New Armour Values and Changes

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

I’d like to address the recent armour value changes which have started to take effect and are being implemented slowly (as far as I can tell at this moment only to recent custom chest piece orders - four, I think, from what I've seen in-game? -, shop armour and a ‘fix’ to one single piece of older custom armour). I wanted to post this publicly because it doesn’t seem this is a topic on which the community was informed at all - outside of one assist answered -, and it’s a fairly large, unbalanced and game-altering change to throw out there with near complete silence. Especially when it’s considered there is no set day for all previous orders to come in and get changed, and it seems only one old armour changed despite a character with another set of previous settings standing right beside the person who had theirs ‘fixed’.

For those of you who don’t think about mechanics much or have little interest in them at all, I’d like to lay out the way armour operates if you aren’t aware, just so you have some understanding of how it works (if you don’t already) and how it’s been changed (as explained in an answered assist). Armour in Shattered Isles works like it does in previous games a lot of people here are familiar with. It’s got a base percentage absorption attached to it and then it has a static number value - basically making it so your high-end armour isn’t letting damage from extremely low level MOBs make its way through. It’d be a little strange to see a forest critter which does 2-4 damage still doing 1-2 through top tier armour. There was a noticeable change after the recent armour orders from July, an assist was sent in and it was passed along that the formula for armour was going to be switched around - static was going to be absorbed first, followed by the percentage which was a reverse of the previous which has been in effect since October.

In theory it isn’t a big change - somewhat noticed, but easily adapted to -, unfortunately in practise it seemed not to have been tested and there’s some major problems that come with it.

If you’ve never had a piece of custom blacksteel or arcsilver, then you might not know it used to protect roughly 50% plus the static number. A static number being a set number of damage it’d protect against no matter what. Materials like fur and cotton, they’re at the bottom end of the material list, something which was probably noticed when you’ve upgraded from the academy armour to custom armour or even steel. Steel used to be roughly 40%. Obviously, these values are subject to change, yet the change we’ve seen implemented I don't think was thoroughly tested. I sincerely hope this result wasn’t intended and I’ll get to that now.

I don’t want to give exact damage values taken because I don’t think that’d be fair to other players, so instead I’m going to give the difference/spread in points of protection given.

After some testing over the week, this is what was found out. Naturally, give a point or two in either direction for the sake of safety and the RNG.

Here were the results of the test (against a high damage attack for clarity’s sake, these were not low numbers being thrown out to skew the results):

Fur armour: Protected roughly 2 points more than unarmoured.

Thoraxium armour (said to be above steel): Protected roughly 1.5 points more than fur armour and 3.5 than unarmoured.

Steel armour: Protected roughly 1.8 points more than fur armour and 3.9 than unarmoured.

Arcsilver armour: Protected roughly 2.2 points more than fur armour, 0.72 points more than thoraxium, 0.36 points more than steel and 4.26 points more than unarmoured.

As you can see, thoraxium, steel and arcsilver (and since arcsilver and blacksteel have the same protection values, it can be assumed blacksteel can be included, in addition to any other materials in the stores or sold at the armour peddle during the festival) protect near the same with miniscule differences between them.

The reason I believe this is to be the case, because whilst I am to understand the intended change - as related in answer to an assist - was to make it so the static absorbed first and then the remaining damage was divided by the armour’s set percentage absorption I think the game’s mathematical properties are doing something completely different. I believe it’s taking the static number which is now set first and instead of taking a percentage of the remaining damage, the game is dividing the static number before it spits out how much damage you’ve taken, and that’s the result. The static number divided by percentage is the total you protect for overall. Not both as it used to be when the formula was percentage and then static.

If you look at the numbers and go through the static value set to them (for example, blacksteel/arcsilver have 5 points set to them) then 5 divided by %50 equals 2.5, but the game rounds numbers which would take it up to 3. Or roughly in the area (taking into account rng variations between tests) of the difference between arcsilver armour an unarmoured. The same applies for the static numbers of fur, steel, presumably thoraxium and all the other store bought armours.

I cannot accept that this was the intended change. The protection value differences are minimal at this point, and would make it pointless and a waste to purchase higher material tiers because they are protecting less than a point more than store bought steel in this system.

I highly encourage staff to please, please be consistent in testing changes - no matter how small or significant, and this one is incredibly significant - before throwing them out to the players. If it’s going to be thrown out to the players, please have the decency to inform them in matters such as armour protection values being changed, in particular if it isn’t readily tested beforehand. If it’s where the core absorption or damage settings, matters of a mechanical nature, are being changed in a huge fashion please set a date to change every person’s old piece at the same time, so half the game isn’t protecting such a hefty number compared to newly purchased or singularly ‘fixed’ pieces. It isn’t cool nor fair to any player to have untested mechanical changes thrown into the live world with little or, as more often is the case, nary a word given to them so they might know what to expect and give proper feedback. Lack of testing and chosen silence hobbles the playerbase in its entirety in PVE/PVP.

I’ve mentioned it before, but there is a test server and there are willing players to go to that test server or even an isolated area within the live server. They’re willing to offer their time, energy and feedback in a way which will allow skills, abilities, weapons, armours, effects and any number of mechanical changes to be documented and properly assessed before potentially throwing the live, interactive world out of balance. Throwing something out and hoping it isn’t buggy or that you’ve guessed it’s going to work correctly isn’t fair to anyone, and it’s going to keep causing problems down the road. Obviously, issues arise with even intensive testing but it isn’t being done here. Please give the players that chance so it stops making the live world unbalanced for people who may or may not get caught up in the thrown net of untested changes.

For a final number to consider - after extensive hunting with both unarmoured and new!arcsilver numbers shown:

A greater vampire hit an unarmoured person up to 35.

A greater vampire hit an arcsilver armoured person up to 32.

A three point difference.

Thank you to those of you who read.
User avatar
Wren
Conclave Representative
Posts: 343
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2013 11:31 pm

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Wren »

The only thing Wren got from the most recent order was a vambrace, so I can't offer any comment on old armor vs new, but if this is the case then that's pretty lame for the people who forked out the doubloons for it this time around. Don't get me wrong, totally understand the reason for raising the price of custom orders, but it's not cool for newer characters to have to pay more for armor that protects significantly less. Hopefully this will get looked into!
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
User avatar
Snaek
SI Staff Member
Posts: 828
Joined: Wed Aug 25, 2010 4:36 pm

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Snaek »

There's a few assumptions here, well more than a few, but overall it's a valid topic. We've never been happy with armor protection. We've tried static and percent based protection but both individually simply could not work. Static discourages players from feeling like they are contributing to a fight, and percentage based is hard to get a feel for any real difference between armors unless you're taking really big hits. To get that difference, the mid to high end armor becomes much too powerful.

As to changing the way they work, we actually "fixed" the way they work. Static was suppose to come before %, but the orders were reversed early on and not caught until around June. This was tested and confirmed to be a way to lower protection slightly without causing a major impact on a system that is eventually going to have to be rebuilt from the ground up. Around this same time, we were faced with a major overhaul of custom armor due to the wear location fiasco which required us to shift them all one spot to make room for vests. Since then we've adjusted both worn slot and protection values for shops, treasure, and custom armor. Your assumption is that we only addressed that of the player who reported the difference when in fact we had been addressing this issue long before that. There's no doubt armor out there that still needs to be adjusted for both reasons but we aren't having a separate event to find them. The majority of players have reported them much as the player mentioned above. Others were spotted at OOC events. We have consistently kept to these standards through the summer.

Pricing is a separate issue that I like to think everyone expected to happen. You've all experienced the increase in custom pricing. Shops are next. You only see the end result in the price changing, but behind the scenes an entire catalog for pricing has been created and each custom order event leaves us with more additions to make. Until a creative player asks for something that hasn't been made before, we're not always sure what the specs will be. This system of pricing has vastly improved life on our end and I think it has stabilized the economy a small amount. Granted that is an impossible challenge, but we are seeing people get out and hunt or craft more to make up the lost income. From our end, that is a good thing.

Armor isn't likely to see a drastic change until combat is addressed. Armor is very dependent on this future update and until that is addressed, we can't really know or test armor the way we'd like. That's a sad state to be in but it's where we are. Thanks for bringing it to our attention and we will definitely increase our efforts to level the playing field when it comes to older custom armor. (computer is at 6% and can't find charger!)
User avatar
Snaek
SI Staff Member
Posts: 828
Joined: Wed Aug 25, 2010 4:36 pm

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Snaek »

Charger found.

Question I did not address was about how the current setup does factor damage absorbed. It does not divide the damage by the static number. It's a fair assumption, but in the formula it does rely on the % sign to distinguish between the two, so unfortunately this is not the answer.

A combat update is the only real solution. Armor protection values are inline with what we want. Minus some minor tweaks to be made to account for the addition of new non-metal armors, the problem largely lies with other factors into how damage is calculated. With these working properly, so too will armor.

As stated above, your concern over some people still having armor that isn't inline with these newer standards is valid and something we've continually addressed for awhile now. All armor is cataloged so we are able to go back through them. It just takes a lot of work as I'm sure you can imagine. Thanks to the players who have reported issues with their armor, our workload isn't as bad as it could be. What we aren't doing is singling out certain players by adjusting their armor while playing favorites with others. It's simply a matter of time as we get to them all on top of our other demands.
User avatar
Snaek
SI Staff Member
Posts: 828
Joined: Wed Aug 25, 2010 4:36 pm

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Snaek »

...and since it comes up from time to time, armor durability is a separate issue we are still looking into. It's important to note though that metal is going to outlast non-metal. Granted cloth shouldn't be breaking as quickly as it does, but something definitely can protect the same as another material without being as durable or heavy. These are balancing differences between materials.
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

There's several inaccuracies in the first response, but I will get to it later today.

I only have a side issue with older custom armour not being changed at once across the board, and it's compounded by how drastic a change this is. Additionally, I have no problem at all with increased prices for any and all custom gear - whether it's for a mechanical or RP purpose. In fact, I've long argued for any type of increased costs in a way which wouldn't damage new players.

My issue is that the changes have made every single piece of armour, except perhaps the lowest three tiers, effectively have the same protection rate regardless of material. It is will all honesty said that arcsilver/blacksteel is supposed to essentially have the same absorption value as steel? To in all truth protect barely more than if you're unarmoured?

If so, what's the purpose behind that reasoning? There'd be no benefit to purchasing higher tier armour if this is the case outside of the few added DR points. Those are appreciated, but they're so miniscule they don't make much of a difference with how much AR/DR is available to melee/physical ranged in the system.

If there isn't going to be another drastic change in armour until combat as a whole is addressed, then wouldn't it be in the best interest to keep armour as how it was - until the time comes to overhaul it all - where there is noticeable differences between materials? This gives players goals to work toward and opportunities to look forward to in terms of peddles/orders. It also doesn't hinder people who prefer solo hunting in relative and appropriate hunting grounds. But right now as it is in a comparison with custom armour, store bought armour and peddle purchased armour - they are all protecting the same, the differences negligible and so minimal it's almost assuredly variations in the RNG.
Bocon L
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 214
Joined: Sat May 31, 2014 5:04 pm

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Bocon L »

I personally have no issues with how armor is right now. With such high AR/DR gains for most classes, I was already under the impression that the game was more about defensive skills, than it was about protections from armor. With how easy it is to obtain a max set of armor, I'm happy that the protection values aren't that high. Playing a preist, it's nice to know that I'm not going to be replaced by high armor values combined with wound mending.
However, I am a bit disturbed that the thoraxium armor isn't better than steel, when it was advertised as being just under blacksteel. Even if it's just a point or 2 better than steel, it should be, because that's what we were told it was. I bought that set of armor because it was the right color and looked very intimidating. The protection value was a second benefit, especially if casters will be restricted to wearing non-metal.

The game is in beta and with that there's going to be a ton of changes. If something is implemented(announced or not) and you think there's a bug or something wrong, submitting a report and moving on is the best course. All of the part time staff have tons of things to do and I'm sure hunting down every piece of old armor is not high on that list. It's not going to break the economy if a few pieces still exist, especially since most people are just making money through crafting and not hunting right now. Not everyone can play 12 hours a day, though I bet a lot would love the chance to.

Considering that nothing really breaks and has infinite repairs attached to it, it makes peddles far less interesting IMO. Once you have your armor and clothing set completed and a max weapon (far, far, far harder to obtain), there's really no reason to go, other than to be social and see what other people buy. So there's money constantly flowing into bank accounts, but no drain for it. I feel this is a far greater issue for the economy than armor being changed or not changed.
User avatar
Wren
Conclave Representative
Posts: 343
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2013 11:31 pm

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Wren »

While I understand that the Priest class needs to be able to perform a function not be so easily replaced by armor or wound mending, I have never and will never agree with intentionally nerfing armor to the point that people with different playstyles can no longer effectively hunt without one. There are people who enjoy solo hunting, there are people who play Assassins that are already at a significant disadvantage when it comes to hunting high-end mobs without a Warrior and/or healer, and then there's the clear divide of the playerbase to take into consideration, and that the Priest count is heavily to one side and almost non-existent on the other. I appreciate Blink hosting hunts every week, a lot, but this should not be the only way for myself and new characters to be able to hunt with any amount of efficiency if they can't find a Priest of their own to come along with them everywhere. It would not be the least bit fair.

That aside, again, increasing the cost of armor is completely justified, but reducing the protection value of the armor to where it barely protects better than steel, or NOTHING? No, I sincerely hope that this is just an error and not the intended result. The fact that it's 'easy' to get should not factor into this seeing as the frequency of armor orders and peddles is determined by staff, not the players. I would rather see them happen every few months or more, and be able to have functional armor than every month or two and have armor I spend considerably more on that barely makes a difference against store-bought pieces.

Just my 2 cents.
Wynestra Renley
Emissary of Temple Itzal.
User avatar
SquallScribe
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 165
Joined: Fri Sep 20, 2013 9:51 am

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by SquallScribe »

The issue is not that armor has changed - not entirely. The compounded issues are:

1. There was no communication about a desire to change armor protection values
2. There was no transparency regarding current 'old' armor protection values and desired change of 'new' values
3. There was no testing done to ensure 'new' armor values are working properly vs. 'old' armor values
4. Current 'new' armor values are not working as intended (They are not just 1-2 points difference from previous armor values. In fact, blacksteel and arcsilver appear to be protecting for ~20% overall instead of a previous ~50% overall protection value.)
5. Old armor values still exist in the game at the same time as new armor values
6. Armor protection values that were advertised as comparable to specific armor materials at the latest peddle are in fact NOT comparable to those specific armor materials

None of the statements above are assumptive. They are based on the available facts, and a series of testing.

The fact that staff has decided to change armor protection values is not in itself the issue; the issue is that there has been NO communication about these intentions, and no transparency regarding how they will change, why they are changing and what they are intended to change to. Likewise, holding both a custom armor order and armor peddle between such changes makes it difficult for players to know what they are actually getting when they spend their time, money and effort attempting to purchase what they think will be good armor, which in practice turns out to be poorer than 'old' value steel.

In regards to playstyles and mechanical balancing: There are a number of race/class combinations that do not have two defenses, or a defense set that procs against more than one type of damage. Assassins are one, so are mages. In the case of mages, they will almost always be hit by a melee character that is attacking them - even if they spend the ungodly amount of time required to slightly improve their DR with unarmed combat. Armor does not detract from the talents of a priest, nor make them useless in PVE or PVP, even with the 'old' armor values. A level 10 priest in healing can out-heal vampire damage even when someone is wearing 'new' value armor - or even no armor at all. Likewise, one should not be required to have a priest along to hunt - it will certainly make things more efficient, but the highest level armor available, costing well into the 10,000 doubloon range should not protect for only ~4 points more than unarmored and require that one hunt with a priest to have any chance at all of not dying in 4 - 6 hits.

Finally, the change in armor values is premature, considering announced patches and fixes such as tightening melee damage range, spell evolution, templar and priest additions and updates, and poisons are in-progress coding projects that will require armor to be balanced yet again.

Thank you.
User avatar
Swamp Ape
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 341
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 8:50 pm

Re: New Armour Values and Changes

Post by Swamp Ape »

SquallScribe wrote: A level 10 priest in healing can out-heal vampire damage even when someone is wearing 'new' value armor - or even no armor at all.
I would like to challenge this statement as being untrue. There is no way a level a 10 priest in healing will out-heal vampire damage. Especially with no armor. This is a very bold and irresponsible statement to make without some kind of proof to back it up. Show me an unarmored level 10 priest out-healing a vampire. I am significantly higher level than level 10 and I'm not even sure if I can do that effectively. I have not tested it so I am not sure if can or not.
Locked