Defensive abilities always passively increase while you hunt. Will having a non-combat heal prevent you from sitting in a room and letting a mob beat on you while you heal and parry? Yes. But I don't think it'd wreck your ability to train the skill.If mending couldn't be used in combat, that would screw every melee class out of being able to focus on training a defensive ability.
That being said, keeping the ability in combat, but increasing the DR penalty for sitting would be a start. I still think a character should need to have at least one open hand free as well, or something in addition, but there are plenty of different ways to balance things.
I think some skills and abilities in the game aren't meant to be power trained, and are designed to increase slowly. It doesn't make the skills any less useful, it just makes them slower to level. For CC classes, nearly all of their abilities are unlocked, or can be leveled passively while they grind up their CC. In fact, their main offense and main defense is packaged neatly in this one skill. CC complementary abilities are generally slower to train, such as shadow strike or pummel, but these abilities are just that, 'complementary' to their main attacks, and should be slower to master.It's bad enough I can't focus train all of my class abilities...I'm of the opinion that you should be able to exclusively train anything on your skill list, otherwise it's pointless to have it as an actual skill
This is probably because in PvE you're facing multiple mobs, and they're able to out pace your healing.Do you mend during combat at all outside of PvP?
Characters can still hunt efficiently even if mend were not useable in combat. In fact, as you stated before, no one really uses mend in a PvE combat setting, so nothing should change much for those who rely on it. The issue here is its effectiveness as a PvP skill.players need to be able to PT and hunt solo with some degree of efficiency if that's what they decide to do with their time.
Interesting thing here: do the stronger races even have downsides to compensate for the fact that they have increased strength and health? Slower spell casts? Lower stamina? Lower stats?Another thing to possibly keep in mind: Race, and class. I've never rolled a Gavial, but I do have a Vukasin, and they have considerably more health, stamina and strength than my human, which means having a much easier time soloing stuff without having to worry about mending.
I know warriors get two defenses off the bat, but the two classes both have the same AR / DR progressions, and both do get two defenses eventually. I think warriors should be generally sturdier than assassins, especially when you guys get your trap and poisons toys to even the playing field, but right now, the two classes seem nearly synonymous, except for the complement abilities unlocked.Warriors seem to be a lot sturdier than Assassins in general, too, so there's that.
Code: Select all
Group hunting is great, don't get me wrong, but the player base is small, and many characters already have their go-to hunting partners. People aren't all on at the same time, or want to do the same things at those times. Forcing people to rely on group hunts does not make them more desirable.By this, I assume you mean to argue that it is a might unfair that healing prayers can be used standing up. Yes, this is an advantage to being a priest, and should be an advantage.Prayers can be used without being seated.
You are right in that "realism" in a fantasy game should be taken with a grain of salt. However, there is a difference in bending realism by saying a character can fly or breath underwater with magic, and saying that a character can adequately mend wounds while simultaneously holding a shield and a weapon and deflecting blows from their attacker. But as I've said before, I don't think taking mend out of combat should be the only consideration here.However, I wouldn't use "realism" as a basis for something in fantasy or a game...Reality gets bent for the sake of game balance and enjoyment.
I'm behind you on this Swamp. I think the first time someone gets into a PvP fight against a team with a priest, they'll see just how valuable one can be in a fight. As well, priests should come in as many shapes and sizes as thieves, warriors, mages, or assassins.Why would a Priest want to avoid PvP? Choosing to play a priest does not mean my character is a pacifist.
At low levels, but as Blink said, what happens when the skill gets into the 30s, 50s, or up to Max? What will the success rate be? The amount of health it heals?...fails all the damn time at low levels
I don't mean to sound like I'm complaining. I noticed how easy and effective it was to mend in combat with very little penalty, and it made me think of the repercussions of the skill and that it might need some looking into. Just like slow needed some looking into when you noticed it doubled your swing time.You're complaining about equally skilled opponents keeping a match going.
