Page 8 of 8
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Mon Mar 07, 2016 3:40 pm
by
Bocon's right on this. It's been outlined, we've said where to find it, and it's easy to find because those logs of meetings with the staff are kept in one place. Most of us aren't going to do the work for you, and it's probably safe to say that this conversation is done simply because the answers and explanations we've given you either aren't goo enough, or you really aren't here to learn or contribute.
If what's been said here, repeatedly, isn't enough substance for you, then there's really nothing else we can do. You'll have to find answers somewhere else, or find something that better meets your standards.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Mon Mar 07, 2016 4:17 pm
by
Snaek says to Trystan, "We've found it to be very discouraging to have death treated as if it is only a slight delay and nothing more, for everyone involved."
Bihi says, "I think you're trying to have your cake and eat it too. If you want players to take death seriously, you need to hit them with significant coded consequences."
Doxx says, "Regardless of the penalties players will treat death as an annoyance. I am a supporter of death penalties but truth be told I am one that sees them as an annoyance."
Gir asks Wren, "Though I agree in good and solid Roleplay, in a fantasy based enviroment so far removed from everyday life...what is realisam?"
Snaek says, "As a staff, we want to see it treated with more respect. That is not to say you can't RP as being above fearing death, but never should your character treat it as the OOC annoyance it can be, or as anything less than a possible one way ticket."
Gir says, "I agree, but in a world where the gods choose who to favor and things of the like, I see death as a big deal but at the same time my only point was I think people feel things should be treated like we do in real life...and sadly I don't see that as valid."
Bihi says to Snaek, "I don't think you can so easily separate RP and coded responses to death."
Wren says, "I guess we have different definitions of RP, then. I like to play my characters as if they are in fact people living in a world where bad shit happens."
Trystan says, "And some of us really don't care if bad shit happens."
Gir says to Wren, "I do understand what trystan is saying though, because if you see enough death you become numbed to it. the prospect lies more in the power that keeps folks teathered to this reality as snaek mentioned."
Wren says to Gir, "Yes, but not everyone has to be hardened and vapid. There will be characters that are numbed to it, certainly, I'm not saying there can't be. I just want to see some kind of acknowledgement towards the uncertain permanency when someone of note keels over."
Gir says, "Though again it leads to what is are reality of death, and the role are gods play keeping us in place."
Visyn says, "Here's the problem, you can get cut up to pieces in a fight but you don't roleplay each slash you take. It's not easy to RP this sort of stuff. I'd rather see someone not react than to react in a way that is unreallistic."
Bihi says to Yiri, "Unless there really is a chance of death being permanent, I just can't get into it: pretending something is possible I know isn't possible. I feel forced."
Meder says, "I think a lot of what we're trying to get at is having a RESPECT for death, rather than some sort of imposed fear."
Doxx says, "Actually reacting shocked or scared to a friend that dies is not realistic if that same friend died 3 dozen times and came back every time."
Meder asks Bihi, "But if I understand you right you're saying that the penalty helped you take death seriously in the past?"
Bihi says to Meder, "Oh yes."
Bihi says, "Staff and our fellow players pressuring us to play death a certain way is just a different kind of consequence. It's a legit means of producing different player behavior, but code might be a better approach."
Kaiah asks, "What about a stat decrease for a certain amount of time?"
Wren says to Kaiah, "It would enforce a sense of a weakened state, which I like. Going through death and having your soul stuffed back into your body would be an unpleasant and taxing experience."
Bihi says, "I think we all agree death is important and should have significant consequences in the game. I think we are arguing only on how to effect those significant consequences."
Snaek says, "We've spent the better part of an hour discussing this and I appreciate all the suggestions on how to improve death. However I can't stress enough the importance of separating your OOC knowledge of death from how your character will treat it. This is something that requires no penalties. Only imagination. You wouldn't be here if you didn't have imagination. Use it."
So i spend the better part of an hour scanning through this and gathering the salient points.
In the end It seems like the exact discussion we have been having here.
And it all boils down to the premise that the lack of permadeath is OOC knowledge.
Frankly, IC repetition contradicts such a premise, and everything based upon it is moot.
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Mon Mar 07, 2016 4:38 pm
by
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Mon Mar 07, 2016 5:20 pm
by
That^^^^^^right there is funny shit!
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Mon Mar 07, 2016 6:09 pm
by
Kody just died and got points added to an incredibly grueling crafting skill, making his total number of uses beyond the starting total for that level.
That's reason enough for me (the player) and Kody (the character) to avoid being so careless in the future.
-_____-
Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Mon Mar 07, 2016 6:20 pm
by
i never looked at those logs, they were before my time ...
Snaek says, "We've spent the better part of an hour discussing this and I appreciate all the suggestions on how to improve death. However I can't stress enough the importance of separating your OOC knowledge of death from how your character will treat it. This is something that requires no penalties. Only imagination. You wouldn't be here if you didn't have imagination. Use it."
Some ideas about death...
1. Mebbe have an RP guidelines text added to the Support tab? .. give everyone a heads up on this kind of thing.**EDIT - it's in the UserGuide (tyKody)
2. When you die, mebbe have your god/goddess give you a speech about death and how they may decide not to bring you back someday?
3. Have a loud THUNDERCLAP throughout the lands whenever someone dies? ... might make it seem more serious?
4. RP donating before a battle to help appease the deity in case you die, or have a small funeral/memorial for the one who has died
instead of just waiting at their temple for the lockout to expire?
For myself, Xiija is kinda a witch-doctor, so she would hate death, but have talismans to ensure her return, and use the time
of death to gather any knowledge she can. When her hunt-mates die, she will start saying prayers for them, or chants.. in hopes of
increasing their chances of returning?
Thanks to all for this discussion, i can't wait to try changing my RP a little

Re: Thief religion changes and class changing
Posted: Mon Mar 07, 2016 6:43 pm
by
Xiija wrote:
1. Mebbe have an RP guidelines text added to the Support tab? .. give everyone a heads up on this kind of thing.
You mean like this?
DEATH SYSTEM
[RETURN TO TABLE OF CONTENTS]
Death has become you.
Maybe you bit off more than you can chew. Maybe you fell flat on your face while jumping across rooftops, or plummeted from the skies because you suddenly forgot how to fly. Whatever the story is, life has come to an end.
You suddenly find yourself in a timeless void with but one escape: up. Next thing you know, you’re in the cemetery of your hometown and can’t remember how you got there. None of your senses work. You can’t speak. Even a ghastly moan won’t escape your lips.
You have turned into a spirit!
You are now separated from your body, wandering the lands unseen and without purpose. With any luck, your deity will deem you worthy of resurrection and reconnect your body and spirit at a nearby temple. The more death you experience however, the longer it may take for body and spirit to be reconnected. How many deaths will it take for your deity to decide you're no longer worth it?
While there is no permanent death in Shattered Isles, dying is not something to be taken lightly. Your character does not know he or she will always be revived. There should be some doubt as to your return. Death should be treated as if there’s a chance your deity may not find you worthy of resurrecting, and your spirit would be forever lost to wander the world. To help enforce this, some penalties have been put in place. For starters, the more times you die, the longer it takes for your body to be restored. More importantly, with each death there is the risk of having uses added to a skill at random. This penalty is a percentage of the current uses left in the selected ability.
While harsh at times, these penalties are a light repercussion compared to the complete loss of a character. Permanent death or perma-death is something we will never support in Shattered Isles, unless self-imposed by a character.
The good news is there is no corpse or possessions to retrieve. Once your spirit and body are reconnected at your temple, you are once again ready to face the world. Your corpse does not linger behind to be looted. You do not have to go back to your room of death to re-enter your body or collect your things.