Page 6 of 8
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Sun Mar 06, 2016 1:22 pm
by
Exactly, the PC is 'special' so the rules for the NPCs is irrelevant to the discussion.
That Joe Shmoe the baker has only a 50/50 shot is irrelevant, other then to set a baseline point of reference.
We are talking about the egocentric (apparently for good reason) PCs and the rules as regards their ability to comprehend just how special they are to keep returning from the dead.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Sun Mar 06, 2016 1:36 pm
by
After 25 deaths standard odds would put you at a 1 in 3+ million individual.
A careless newbie could rack that up before getting to Pearl.
Assuming that is an average figure, and an accurate representation of how special we are.... given the 56 different names i have seen via login messages....the islands are home to almost a billion people.
Which seemed a tad inflated....
Edited for math.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Sun Mar 06, 2016 1:59 pm
by
I think you're thinking about this way too hard. They've put out how death is supposed to be taken and it's your job to RP it out, depending on your gods views, mixed with your own characters views. Maybe that will change a bit once priests can resurrect and commune with spirits, but right now this is how it is. So basically everything Kaiah said.
I'm sure if you go through the OOC meeting logs that were posted, you'll find whatever it is you're looking for.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Sun Mar 06, 2016 2:11 pm
by
The NPC actually isn't irrelevant. It is the average for PCs to be compared to. Very few people want to play a game where they are average.
PCs HAVE "died" in the past, mostly on the choice of the player. The reason we keep coming back is because the people running the game give us that choice, and very few people like starting over from scratch after establishing a character and spending time and game currency on it for the sake of advancement. It's the same reason we hardly have any class changes, because it costs almost the same.
Assuming that your god will always bring you back is one of the heights of arrogance. While there are a lot of arrogant characters and players, it is silly to assume someone doesn't eventually wear out their usefulness to their god. Thankfully, I don't get to make the rules for the game, because the consequences for things would be far higher and the rules a lot less flexible.
As a child, did you ever play acid tag or "the floor is lava?" The mechanics of the game were hardly unforgiving (no one actually died by acid or lava) and different people got to be "it" or lose all the time. It was almost entirely imagination based. A kid would take the game pretty seriously, to the point that tears and dissolved friendships weren't exactly unheard of. Same concept applies here. In an RP game with mechanics like this, you use your imagination.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Sun Mar 06, 2016 2:28 pm
by
I just think everything through.
If that is too hard, then you are correct.
I am extremely literal.
I expect things to make sense.
And i did mention that the baseline was an exception...
Your examples of a childhood game are fitting in that this is also a game.
But there was the added benefit of being able to 'win' those games.
They had a singular goal, and once it was clear weather or not that goal was met, the game was over.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Sun Mar 06, 2016 5:39 pm
by
Shadowbane wrote:Staff doesn't appear to want anything more serious than a time out with perks and the chance to lose skill gains, so really, that would have to be taken up with them.
Player characters make up a very small percentage of the game world's population. It's safe to assume that Pearl realistically would have a population of some thousands, not the handful of NPCs and PCs people see in the day to day. PCs are really the only ones who actually come back. So, the IC explanation for anyone returning from the dead is that their god decided to bless them that day, not that no one likes to go Ironman. The PC does more for their god than the NPC, so it stands to reason that the PC would be more valuable to a god.
There's more than one or two somber old ladies wandering the streets, or a few lavishly dressed merchants in King's Port. PCs are supposed to be your above average individual, for whatever reason, and NPCs fill everything else out for the common Joe. While we come back, they don't. They just get replaced by the next average schmuck.
I like a lot of your points however, I think you are assuming too much here. How do you know what the staff's plans are for death? The staff seems to always be working on updates/improvements, which could include changes to the way death is handled. Granted, beta is supposedly ending in September and you would think death would kinda be set by that point, maybe.
I like the priest resurrection idea that was brought up.
Stating that PCs are the only ones that are resurrected, whether or not that is mechanically true, should probably be handled by RP. As PCs we can easily RP that everyone gets resurrected by their god, we just don't see it, or no NPCs because as you stated, PC are "special" to their god.
Personally, I think it would be cool after a PC kills one to have the somber old lady or the lavishly dressed merchant resurrected in temples and have them wander back to their "zone".
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Sun Mar 06, 2016 6:08 pm
by
Snaek wrote:Spirits are working as designed. They can't pass through closed doors, so be extra suspicious and paranoid when discussing secretive stuff. Eventually priests will be able to detect spirits, so that will help out some.
This would be a big reason why I said this is what staff has intended for death, seeing as how they've basically said "working as intended" here. It has also been the one static and unchanging thing this game has had since day one. It has already been stated that death is serious, and resurrection isn't promised. When temple guards have been killed, in most temples, it was RPed that they were not brought back. I think there was a single exception made sometime last year, and live team contributed to that one.
As for comparing games, I was comparing seriousness and mechanics of the game. Winning and losing was never part of the discussion.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Sun Mar 06, 2016 9:11 pm
by
Permadeath is the ultimate loss, so it kinda was.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Sun Mar 06, 2016 10:26 pm
by
Permadeath will never be considered here, so it's a moot point.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Sun Mar 06, 2016 10:32 pm
by
Right, which leads back to my original question... how long does it take before my character can deduce this fact from empirical evidence?
It is all well and good to SAY we should fear death.
But when it is shown to clearly have no teeth...
There needs to be a believable IC reason that doesn't rest entirely on the OOC concept of suspension of disbelief.
I don't enjoy playing the ignorant fool.