[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
http://www.shatteredisles.com • Closed Conclave Meeting Notes 3/29/15
Page 1 of 1

Closed Conclave Meeting Notes 3/29/15

Posted: Fri Apr 03, 2015 11:22 pm
by
These are the notes for the closed Conclave meeting that took place on the twenty-ninth day of the third month.

Emissaries Clarveu, O'Hara, Fairuz-Taqqi, Bouldermoore, Renley, Eldur and newly appointed Sarantis took their respective seats and eagerly awaited the arrival of the King. His Majesty showed interest in the law proposal submitted by Blink Walkabout, and so it was decided that this would be where the night's discussion began. Each representative stole a moment to re-read the proposal prior to commenting, save for Emissary O'Hara who was quick to point out that she would not be looking to alter any of His Majesty's laws.

Attempting to lead her peers into discussion, Emissary Renley asked what their collective thought surrounding the proposal was, and if there was in fact a desire to discuss and refine it with intentions of voting favorably, or deny it and move on in order to save time. Emissary Eldur commented that while he liked the idea, he considered it an incomplete thought, and that it seemed to favor criminals while failing to represent any true sacrifice. The assigning of tasks to the individual in question, a term written on the proposal, was deemed a potential waste of time for law enforcement to oversee, but it was observed by Emissary Fairuz-Taqqi that this might prove a better use of said time for a handful of marshals to see to it rather than have dozens running from one end of the city to another in pursuit of a single goblin or sylph. In summary, many of the suggested terms were reviewed, debated and defined in further detail, but ultimately it was decided that this would need to be handled on a case by case basis rather than apply the same rules and terms to all. Emissary Fairuz-Taqqi stated that the time and resources would be spent to help reform and show forgiveness to some in the hopes of preventing repeat offenses in the future, thereby reducing the amount of chaos the marshals may face.

The King stated that if it were Conclave's intent to weed through the criminals and decide which can again contribute to society, without interfering with the knight marshals, then he would accept their judgement in most cases. A tardy Emissary Tietjen then arrived at the meeting, and was quickly brought up on the current topic. After adding his opinion to the mix, that this would provide an opportunity for collaboration between Conclave and the law of the knight marshals, a vote was cast on whether to take the process on as a new responsibility for those of the table.

The vote was as follows:

In favor: Emissary Fairuz-Taqqi of Kaleith, Emissaries Eldur and Sarantis of Pyrous, Emissaries Renley and Bouldermoore of Itzal, Emissary Clarveu of Aerthane, and Emissary Tietjen of Tetherias.

Opposed: Emissary O'Hara of Astraeva.

The motion passes as modified.

Discussion then turned to the request submitted by Suyessod-Taqqi to have the terms of his pardon lifted, thereby removing the the ban on anyone of his name holding a position within the city. Emissay Tietjen commented that while he has no ill will towards the man or those of his lineage, the ban was in exchange for his life and continued citizenship in the city, and without good reason is not keen on reversing it. Emissaries O'Hara and Clarveau soon asked if all were ready to call a vote, but Emissary Fairuz-Taqqi and Eldur as well came forward wanting to comment prior to the vote. Both offered valid questions and points in favor of the request, in the former's case highlighting how much one can change in a year's time, and that Suyessod-Taqqi has abided all laws since his pardon as well as contributed to the betterment of the city's economy during this time.

The vote was called again shortly after this, and it stands as such:

In favor: Emissary Fairuz-Taqqi of Kaleith, Emissary Renley of Itzal, and Emissary Clarveu of Aerthane.

Opposed: Emissary O'Hara of Astraeva, Emissary Bouldermoore of Itzal, Emissary Tietjen of Tetherias.

Abstain: Emissaries Eldur and Sarantis of Pyrous.

With the vote resulting in a tie, the king then spoke up after observing the process, stating that with so many issues on the table, he secretly wished for the opportunity to cast the deciding vote. Questioning how it might look for Conclave to first overturn his order of execution, then remove the only form of punishment applied, he said it seemed only fair that he remove this burden the Emissaries' shoulders and take it upon himself to lift Suyessod-Taqqi's remaining ban. Addressing Emissary Fairuz-Taqqi, he stated that the man can never return to his previous position within the king's guard, but otherwise the request has been passed.

With a new record of three applicants at once to go over, Conclave's attention shifted to reviewing their applications to decide which would be asked to jointhem at the table. The king expressed that he knows not of these individuals, and that he was confident Conclave could decide on his behalf. After thanking them all for the glimpse inside their procedures, the king said he looked forward to what they are able to accomplish by bringing willfull workers back into the city, and took his leave. The first to be called to a vote was Menfanous Hammersmith for the 2nd seat of Astraeva. The voting was as follows:

In favor: Emissayr O'Hara of Astraeva, Emissary Fairuz-Taqqi of Kaleith, Emissary Clarveu of Aerthane, Emissaries Renley and Bouldermoore of Itzal, Emissaries Eldur and Sarantis of Pyrous, and Emissary Tietjen of Tetherias.

Most impressively, all were in favor with no vote against or abstaining. Mr.Hammersmith's application has been approved.

The next applicant was Rochiriel Azahar for the 2nd seat of Tetherias. In similar fashion to the previous applicant, little remained for discussion and many were prepared to vote immediately. The votes cast were:

In favor: Emissary Fairuz-Taqqi of Kaleith, Emissaries Renley and Bouldermoore of Itzal, Emissaries Eldur and Sarantis of Pyrous, and Emissary Tietjen.

Opposed: Emissary O'Hara of Astraeva.

Abstain: Emissary Clarveu of Aerthane.

Mrs.Azahar's application has also been approved.

Last to be tended to was the application submitted by Blink Walkabout for the 2nd seat of Aerthane. Emissary Clarveu was quick to praise Mr.Walkabout's contributions to the city and Conclave, and comment that he represents a larger portion of their temple and that those voices should be heard as well. Emissary Tietjen voiced concern over the Avardi's flighty nature, how he will conduct himself in a position of responsibility, and that his actions would reflect directly upon all of Conclave even if they might wish otherwise. Emissary Renley mirrored Emissary Tietjen's doubts and added a few of her own in regards to Mr.Walkabout's tendency to ignore, alter or miss facts when making judgments. She claimed that she is not forgetting the contributions he has made, but judges an applicant based on potential and suitability more than their list of deeds. Emissary Eldur told Conclave how Mr.Walkabout has been a friend since he arrived in Pearl, before expressing concern over his ability to remain focused on the position, and that he has seen first-hand the damage he is capable of.

Emissary O'Hara chimed in as well to say he has spent much of his time running the Conclave around in circles, to which Emissary Tietjen agreed with. Emissary Sarantis suggested that perhaps his place is not at the table, that he may actually better serve Pearl and Conclave by not claiming a seat, as he has done thus far. She later added that in the short time she has been around him, he has claimed to be many things, following Emissary Eldur's brief comment that his main concern is whether or not Mr.Walkabout would take the position seriously enough.

Quiet throughout much of the discussion, Emissary Fairuz-Taqqi weighed in to say she holds some of the same thoughts and concerns as the others, that she believes Mr.Walkabout has the right motivation, has shown invaluable dedication to improving the lives of his fellow citizens, but that she does not know if he wants to be an Emissary and all it entails, or if this would be where his energy was best spent and channeled were he to gain a seat. With this, it was called to a vote.

In favor: Emissary Clarveu of Aerthane, Emissary Bouldermoore of Itzal, Emissary Tietjen of Tetherias, and Emissary Eldur of Pyrous.

Opposed: Emissary Sarantis of Pyrous, Emissary O'Hara of Astraeva.

Abstain: Emissary Fairuz-Taqqi of Kaleith, Emissary Renley of Itzal.

Despite the ample concerns and doubts voiced by near all present, Mr.Walkabout's application has been approved.

This concludes the results of the meeting.