a logical reason, even if it boils down to an arbitrary choice by staff.
Personally, I hate arbitrary choices, but if that's what it is, I can live with it, just own it.
Hiding behind an overarching umbrella defense of magic just doesn't hold up under critical scrutiny.
Re: Temple Defense
Posted: Sat Jun 11, 2016 3:10 pm
by
Vexing wrote:
Besides, he magicalness of the world has no effect on logic.
Logic is not mine alone, it is a standard that the civilized world has come to agree upon.
It is the methodology of deduction.
Learn to love it.
Logic and reason are the same thing.
Science is just the explanation of the world around us deduced by logic.
Much of what used to be magic has since become mundane with the more science our culture develops.
Some confusion about logic. It is a representation of certain methods of reasoning. It is not itself a methodology. Some logic is deductive, some is inductive. The methods of science are largely inductive, not deductive. And, while it is a controversial point, some logicians and philosophers believe that logic cannot cleanly be separated from the way the world is--its ontology and metaphysics. A world imbued with magick might, under this view, demand a different logic.
However, your complaint seems to center on how things are represented to you, not how they appear to your character. You are troubled that disguise is not listed as a spell even though it appears to have a magickal element to it. But, of course, it is not listed as anything for a character. If characters choose not to treat disguise as a spell, it may be because it lacks certain characteristics typical of spell-casting, like stylized gestures and verbal incantations. That doesn't mean the characters involved, thieves in particular, fail to recognize that there is a magickal element to disguise, just that they don't think of it as a spell in the usual sense. Aruskin has discovered that tracking must be, in some sense, magickal through much experience and experimentation with the skill, but he does not think of tracking as a spell. And even if he did, it would not affect how Aruskin goes about using his tracking ability nor would it change its effectiveness. So why bother even wondering if it is or is not to be classified as a spell? From the point of view of characters, such a question appears to be unimportant.
--Aruskin
Re: Temple Defense
Posted: Sat Jun 11, 2016 3:56 pm
by
The premise of disguise being magical seems flawed.
The only aspect of it that seems magical is the ability to mask an aura.
All other aspects should have mundane methods.
Nothing about the messaging suggests you are weaving some illusion magic to beguile passers by.
Perhaps, have the two abilities separated from each other, so that aura masking could be a spell?