Yes, resists appear not to be working properly and I hope it is fixed as well. As well, melee damage range needs to be tightened up, but I believe Anselm and Gir have both said staff is working on correcting that. No PC is going to be able to win all the time, or against multiple opponents. That is just the nature of the game, and no amount of time spent leveling should justify you to win in all situations and against all classes. Anselm has said all classes have a foil.Blink wrote:
But yes, mages ARE a bit broken, for the reasons Anselm has stated. We aren't going to get a very accurate reading or combat test without those issues fixed. It doesn't matter much time you've put into grinding, SI isn't designed for one person to be hugely powerful. Taking on two or three characters will often prove difficult, unless something is very broken, or levels in your primary attack are vastly different. (Assuming everything is fixed and working right, like mid level third tier attack spells)
Racial diversity does make the game more enjoyable. The point I was making is not that racial diversity should not occur - it's that a low strength mod melee is likely going to lose to a race and class combo designed to foil it ... especially under 1v1, prepared, no-surprise circumstances. Just as a Human warrior will likely lose to a Gavial or Vukasin warrior of the same levels due to the HP disparity and racial strength bonus when using the same level equipment (unless of course the RNG is being exceedingly generous to the Human that day). These are simple facts of race/class combos and need to be considered when comparing mechanics. As it stands, the Gavial do not have options other than warriors or barbarians to play, even if they wanted to - for RP purposes - drive a Gavial toon with a terrible casting mod when casting mods are implemented.Blink wrote: Oh yeah, I want to say I'm also glad that there are a ton of Human and elf melee people in the game. It's good to have roleplay diversity. It can get pretty tiresome when every warrior is a Vukasin and every mage is an Elf.
This goes back to the fact that some RP race/class combos (Human, Elf, Sylph, Goblin melee) are not as strong as their more bestial counterparts, and when facing a race designed for the class they are, will likely lose if the attack levels are comparable. It is the same situation as described above for melee. A Gavial warrior of the same levels as a Human warrior will almost always beat the Human warrior because the Gavial race is designed to excel as a melee. The Human is mostly average at it. I'd wager if Blink and Faran were to throw down, the outcome would be a complete toss-up since they are equitably matched.Draven wrote: So the thing that makes people upset is people with the highest Armor/Weapon combo couldn't beat you and it seemingly didn't matter what level CC they were, that seems problematic.
Parry, dual parry and shield block are all passive skills that level at the same time without added delay of leveling close combat. Shield block is the only skill I can level passively as well. While it's true melee have the capacity for much more utility in this game than they do in others, during the Draven/Faran fight you only used close combat. Again, had you been using equipment of the same level (blacksteel), and were melee damage ranges tightened as well as resists working properly, you would have won.Draven wrote: I certainly wouldn't win if I just won CC only in addition to parry, dual parry, and shield block. Warriors have other skills to work combat related as well as assassins.
Also, I did not mean to imply you have also not worked to level the Draven character, but it is evident that viability of power in three months versus six months makes leveling close combat (your only damage-inflicting attack skill until dual wield is implemented) a different bag than leveling the number of spells required to have the attack power and utility I do right now. That is just the nature of the beast between casting and melee, though, and I welcome the challenge to continue unlocking spells and improving my PC.
That is entirely probable, although elves do start out with higher intelligence and wisdom stats which I believe contributes to overall casting success/failure. Perhaps it doesn't right now, but it is certainly intended to.Blink wrote: A Human mage trained up may well have caused the same controversy by beating a bunch of high level warriors at the games because spell resists aren't working. Maybe the coming OOC games will help hash some of these issues out.
Indeed it would, and it would benefit everyone if people could continue to make thoughtful, honest feedback with the overall goal of making the game balanced and enjoyable for everyone.Blink wrote: It'd be a poor long term character strategy to rely on broken things to make my character powerful.