Lock picking

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
User avatar
SilverShade
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 197
Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 12:03 pm

Re: Lock picking

Post by SilverShade »

Actually, assassins don't have two defenses. We have an additional check for the same type of defense. This was mentioned in the Game Update 1/23 thread up in the Game Info subforum.

If we lose any more of our defenses, we'd be useless as a melee class. Our damage output isn't the same, because we have racial modifiers to consider. I compared stats of a human, a gargoyle, and a vuk. Vukasin blew it out of the water with health and stamina alone, and gargoyle had strength (but bad health and stamina.) As a human, I don't have impressive strength or dex, and I don't have impressive stamina to start without training up several combat skills. But at least the human's health was greater than the gargoyle's.

If we became a pure burst class, I'm pretty certain the assassin class wouldn't survive. I don't mind playing a glass cannon (I mained a frost death knight for a long time in WoW), but a melee class needs SOME kind of defense. With mage spells, ranged attacks, and improving naturals, we're actually at a disadvantage with just parry and a second parry check unless the person we fight is JUST a weapon user.

The chances of that are pretty slim.
Breath, Blade, and Blood
~Xercien
User avatar
Aumnren
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 245
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2013 8:18 pm

Re: Lock picking

Post by Aumnren »

Morley wrote:when new players come from other games via topmusites, that's the description they see. and it's an awesome description and makes you want to roll one. To roll an assassin and not be able to kill anyone is just bad advertising and disappointing to say the least.
I agree that I'd like to see the site updated with descriptions for each class currently implemented, and and accurate summaries of those classes as the creators want to take them.
SilverShade wrote:Actually, assassins don't have two defenses. We have an additional check for the same type of defense...If we lose any more of our defenses, we'd be useless as a melee class.
This sounds like a second defense to me: you can block two attacks. Yes, your defense has limits; it's the way things go. And as I said earlier, removing dual parry might not be needed when poisons and traps are brought in. I don't know what the creators have in line for them or how potent they will be.
SilverShade wrote:Our damage output isn't the same, because we have racial modifiers to consider. I compared stats of a human, a gargoyle, and a vuk. Vukasin blew it out of the water with health and stamina alone, and gargoyle had strength (but bad health and stamina.) As a human, I don't have impressive strength or dex, and I don't have impressive stamina to start without training up several combat skills. But at least the human's health was greater than the gargoyle's.
Racial modifiers have little to nothing to do with a class' base specs. On even footing, warriors and assassins have the same offensive capability. Assassins have since seen their defense reduced by about 15%, but they also have additional skills the warrior doesn't right now to compensate.

Races right now seem broken, one that is being worked on the coming updates, I believe. Vukasins and Gavial seem to have higher damage output with no real negative to balance this - vukasins especially from what I hear. Choosing a human or a gargoyle, or vukasin for an assassin and noticing the unbalanced differences simply points out flaws in a race system, not a class one.
SilverShade wrote:If we became a pure burst class, I'm pretty certain the assassin class wouldn't survive. I don't mind playing a glass cannon (I mained a frost death knight for a long time in WoW), but a melee class needs SOME kind of defense. With mage spells, ranged attacks, and improving naturals, we're actually at a disadvantage with just parry and a second parry check unless the person we fight is JUST a weapon user.

The chances of that are pretty slim.
The assassin class has defenses. It will always have defenses because you're right, the class - or any class - wouldn't survive without a way to defend themselves.

The question here, really, is how: if not through passive defenses, then how will a class defend itself? The answer could come with - and I know I've beaten this horse to death - poisons and traps. The sheer amount of utility available from these skills is considerable, matching nearly any spell or skill that a caster or other CC class could have.

And it seems like a majority of the player base right now is straight CC. There are a few scouts, though Visyn is the only one I know for certain, and Faran, Blink, and Seren are the only mage classes I think have leveled spells. UC still isn't any form of reliable combat. The skill hasn't really improved much as a form of offense, save for the nifty new grapple skill, but that hardly maneuvers it as an effective answer to CC, especially since you have to be completely unarmed to use grapple (i.e. nothing in any of your hands, which means no defenses unless you have dodge). In the future all combat interactions could could change when all the classes are more flushed out to see how their abilities interact. Your additional skills might give you what you need to counter the things you can't block with passive defenses.
Anselm
Posts: 131
Joined: Mon Jan 02, 2012 12:46 am

Re: Lock picking

Post by Anselm »

Morley Darkfire wrote:Fine. I'll admit it. Draven actually had me beat. I had filled vigor bottles with healing. :P
Stick that in your "over-powered" pipe and smoke it.
This isn't possible, mate. The game goes an' reverts potion liquids drained from healin' flasks/bottles/vials drained into blue (vigors) bottles/flasks/vials into normal liquids; it'll no longer act as a healin' agent.
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Lock picking

Post by Blink »

Not much to add, except that this is a very low damage system overall. Nearly all weapon users are pretty low damage. Unless you are Geel. And it's Geel, so you need not question it. Magic damage isn't very high either, even when heavily leveled. It's just very consistent, which weapons are not. There just are no quick fights in this sytem. Maybe that'll change after Gir's damage tightning project. It may also change once there are high level people with things like dual wield and haste spell.
Seryth
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 87
Joined: Wed Dec 18, 2013 10:44 pm

Re: Lock picking

Post by Seryth »

Blink, I think you are spot on. Currently a fight could take upwards of 10 minutes between relatively equal combatants. In my opinion, that long of a fight removes a lot of the tension associated with PvP. I have no solutions for this, but I trust Gir's damage tightening ability.
User avatar
Austere
SI Staff Member
Posts: 389
Joined: Fri Jan 21, 2011 1:12 am

Re: Lock picking

Post by Austere »

Morley Darkfire wrote:Assassins reflect the darkest and most wicked side of the rogue. The dealing of death becomes a goal in itself, the epitome of evil. The assassin becomes so centered on this art that he begins to slow his pace, learning and contemplating each "mark" as the best method of killing them becomes clear. They also learn skills in keeping track of and tracking down their marks, as well as other means of making life for the targeted miserable, and short. The assassin can use any weapons, unlike the standard thief, though his armor is still restricted.
Unfortunately, the website is behind the times on the Assassin page.
The current in-game version of the Assassin help file is:

Assassins are specialized warriors in the art of meticulously and methodically killing their adversaries. Though greatness requires serious drive and intense practice, a mindful assassin may take on more of the facade of a warrior to fit in amongst adventuring groups and gossip circles. A proficient assassin may spend months watching a mark and contemplating the best method of eliminating that target. Whether motivated by politics or merciless revenge, a resourceful assassin can make high amounts of coin working for others.
Visyn
Conclave Representative
Posts: 115
Joined: Sun Dec 01, 2013 4:25 pm
Location: Illinois

Re: Lock picking

Post by Visyn »

Seryth wrote:Blink, I think you are spot on. Currently a fight could take upwards of 10 minutes between relatively equal combatants. In my opinion, that long of a fight removes a lot of the tension associated with PvP. I have no solutions for this, but I trust Gir's damage tightening ability.
A way to fix this is to have wound damage.
Creon
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 275
Joined: Sun Dec 22, 2013 9:22 am

Re: Lock picking

Post by Creon »

I honestly don't know how an Assassin's damage compares to that of other classes, and maybe things will change once class stats are implemented and racials don't count for as much, but given that an Assassin in better armor with 10-15 more CC levels couldn't take down a Warrior and was getting hit pretty hard in return, the idea of our offense being reduced is kinda scary.
Additionally on another thread Anslem did the math of defense I spoke with Morley just doesn't have very high defense skill in comparison to his CC.

He isn't far apart from me in CC levels it's been very wild speculation though. I wouldn't be able to hit him consistently with that level gap.

He did more damage to me his dmg range was on average from a decent or solid blow 11-18.

Grazing or minor cut 1-7.

The data I got from him was around 10 on average from me.

If anyone was wondering we had the exact same weapon.

Additionally how did we get on this subject? I thought this thread was about lock picking. Which by the way I can't wait to be implemented although I'd like to see it were there would be a pawnshop that could pick them for a significant cut of the coin of items that were in there. That being said that would really raise the value of a thief or 'locksmith' PC. Just a thought
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Lock picking

Post by Blink »

Additionally how did we get on this subject? I thought this thread was about lock picking. Which by the way I can't wait to be implemented although I'd like to see it were there would be a pawnshop that could pick them for a significant cut of the coin of items that were in there. That being said that would really raise the value of a thief or 'locksmith' PC. Just a thought
Snaek just said there won't be locked chests on monsters. Thus there will be no locksmiths of that type. How thieves will use this skill remains to be seen. But I think most players are very interested to see what is behind those locked doors in the game.
Creon
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 275
Joined: Sun Dec 22, 2013 9:22 am

Re: Lock picking

Post by Creon »

I know I think that's silly some monsters need to have a chest with locked goodies!
Post Reply