Shadowbane wrote:For example. Alexis can hit me for more than 12 points fairly regularly now. I'm still doing 2 through 5 between the decent strikes I sometimes get purely because of my high combat level.
This has been rehashed over and over again, and the sole fix to this is to tighten melee damage ranges which I'm certain we've all advocated for, and a fix which I hope comes soon because it will be a deciding factor on other balancing - such as armor values, priest curses/miracles and spell evolution. Also, choice of weapons against certain classes will be more effective. Additionally, you'd be doing other numbers of damage as well, not
only up to 5 during a match. It's more likely that you're seeing widely variable ranges of 2 - 15 points of damage output vs. arcsilver or blacksteel that hasn't been tampered with, which is the issue with melee damage range, again. The string of those variables you get at any one time is also wholly dependent on the ever soul-crushing RNG. Mage damage range is working in that the bottom range improves, but top end never does. I've been doing "decent" to "solid" strikes for about 40+ levels now. That lack of improvement is also frustrating.
Shadowbane wrote:It's entire classes by themselves, because they're either missing several skills that could give them a better chance than just the pew-pew CC filler they've got now, or because they have a tighter damage range and therefore can deliver more damage than others.
Again, damage range tightening has been advocated for. There are unfortunately a number of other things that keep going in before this crucial fix, and some of them seem premature. I think a lot of the mechanics issues will be on the right track to getting solved when damage ranges and evolutions are in place. And entire classes are exceptionally lacking - such as barbarians. No one's tested them much and they've been given almost no attention. Priests also require more complexity, and I hope the priest update gives them more combat utility in the form of buffs, debuffs, curses and miracles. And scouts. Poor, poor scouts. Good with bows but that doesn't mean much in a game without units of movement and tactical range.
Shadowbane wrote: There are still competitive aspects in an RPG, such as PvP, and being able to actually compete and win a match is a part of playing.
You can compete and win a match. But you won't be able to do so against everyone, or with the same tactics that might work against one person. Once melee range is tightened, you'll see a better return against casters, but you'll still see issues when taking on min-maxed melee combos like Gavial and Vukasin warriors/assassins simply because you have a character with low strength mod. And humans are traditionally 'average' in every game. Not really good at anything, but not really bad either. This will become more apparent when ranges are fixed, and casting mods are implemented.
Shadowbane wrote:No one has ever played a game with the intent to feel like they're losing or coming up short. Games are meant to be fun, and if it's not fun, people tend to go find their fun somewhere else.
Games are meant to be fun, and in MUDs like this, there exists a number of ways to derive that enjoyment which is not solely based on mechanical superiority. Likewise, you control a lot (not all) of the enjoyment you can get out of the game based on your play style, interaction with others and how you choose to react to things. Isolating your character when you don't want to play that sort of game can be taxing, but the growth and development of character is always something to look forward to in roleplay.
Shadowbane wrote:Until classes are completed and combat between different damage types is balanced better, OOC games will probably be more popular than the IC ones, unfortunately.
I feel there are a number of reasons people end up not playing in PvP games - and they're not all solely based on damage output and mechanical balance. Some people dislike others knowing their levels or combat competency. Other people just derive no enjoyment at all from PvP. The main point remains that the
majority of classes in this game are not complete, and a number of mechanical balancing issues persist - of which damage range tightening is one of the most crucial to fix, as it will determine a number of other balancing effects.
Also, super sorry to Visyn for sort of derailing this thread. OOC games will be great. Please host them. <3