Priest discussion and feedback

Discuss your favorite races, ask the questions you've always wondered about, or just follow along in the conversation. This is the place for everything that is Shattered Isles. Keep your debates civil. Trolls will be executed on sight.
Wonton
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 30
Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 8:35 pm

Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Wonton »

Hi, Halisera's player here. I thought I'd open this form to collate any feedback and discussion about priests, seeing as there was quite a bit of discussion about them from the armor changes thread, and this seemed like a better place to explore the topic.

I'll begin by offering my general observations of the class so far.

AR/DR progressions
Weapon: 3/4
Unarmed: 2/3

I was actually pleasantly surprised to see the class have a 3/4 progression. I briefly played a mage and a scout before settling into a priest. So, for reference, Mages have a 3/3 and scouts a 6/6, so a 4 in DR actually puts them in a nice median between a mage and a melee(ish) class. The AR seems about right to me, though I could see them also having a 2. But there is currently too much in the air at the moment - what with all the updates coming - to even begin tweaking Priests AR (or DR) progression, and I don't think it's really a problem where it's at now.

I'm going to guess that unarmed progressions are the same across the board for all classes, and that one would train it (most likely mages as the DR gains are the same) so they didn't have to carry around a weapon, and with a 2 it doesn't seem like it'd be a viable option for attack. Which is fine.

An idea though: set priests to have 2/4 UC, 3/3 CC. I say this because it'd allow for a subtle difference between RP styles and how a character builds their priest. Do they forego weapons and make a more defensive priest, or practice CC and become more effective in combat? Granted, at 3/3 a priest's combat options are still limited - but then again, mechanically speaking, combat isn't the class' role. For those characters who want, say, a battleaxe wielding harbinger of doom priest, they'd likely be more interested in getting that AR, and the Templar class would probably better suit such a playstyle. As I said before though, I think there's too much going on to even consider altering something like that, so I'm just musing out loud.

Prayers
Currently, my arsenal of prayers fits what I expected a healing class to have. Health and stamina healing, along with a buff, and an equalizer (revoke: to remove buffs on enemies, or debuffs on allies - if they exist/when debuffs are added. I haven't seen any). I brighten to see curses added to the priest's utility belt, though I'm not sure yet what kind of effects they have.

Mechanically speaking, I see the priests as the healing class, but also as the main support class, meaning I think they should have more buffs as well as the Curse debuffs added to their class skills down the road. So 'Blessings' and 'Curses' to aid allies or hinder enemies - all in exchange for their stunted damage output.

I can't comment much on failure / success rates, but it seems sometimes that I fall in to a failing groove, where my prayers will fail 5 times or more in a row before returning to a more normal fail/success rate. It seems to happen every so often when it just gets caught in a fail block, so I'm not sure if that's something odd in the mathematics of the code or not.

Armor and priests
Since this was brought up in the Armor thread, I figured I'd open up some discussion for it here.

Personally, I don't think Armor detracts from the value of a priest, as long as the protection values don't skyrocket too high. Some skills rise stamina, but I haven't seen one that rises HP, so characters will always have a finite health reserve even as enemies grow stronger. From the armor post, Nikolas said someone got hit for 35 from a vampire, so perhaps there will be, say, "sandworms" that hit a character for 40, or 50. Even at 50% reduction, that's 20 - 25 damage each hit, out of a reserve of 185 (for elves - less or more for other races). At an average of 20 dmg per hit, that's 10 rounds you could survive at minimum, misses or defensive blocks aside, meaning you'd better be able to kill the worm in 9 hits before you have to flee.

I understand that protection values that are 'too high' is a matter of perspective, but that's a mechanic I think should be discussed in the armor thread Nikolas restarted so we keep the two topics separate.

Anyway. New or old armor values, I don't think it has much impact on a priest's utility in a group. Of course, without a group, we can't hunt in many places for doubloons, but I'll talk about this more in my next section.

Speaking of...

The Priest's Moolah

I, too, have noticed the means of income for priests is stunted by the fact that we can't really hunt well in a place we can't utilize our holy strike or turn, and I count only three hunting areas for that: Skeletons, Crypts, and vampires. The training curve isn't so bad from Skeletons to the crypts. I was able to effectively hunt in the crypts when I reached 10 heal, 5 strike, 10 CC, and 10 turn, which wasn't hard to get to. After repair costs, I was making around 500 doubloons every few hours, and I'd likely make more if I just attacked using Holy Strike instead of turning first (But turn also raises a priest's stamina, so I like to train that up too :3). From what I've noticed, however, it's going to take a long moment from now before I can effectively hunt at Vampires, so I'll be staying at crypts while other characters move on to more lucrative hunting grounds.

---SIDE NOTE---
So this is interesting to consider: having turn raise my stamina makes me want to use it more. Kind of a 'duh' thing to consider, but what I think the take away here is that positive reinforcement works better than punishment. Take Elder Scrolls as an example. In Oblivion, wearing armor gave you less spell efficiency, which is the way games normally balance spell casters. But that's boring and chokes individuality. So what'd they do to fix it? Let let characters wear all the armor they wanted, but gave them an incentive to not wear armor. Mage robes increased magic recovery, and, at times, reduced their casing costs. It gave mage-style characters a reason to not wear armor, instead of punishing them for wearing it. It was a refreshing mechanic to see, and I think aspects of that kind of class balancing could be used in Shattered Isles going forward to make for an interesting and unique game.
---/SIDE NOTE---

So, if not hunting for coin, then what? Crating seems to currently be the only reliable means of income for priests, and it seems to be what most players are focusing on now. Unfortunately, we can't utilize our skills that way, but that's the same for any class during ccrafting as it doesn't seem to be combat intensive. However, for those priests who don't want to have a crafting aspect to their RP, and who don't think they make enough from hunting, I'm not sure what else there is. I guess you could always send the offering basket around at temple meetings.

Thing is, though, priests don't have a lot they mechanically need to spend money on. The best armor or weapon doesn't help us heal better. Granted, the better the armor, the better we stay alive, which is only a plus, but it's not as critical to a priest because we can heal away the pain. A shiny weapon isn't a bother either mainly because a bone dagger or a death blade with both give us the full 4 DR per level, and seeing as we'd likely need double the levels to be on par with a melee class, attacking doesn't seem to be the rout we'd take in battle, not when we'd be busy healing anyway. A better weapon may help us hunt better, true, and help offset our steep hunting curve, but it's still not apart of the class' core mechanics. Now, that aside, we still want to buy shinny stuff for our characters for RP reasons, and that's well and good, but speaking strictly mechanically, steel-grade weapons and armor would likely suit our purposes just fine. Armor, as I said, is a slight exception to this, as it increases our survivability and allows us to be a sort of tank; couple better armor with better weapons and we can hunt better, which is a plus, true, but it still won't help us heal better. There's an idea though: 'weapons' that improve some aspect of the 'casting' classes. But that's neither here nor there right now.

If we're patient enough to wait for custom orders, we could likely just order the weapon/armor that we needed. I'm guessing armor and weapon orders are few and far in between, so we should have plenty of time, even hunting just in the crypts, and even if no crafting is involved, to raise money to purchase a custom piece.

All that to say even though we have a stunted doubloon intake, it doesn't appear that we particularly need all that many doubloons - at least the doubloons necessary to out bid someone at a peddle for that one weapon / armor piece we need to improve how our class functions. This is all perspective though, I know, and it does kinda stink not to have the same, smooth hunting ground graduation as the other classes. But that stems from not being able to do damage, which is a necessary counterweight to healing, I think, so it might have to be something that we live with as a class, and knowingly trade for the power to restore.

Thanks for reading if you got all the way through! These are just my thoughts, and I'd like to know how other priests - or anyone, really - see the class developing in the context of Shattered Isles.

Thank you much!
Halisera's Player
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

Wonton wrote: Prayers
Currently, my arsenal of prayers fits what I expected a healing class to have. Health and stamina healing, along with a buff, and an equalizer (revoke: to remove buffs on enemies, or debuffs on allies - if they exist/when debuffs are added. I haven't seen any). I brighten to see curses added to the priest's utility belt, though I'm not sure yet what kind of effects they have.

Mechanically speaking, I see the priests as the healing class, but also as the main support class, meaning I think they should have more buffs as well as the Curse debuffs added to their class skills down the road. So 'Blessings' and 'Curses' to aid allies or hinder enemies - all in exchange for their stunted damage output.

I can't comment much on failure / success rates, but it seems sometimes that I fall in to a failing groove, where my prayers will fail 5 times or more in a row before returning to a more normal fail/success rate. It seems to happen every so often when it just gets caught in a fail block, so I'm not sure if that's something odd in the mathematics of the code or not.
I think one of the biggest issues for priests right now (an issue which effects mages, too) - outside of the lack of additional prayers of any kind - is that healing prayers level off for the most part pretty early on. This'll be address in the upcoming caster evolution, hopefully, but it's probably discouraging for casters of any kind, or in this specific review priests, to see minimal returns/gains over the course of ninety levels. So whilst at its current rate it can keep a group properly healed simply due to loose damage ranges, if those are ever fixed priests will probably negatively impacted. Depending on which is fixed first. Either of those being fixed, however, will also probably make priests feel like much more 'necessary' addition to parties for higher hunting areas (even though every group hunt would want one now, regardless). All this considered, the RNG blocks of failures probably compound the issues.

For different kinds of buffs and debuffs there was a thread a while back with some good ideas tossed around by current and former players alike. I think for a debuff something that came up - if I remember - in a conversation between Faran, Wren, Loriel, Kschilan and I want to say.. Kaiah and Draven's persons is the idea of an atrophy debuff. It'd lower strength and DR for example, maybe it'd be possible to throw dex in there. That'd make a priest a boon in both PVE and PVP outside of healing, but without doing any damage to the point where they'd be able to 1v1 KILL someone else in any quicker order. But speaking of AR/DR..

I think the priest AR/DR progression is about right, though it's odd to me they'd have more DR than say a mage, but it isn't a game breaker or something overly significant. Yet in talking about buffs, debuffs, AR and DR it has to be considered that even though DR buffs are in-game right now, they're for the most part of little value besides something else to cast. They add between 20-30 DR which is negligible when you realise how much AR physical classes get. I'm hoping if spell evolution ever goes into effect, or even before then perhaps, that we'll see casters get (de)buffs more along the lines of 150-200. Fatigue debuffs would also be a bonus, and obviously these have all been talked about before in other threads, against either caster or melee. If caster modifiers are ever put into place, a debuff from a priest that might act as some type of "corruption of the soul" to bring down those caster modifiers - or even all racial modifiers across the board - could be something that'd be extremely helpful.

It'd also allow for more variety in the spread of hunting areas made available in the future. As we all know there's only a few right now, but as there's growth and the implementation of new prayers it'd be nice to see how many different kinds of undead hunting areas there might be able to be opened up. Which would, I'd think, increase the fun of priests in hunting whether in groups or solo.

Lack of money sinks is probably for a different topic.

Ultimately I'd think it'd be best if priests remain as a healing/support class only, as I don't think it'd be fair for them to have any huge increase in damage against players. This isn't to say it should remain that way in hunting - though I don't think they should ever be able to solo with the same efficiency and speed as a high level damage class - as mentioned above. Nor is it to say as you brought up and I touched upon that they shouldn't have plethora of utility spells in the forms of debuffs and buffs to help add a necessary dynamic and depth to the playability of the class, and to feel as if they've served some purpose outside of solely healing.
Bocon L
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 214
Joined: Sat May 31, 2014 5:04 pm

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Bocon L »

I guess I'll put in my 2 cents before the clergy patch hits this month or next.
AR/DR:
It was nice to see that they get a 3/4 progression. I only raised HtH and thought that it was standard across the board, so that's a pleasant surprise. Good info.
I'd be more inclined to support a standardized progression. That way, it opens up the option to pick HtH or CC. I don't know many people who wouldn't pick the most defensive choice, since I only knew of 1 other priest who used naturals to attack, instead of spells.

Prayers:
The log from the OOC spells meeting has some things in it about some new proposed priest spells. Thinks like element absorption spells, resistance lowering spells, and spells that would make you take damage instead of your linked target. I'm personally hoping for a HoT and some kind of ablative/absorbtion shield.
I'm in total agreement with being a support class. We just need hunting areas where our support is needed and have them be worthwhile money wise. It's why most people swapped over to crafting. Crafting has surpassed the money making ability of the old hunting grounds. So until more worthwhile places are opened, people are going to craft.
If we do get monster debuffs, they have to be worth casting. So something like atrophy would have to lessen damage enough to make up for casting, say, 1 heal, or it's not going to be efficient or worth casting.

God, I'm so glad I'm not the only person who is experiencing the chain fails when casting. Failing my level 1 healing spell, 5 plus times in a row, on a regular basis, at my level, is horribly embarrassing. Especially as the representative of Pyrous. Having other players see "You pray to Pyrous for _____, but nothing happens", chain failing, makes you look like a complete joke. It's the sole reason I stopped going to the hunting parties.

Armor:

From what I understand, all casters will be unable to wear metal armor if they want to successfully cast spells.
This has been pretty standard in almost every MUD I have ever played. Personally, I think only warriors should get the privilege of wearing the best metal armor, since they are supposed to be tanky. It would be lovely if they had taunting skills to back that up though.
The fact remains, however, thay any skill, armor, or spell that reduces or stops incoming damage, reduces the need for healing. That is not up for debate, it's simply what it is. I hope we can all agree on that.

With that said, I think armor abortion rates are too low as it is now and I expect that once new, higher level hunting areas are put in, that armor values will change accordingly. I'd love to see a nice balance for armor, so people can still solo, but still require healing assistance for group hunting areas. It's not an easy task.
I'd also like to see wounds play more of a role than they do now.

The only thing I can think of that would work with your elder scrolls armor idea, would be lighter armor with enchantments that boosted your casting mod. Or extended your curse time, or your pulsing heals tick a few more times, or gave you some kind of bonus to turning success. I have no idea how hard that would be to code in though.

Money:

Crafting. There's just no other option if you want to make the most money for your time. We just kill too damn slowly with our DD, and turning is extremely unreliable as to which outcome you'll get when it actually succeeds. Hunting parties are still far inferior for time spent. We just need updated hunting areas for everyone.

Side Stuff:

This is going to be a make or break patch for priests. At least mechanically speaking. I can still sit by a fire and craft all day if I wanted to and run temple meetings, regardless of how shitty they are.

Unfortunately, I imagine that this feedback is too late, as the patch is probably really close to being done. I highly doubt that it will be pushed back due to any new ideas that have been brought up here. But it's nice to talk about it regardless.

Edit: This should probably be moved to the player feedback folder.
User avatar
Kiriath
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 79
Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2014 2:35 am

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Kiriath »

I hate to put in my thoughts here, primarily because I don't understand most of the mechanics discussed. (I've never played WoW and the MUDs I have played, I've mostly ignored mechanics in favour of rp.)

That being said, I do understand, and I do like the idea of casters, either divine or elemental, not being able to wear metal armor. To me that means that there will have to be some other means of protecting the healers. I hope to NEVER be involved in PvP, mostly because I've spent so many years in various games helping new players that the thought of attacking one squicks me a bit.

Personally, I'd love to see magical robes and things. Clerical garments full of divine protection in rich fabrics of lustrous weave. But mostly I want something that will keep Kir alive so she can find a safe place to hide, since she couldn't hit the broad side of a barn in combat. Slippers of clerical retreat? ;)
Kiriath Windrose, Chatelaine of the Temple of Aerthane
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

If there's going to be a move to make it so casters in Shattered Isles cannot wear metal armour, then the following must be considered:

1. Are there still plans for a functioning tact and ranged system? If so, how soon will it be available?

2. Are absorbs and ablations spells/prayers still in the cards?

3. Will other classes such as thieves, assassins, scouts be only able to wear more flexible, light armour?

Those other games a lot of us have played succeeded in having casters wear lighter, less absorption armours because there were tact systems, binds, flight, DR spells which added a sufficient amount in addition to the aforementioned absorb and ablation casts. In Shattered Isles it makes more sense if we're not going to have those available, for whatever reasons, for casters to be allowed to continue wearing the same protection values as melee. Because of the low DR and one defence, they're hit at an extremely high rate without chance for escape (unless we're speaking of running). One might argue in turn that the spells will always hit a melee/other caster, but they also do deal with fail rates and one day, hopefully, a functioning resist system which is planned even if it is not (or was not) working as intended.

If for an aesthetic approach people don't want casters to wear metal armours, that's understandable. But I think the questions above have to be considered and the long-term thought of before advocating for casters to not be able to wear the same protection values as melee in this particular game.
User avatar
Snaek
SI Staff Member
Posts: 828
Joined: Wed Aug 25, 2010 4:36 pm

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Snaek »

The end goal is to balance armor in a way that will encourage casters to wear non metal armor to maximize their spells or prayers. We don't plan a flat restriction, but instead benefits to wearing lighter gear. We've taken small steps that will lead to this one day, but not until a lot of other issues are addressed, many of which have been mentioned above. It wouldn't be fair to implement these changes now with so much else being subject to change.

The feedback is appreciated. Yes we are close to the clergy update, but that doesn't mean your feedback can't still factor in.
Trystan
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 134
Joined: Mon Jul 14, 2014 12:15 pm

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Trystan »

Another 2 cents...

AR/DR progressions and armor both relate to the overall balance equation that’s top secret, so I can only hope that they’re where they need to be.

Earning for a priest should average from 600 to 1200 gold per hour solo hunting, depending on level. I’m guessing that mages are the same and I’ve no idea what crafting or melee earns, maybe somebody would be willing to share the ranges? Group hunting almost seems completely RP at this point, there’s no real advantage to it. What I don’t understand is when Blink & Trystan hunt together, that both of their earning averages drop.

Turning is the priest’s most powerful weapon against the undead, couple that with Holy Strike at a similar level and an argument could be made that they’re twice as good against the undead compared to any other class. There really needs to be another hunting area between the Crypt and the Southern Outpost, the grind required in the Crypt to make it to vampires almost drove me insane, but it’s obviously doable, if not mind numbing.

The current utility prayers seem to have little value at the moment. If poisons and diseases become more prevalent in the game, then maybe they’ll serve a purpose beyond fixing a hangover.
At the current danger level of the game, I don’t see a need for the priest class. There is no hunting area or mob that’s off limits without a priest and any malady can be dealt with by a potion and resurrection is probably some distance off.

To staff: When thinking about the armor issue, please keep in mind the Defend ability a priest has and the need to take the occasional blow.

With all that said, it’s a fun class to play and I’m looking forward to the eventual class update!
Nikolas Suyessod
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 184
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:49 am

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Nikolas Suyessod »

Are you saying priests should be able to earn six hundred to twelve hundred per hour in an ideal setting, or they're currently making this much?
User avatar
Kiriath
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 79
Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2014 2:35 am

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Kiriath »

I can assure you I make nowhere near 600/hour.
Kiriath Windrose, Chatelaine of the Temple of Aerthane
Trystan
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 134
Joined: Mon Jul 14, 2014 12:15 pm

Re: Priest discussion and feedback

Post by Trystan »

I'm saying that they currently can make that. The 600 starting is not for a fresh PC, but once in the crypt and with a focus on earning and not skill building, yes, 600 isn't unreasonable.
Post Reply