Page 5 of 6
Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.
Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2014 3:59 pm
by
However,for casters like Faran and Blink, who pour hours into their characters to round them out in all these areas, their effort and the power they have achieved needs to be respected. I understand that there are broken aspects, including resist and damage ranges. These will get fixed. We will move on in the endless journey to balance out a game. But even after all this gets fixed, there's something that needs to be recognized: Mages are not going to be punching bags for melee classes. They are going to need to be approached carefully and with a bit of thought, just like any other leveled PC character should. Just because you have a big sword and a good number of CC levels, doesn't automatically entitle you to an immediate victory against a casting class.
All fixed by making one spell casting skill giving it the same stamina benefits every 5 levels.
Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.
Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2014 4:11 pm
by
Try this: Let's say you and Kaiah and Blink went on a hunt. Go together, but don't group up. Before you move, 'look' into your surrounding rooms. When you spot a mob, send Blink in first to catch the agro, then you and Kaiah can move in, hide, and SS or BS until you fail. Kill the mob, rinse and repeat
Given where most people hunt, this really isn't a sound idea. Statues and vampires both spawn according to people moving through the area. Multiple spawns are extremely likely in such a scenario, and without being in a group, we can't keep tabs on the other's health quite as easily without filling up the window with even more spam.
So if one person takes off suddenly due to low health, it kind of leaves the other two in a lurch. Especially if the one that had to run is the only one who can actually defend against vampires. (That happened once.)
The idea might work, in an area where mobs didn't appear only when people moved around in the area. However, if I want to hunt without a group, I'll just go alone. It's probably safer that way for everyone, and I don't have to worry about leaving someone out to dry.
Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.
Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2014 4:14 pm
by
All fixed by making one spell casting skill giving it the same stamina benefits every 5 levels.
As I said before, Staff has said no way, never, not going to happen.
Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.
Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2014 4:31 pm
by
If a mage wants to level their attack, they train their attack spells.
If a mage wants to level defense, they do have their passive shield block, but they either level shield or, slow (which is the more potent defense of the two) - or even CC if they want that little bit of hope with the RNG
If a mage wants to up their stamina for more casting, they can either train vigor or CC.
If a mage wants to up their utility, they can train portal, gate, or any of others they have.
Maybe I'm just crazy, but that actually sounds more appealing to me than being stuck with one skill for everything. Not only is it tedious, but basically my point is that we have no options as to what we want to train, because ultimately there's only one skill that matters for us right now, and we aren't allowed to focus-train 'complementary' skills because to do so abuses game mechanics, whereas a Mage has free range to train anything they want because a lot of their spells can be used out of combat and thus don't go against the CoC. It also means there's no diversity between melee classes beyond their AR/DR gains, whereas Mages can specialize in portals/gates if they wanted to (even if only for RP reasons), or be proficient in a blade and have higher AR/DR than their fellows like Blink, etc.
Try this: Let's say you and Kaiah and Blink went on a hunt. Go together, but don't group up. Before you move, 'look' into your surrounding rooms. When you spot a mob, send Blink in first to catch the agro, then you and Kaiah can move in, hide, and SS or BS until you fail. Kill the mob, rinse and repeat.
That's a decent suggestion, and I may try it at some point if Blink is willing IC, but buddy-training was by far the best method and most enjoyable from an RP perspective. I remain disappointed that it's no longer an option.
Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.
Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2014 7:44 pm
by
SilverShade wrote:Given where most people hunt, this really isn't a sound idea. Statues and vampires both spawn according to people moving through the area. Multiple spawns are extremely likely in such a scenario, and without being in a group, we can't keep tabs on the other's health quite as easily without filling up the window with even more spam.
When you fail your SS or BS, just group up on the 'tank', which was Blink in my example. After the mob dies, just ungroup and keep going. If you have to, hunt in the statues so you can utilize your parry.
Wren wrote:Maybe I'm just crazy, but that actually sounds more appealing to me than being stuck with one skill for everything. Not only is it tedious, but basically my point is that we have no options as to what we want to train, because ultimately there's only one skill that matters for us right now, and we aren't allowed to focus-train 'complementary' skills because to do so abuses game mechanics, whereas a Mage has free range to train anything they want because a lot of their spells can be used out of combat and thus don't go against the CoC.
Yes. Mages have many spells. They have the ability to sit in a room and train up their utility because it doesn't have a combat effectiveness. Even the one that does - elemental shield - isn't effective now, and even if it were, leveling it up in the current manner just helps to compensate that they need to raise separate spells to level certain aspects of their character. This is what separates a mage from a melee: the wide range of utility to level. The utility that melee receives is usually combat utility, and therefore needs to be leveled in combat. It's not that you can't focus train your skills, it's that you can't focus train them as fast as you'd like.
Wren wrote:It also means there's no diversity between melee classes beyond their AR/DR gains, whereas Mages can specialize in portals/gates if they wanted to (even if only for RP reasons), or be proficient in a blade and have higher AR/DR than their fellows like Blink, etc.
This diversity isn't there now because all of the classes are incomplete. Mages are a mixed bag, yes; they're supposed to be. As a melee class, you choose your specialization when you choose your class, so a warrior will focus more on front-line fighting, a thief more on tactics and guile, etc.
Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.
Posted: Wed May 07, 2014 11:23 pm
by
Hoping this won't be seen as beating a dead horse, but given staff is presently in a meeting I wanted to post feedback from some OOC PvP testing I've been doing with another player. I have permission from them to do so.
Health: 15/177 You are nearly dead!
Stamina: 118/125 You are barely winded.
This is the result of one of the fights pitting their level 11 sylph mage in cobalt armor, against my 60+ assassin in blacksteel armor, using a blacksteel weapon. Given the mage's level, there was no slow spell involved. You can imagine how it would have ended if there had been.
I won 4/4 fights, but in two of those he got my character to 1/3 her health, and in another he very nearly killed her, as shown. I've seen players of mages defend the work they put into their characters, and I respect that, but that argument does not apply in this case.
These results speak for themselves. I know melee damage ranges are in desperate need of tightening, so I hope this will put that way up on the priority list.
Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.
Posted: Wed May 07, 2014 11:36 pm
by
The fact that a character that was a sixth your level nearly beat you is a little silly, especially when there's such a massive difference in gear type and not just level alone.
From everything I've seen of mages and melee, spells are very consistent with their damage. If melee don't have tools to deal with casters, the least that can be done is to tighten the damage up. It's clearly been done with mages, so surely it can be done for those using weapons. I wouldn't mind seeing other classes get some more utility stuff added in to make them a bit more filled out.
It is what it is, though. I guess.
Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.
Posted: Wed May 07, 2014 11:45 pm
by
SCOFFS apparently you just don't appreciate the hard work it takes to get to level 11... especially level 11 on the third tier spell. It takes almost all of 24 hours... You have besmirched the name of mages everywhere by beating one. Let's see you do that to my elf who has 30 more hitpoints.
Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.
Posted: Thu May 08, 2014 12:04 am
by
The message is pretty clear, there's really no need to be sarcastic and rub it in.
Kudos to the elder mages who worked to get to where they are, seriously, I just don't get how/why the class can be that powerful so early on, especially against a character that's had many months of work put into them.
Re: Tell me again how weak mages are.
Posted: Thu May 08, 2014 1:18 pm
by
Teef wrote:SCOFFS apparently you just don't appreciate the hard work it takes to get to level 11... especially level 11 on the third tier spell. It takes almost all of 24 hours... You have besmirched the name of mages everywhere by beating one. Let's see you do that to my elf who has 30 more hitpoints.
I know, it's so terrible. My level 11 water mage has been spanking you for forever. Better write an expose about it on an IC forum after you complain about the very same things in more than three OOC posts. Better luck next time.
Onto some REAL concerns:
Wren wrote: I just don't get how/why the class can be that powerful so early on, especially against a character that's had many months of work put into them.
That is very aggravating, and it is just as annoying for actual high and multiple-leveled mages. A level 11 mage does maybe 2 points of damage less per hit than a level 80 mage. The ONLY difference is fairly minute, and that would be the fail/success rate. A high leveled mage has a much lower fail rate, but the fact that our damage does not improve at all I guess is there to balance us long-term. I suspect it's also a mechanically balancing technique for melee damage to be so sporadic and unreliable. So don't worry. It's all working as intended.
Shadowbane wrote: It is what it is, though. I guess.
Preach.