[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
http://www.shatteredisles.com • Sneaking
Page 1 of 2

Sneaking

Posted: Tue May 13, 2014 11:22 am
by
If I am not hidden but I successfully sneak into a room with aggressive NPCs, they automatically start attacking me. Is this intentional? I would have thought that a successful sneak would at least give a few seconds of NPCs being unaware so you could hide or keep sneaking past them.

Re: Sneaking

Posted: Tue May 13, 2014 12:32 pm
by
The NPCs don't trigger off whether or not they see you enter a room. They're actually on timers and they periodically check the room for visible characters. That's why it's possible to walk into a room and have a couple seconds to hide before they attack you.

Re: Sneaking

Posted: Fri May 23, 2014 12:14 pm
by
I've been playing around with sneaking quite a bit lately. I'm concerned that I get apparent success and fail messages. I don't know if it's appropriate for me to know my character failed. Would he or she realistically know this? I think that's a valid question. If you try to sneak into an area with a deer, then yeah, you fail and the deer immediately looks in your direction, or you inadvertently step on a brittle branch and realize the jig is up. But with sneaking up on another PC the possibility exists that the target would realize the presence of another and choose NOT to react. So I don't know if these success and failure message are always appropriate or not. I might suggest the following: the current messages as they stand when one obviously passes or fails (based on how the code decides this) and a third: "you think you may have sneaked in successfully" when one is within like ten percent (either way) of the pass criteria.

Re: Sneaking

Posted: Fri May 23, 2014 12:39 pm
by
In most cases you would notice when your attempt to be stealthy didn't succeed - either because you made noise, or because someone saw movement and turned their head. I think it would be up to you and the PCs around you to act accordingly. For example, if Wren snuck clumsily into a room I'd probably emote her as knocking over a vase stand or something to that effect. I don't personally feel a third/undetermined message is necessary. This is first and foremost a roleplaying game, so it's our IC responses that really determine whether a situation is realistic or not.

Re: Sneaking

Posted: Fri May 23, 2014 12:40 pm
by
All I want is for sneaking to go back to costing 2 ftg rather than 4 D:

Re: Sneaking

Posted: Fri May 23, 2014 12:43 pm
by
Yiri wrote:All I want is for sneaking to go back to costing 2 ftg rather than 4 D:
Ugh, yes. Please.

Re: Sneaking

Posted: Fri May 23, 2014 3:10 pm
by
Wren wrote: I don't personally feel a third/undetermined message is necessary. This is first and foremost a roleplaying game, so it's our IC responses that really determine whether a situation is realistic or not.
I want to emphasize how important a consistent, realistic implementation of code is, even while recognizing how difficult that project can be for any MUD to achieve-- if it ever can be. Granted there are situations were code can never meet our expectations of "realism" and we as players need to 'leap' beyond it with consistent and realistic roleplay solutions. That being said, I'm going to contend the exact opposite of what you contend: it is first and foremost the CODE that decides if a situation is realistic or not.

No matter how realistically I roleplay a character swaggering around the game world as its greatest warrior, the code will easily allow others to demonstrate otherwise.

The best RPI MUD environments I encountered-- SoI, Armageddon, Harshlands-- all imposed very sophisticated and realistic code limitations on characters (including permadeath). Playing there has led me to the conclusion that it is good (realistic) code that promotes and nurtures good roleplaying. The more 'clunky', inconsistent, and unrealistic the code is, the more a player becomes frustrated with it, the more the immersion is compromised and the more they are tempted to be twinkish about exploiting it to achieve their desired ends: commanding their characters towards unrealistic behavior. I include myself in that assessment. (The moment I realized my character did not have a coded need to eat or drink in Shattered Isles, I stopped worrying about it.)

In the example of sneaking: if I sneak into a room and KNOW I failed the attempt, I'm going to attack my victim immediately-- expecting the same from them. (It's a classic "prisoner's dilemma" I have to be twinkish because I can't be sure my opponent isn't going to be twinkish.) But if I don't know if I succeeded in entering the room clandestinely, I'm faced with a "better" dilemma: listen to the conversation to possibly learn where the loot is hidden, or attack immediately? And my opponents are handed their own new dilemma: pretend I'm not there when they know I am, and provide me with false and misleading information in their conversation, or attack me immediately?

Realistic code promotes realistic roleplay.

Now Shattered Isles is a newer endeavor, and we should all feel obliged to cheerfully roleplay through breakdowns in code. But I think the ultimate goal really must be the most realistic and immersive code possible.

Re: Sneaking

Posted: Fri May 23, 2014 3:30 pm
by
As much as I wouldn't mind a "realistic code" for the game, we don't currently have the capabilities of coding it. So unless you've got some stellar coding skills and want to volunteer, we won't be getting that advanced just yet.

That point aside, I like the idea of players having the responsibility of roleplaying. It sets the mediocre roleplayers apart from the exceptional ones. Additionally, someone who has training in stealth movements will know when they messed up. They'll know when their performance was unacceptable. I, as a player, do not want to be wondering if my character failed. I have no interest in sitting there OOC looking like a tool because I had no way of knowing whether or not my character succeeded in something they are trained to do. If my character fails, I'll react IC accordingly as I always do. A smoother code would be wonderful, but the best RPers I've seen in this game have been the ones that can role with clunky programing.

When it comes to a game, some realism has to be sacrificed. It's fantasy, for one, and because of that I can get away with wearing metal armor and not suffering as a stealth based class. Two, as much as I like immersion, I dislike being inconvenienced in a game. I play it for fun, not to smash my face against my keyboard in frustration.

To make it short, I also do not think a vague feedback message is necessary to force realism on people playing a fantasy game. Let them show people their awesome acting and writing skills instead. That's always cooler to see.

Re: Sneaking

Posted: Fri May 23, 2014 3:47 pm
by
Consistency is very important to us in our approach, but as far as sneaking goes the messages are working as intended. This is part of the balance between realism and playability that you spoke of, and in this case that message of failure is there because it's also determined in other ways such as a reveal notice or simply checking your score command.

Re: Sneaking

Posted: Fri May 23, 2014 5:49 pm
by
Shadowbane wrote:
To make it short, I also do not think a vague feedback message is necessary to force realism on people playing a fantasy game. Let them show people their awesome acting and writing skills instead. That's always cooler to see.
I agree with most all your preliminary contentions, but I can't agree with your conclusion. I just need to push it to it's logical extreme: would it be more fun if you just typed "kill bear" and the code eliminated all the vague feedback told you immediately if you won the battle or the bear did, then imposed the consequences? The 'vague feedback' imposed by the random number generator in the combat code creates the suspense and excitement in the encounter-- and if done right-- coaxes players towards realistic behavior in their characters: do I fight, or flee? What's the (coded) consequences of fleeing to the next room?! That's good immersion; and good roleplay.

Suspense-- not having immediate and complete knowledge of a situation-- is a critical aspect of storytelling and roleplay. Designers can use code to promote suspense in a game, or not. But again: realistic (in this case suspenseful) coding promotes realistic (suspenseful) roleplay.

For example: we have food and water in the game, and we have cooking skills. But when there is no coded hunger or thirst, we don't eat or drink: we don't waste our coin on it, except a few of us on rare occasions. And we don't value good cooks the same as we do good armorers (who make products that do provide coded attributes). That's a natural and expected reaction to that situation-- that's human nature. If the designers want to promote realistic cooking and eating and drinking in the game, the solution is NOT to pester us about it, to spy on our characters and expose our inadequate roleplay. The solution is to change the code. If a good meal gave our characters a temporary boost in stamina or strength (which is realistic) things would change in a hurry. We would know the best cooks and the best taverns and we would frequent them and cater to those cooks before every expedition. (That being said, I do commend the designers for what is happening at the moment: they don't have the resources yet to create a complex eating code, so they just leave it up to us as individuals to do whatever we think best.)

Good code promotes good roleplay.

When I perceive the attitude: "we don't need coded solutions, we just need to demand higher standards of roleplay from each other" I always sigh. It encourages the designers to neglect the most powerful tool in their box to achieve those exact ends.