Page 5 of 8
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Sat Mar 05, 2016 9:47 pm
by
As for class changes, someone had one quite some time ago. They didn't stay in their original class long, if I remember correctly.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Sun Mar 06, 2016 2:19 am
by
Just because you're a member of a temple doesn't mean you're promised a resurrection from your god. A god can chose to not bring a follower back for whatever reason.
we've had alot of people die on hunts, and we usually go to their temple to get them after.
I think temple rezzes are guaranteed, and the only reason someone would Not get one was if they choose to remain dead?
It's a point for the players to decide on I guess?
...how should we handle the auto rez we get IC?
Death is NOT permanent here, should we include that fact in Game?
I vote for common knowledge that our god/goddess will rez us.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Sun Mar 06, 2016 3:21 am
by
I think it completely depends on your gods philosophy. A god who expects you to maintain a high worth of yourself shouldn't be okay with someone just throwing away their life. But a god who is all about rebirth, would be far more accepting of it. You should just read about the lore of your religion and try your best to think if your God would normally rez you or not.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Sun Mar 06, 2016 3:26 am
by
Short of extenuating circumstances and personal choice, resurrection seems guaranteed.
What extenuating circumstances are there short of major rules infractions though?
This seems to imply that there are ways to incur perma-death short of personal choice or a staff ruling...
Just to speculate...
Will there be a perma-death poison?
Or a major faith ritual to beseech the Gods to turn a blind eye to so-and-so's requests?
Maybe there is some [un]natural material weakness (like kryptonite) that would prove the Gods to just be vastly superior beings, and not deities?
Is there going to be a regular D&D style alignment check to make sure you are staying true to your faith codedly, the better to weed out the heretics and mark the unbelievers for true death?
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Sun Mar 06, 2016 4:34 am
by
Probably no to all of those. If you want permanent death, I'm sure you could certainly work it out with staff to do that. There have been cases where players have been excommunicated from their temples for going completely against the grain though. But that's the closest you're gonna get to not being resurrected.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Sun Mar 06, 2016 11:17 am
by
Because of game mechanics (and not many people like an Ironman challenge), player characters will always be brought back. Staff isn't going to impose permanent death, so it is up to the player to decide when they are really dead.
The explanation for why people can die repeatedly and always come back has just been that they're blessed. If we go along with "well, the gods will ALWAYS bring us back" the seriousness of death suddenly isn't there anymore. Death is supposed to be a serious thing, unfortunately, it's been left up to players to make it serious.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Sun Mar 06, 2016 11:21 am
by
So why do you try to pretend like the resurrection isn't guaranteed, when for all intents and purposes, it is?
Death isn't serious.
I see no point in pretending that it is.
If you want death to be feared, make it mechanically fearsome.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Sun Mar 06, 2016 11:56 am
by
And if I were staff, it would be a very serious thing. I think our death system is far too gentle.
Why do I pretend? It's called roleplay. It's what's supposed to happen here. An OOC meet was held some time ago that included a discussion on death, and how it was supposed to be a serious thing. If someone needs mechanics to RP properly, then it's really on the player, not the game. The point behind roleplay is to act a role and pretend. Several of those playing SI do treat death seriously.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Sun Mar 06, 2016 12:08 pm
by
Yes, but the roleplay and the mechanics should agree.
Or rather, anything that happens mechanically should have a solid IC explanation for why it is the way it is.
The explanation for why the Gods are so lenient (to keep players from whinging about Ironman) seems lacking at the moment.
Perhaps if the process of resurrection took more of an active roll from the clergy PCs?
Otherwise, you stay a ghost for a LOT longer.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Sun Mar 06, 2016 12:21 pm
by
Staff doesn't appear to want anything more serious than a time out with perks and the chance to lose skill gains, so really, that would have to be taken up with them.
Player characters make up a very small percentage of the game world's population. It's safe to assume that Pearl realistically would have a population of some thousands, not the handful of NPCs and PCs people see in the day to day. PCs are really the only ones who actually come back. So, the IC explanation for anyone returning from the dead is that their god decided to bless them that day, not that no one likes to go Ironman. The PC does more for their god than the NPC, so it stands to reason that the PC would be more valuable to a god.
There's more than one or two somber old ladies wandering the streets, or a few lavishly dressed merchants in King's Port. PCs are supposed to be your above average individual, for whatever reason, and NPCs fill everything else out for the common Joe. While we come back, they don't. They just get replaced by the next average schmuck.