[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
http://www.shatteredisles.com • player death
Page 1 of 2

player death

Posted: Thu Jun 11, 2015 2:57 pm
by
Just wanted to throw an idea out to you:

Once characters make the ferry trip to Pearl, I want to suggest character death have much more 'grave' repercussions.

Characters die and drift to their temple-- as they do now. But they do not reincarnate there. Instead, they stay there in "limbo" or "purgatory." Priests may have a means to 'seance' the character (if they are on line) or leave messages for the dead character at the altar (if they are not on-line). Otherwise, the character is stuck in their temple, unable to be seen or talk to other characters.

Characters can get released from purgatory and start playing again by the following means:

Every player-- while alive-- can make contributions towards their respective religions/temples. These contributions please the respective god and give that player a 'score.' The more they give, the higher their score. When a player dies, his or her friends within the religion must make a combined sacrifice (or not) through a "prayer for the dead" to bring the dead player back to life. If successful this would involve some very real sacrifice (like lowering some randomly chosen skill by a percentage.) The more friends step up to participate in the revival, the less each individual friend would suffer a loss. The more the dead character contributed to the temple while alive, the less each individual would suffer a loss. Any character can go to their respective altar and make the "prayer to revive the dead" once a deadline is reached, all players who made the prayer get the "hit" to their skills and the dead player is revived.

We could also make provision for a dead player to be revived by another religion's followers: in that case they would switch religions if revived. If when the deadline is reached more players from other religions made the prayer for the dead at their altar than did the players from the dead character's religion, then the dead character would be revived by the other god, the newly resurrected character would switch religions. This would be "painful" for the members of the other religion unless the dead player was clandestinely making contributions to that religion instead of, or in addition to, his or her own.

Examples:

Through their life Character A gave 120 thousand worth of goods or coin to the temple. 100 thousand is the (secret) threshold. One comrade of player A prays for their revival. The comrade loses one point of random skill (the minimum) and player A is revived. 20 thousand is 'rolled over' into Character A's account for use in their next death.

Stingy Character B only gave 50 thousand to the temple over their life. Five characters pray for Character B's revival. Each loses 10 points from a random skill to make up the shortage in Stingy Character B's contributions.

The King dies. He has made many a contribution to Astraeva. Two followers pray for his revival in that temple. However, five Itzal followers pray for his revival. If-- at the deadline-- more folks of another religion gave the prayer than in his own, the King is revived as a grateful follower of Itzal, and all five Itzal supplicants lose 20 skill points each, to make the 100 points necessary for revival. (While if the Astraveva had the majority, they'd only pay one point each, presuming the king was generous with his religion in his lifetime.)

The details of the point system are arbitrary. But the mechanics are the important part.

The hoped-for effects are (1) make players more respectful/fearful of character death. (2) Greatly increase their loyalty to their religions and co-religious comrades. (If you piss off the other members of your religion, you might not get revived at all, and need to start a new character.) (3) suck some of the excess money/resources out of the game, making the economy more realistic. (4) Make it difficult but possible to change religions. (5) Make character death an 'event' for political/religious intrigue and alliance building, especially concerning more prominent characters. (6) Create opportunities to play out "noble sacrifices" where one beloved player is revived by a grave sacrifice of one or two others.

Re: player death

Posted: Thu Jun 11, 2015 7:27 pm
by
I like the idea.

I'm not for anyone losing "skill" points though. It would make more sense that each person would lose "devotion" points with their God/Goddess for bringing anyone back to life. "Devotion" points being obtained through devoted roleplay and donations etc.

It would cost more to bring back someone not of your particular religion.

In order to change religions I would think the player being brought back to life would need to agree with and role play any change in religion. I am not for a forced change simply because more players from a different (competing) religion prayed for a player's character to be brought back to life.

Priests obviously should be required for any ceremony bringing anyone back to life and it should not necessarily be easy to do. Death is supposed to be traumatic.

I'd like to hear more ideas on this.

Put your 2 cents in folks.

Flynt's Player

Re: player death

Posted: Thu Jun 11, 2015 8:24 pm
by
I'm not keen on being stuck dead because I don't have anyone of my faith online, or in the case of Itzalites, in existence. That's unfair to players who have characters following a less popular religion (it's all Aerthane and Tetherias these days, after all), and pretty much screws everyone else. This is a small game. Besides that, I don't see how relying on other players to bring you back to life can build a good community. Getting better gear as a new player is nearly impossible at peddles with the characters we have.

I am also not a fan of permanent character death if the player of the character doesn't choose it. It's one thing if I decide to kill Kaiah off and not go along with a revival after she's killed or executed. It's something entirely different if the players of the turncoat characters she sees around her decides for me. No thanks.

Also, no forced religion changes just because someone else from a different religion prayed for you. That's just asking for trolling, and if Menfanous died (for example) Kaiah wouldn't be able to pray for her friend because that would result in her god claiming him against his will. She wants to bring strong, willing, devoted followers to Itzal, not weak-willed people who were conned or bought.

I do, however, want the option to chose the time of my rebirth. Rping as a wraith or ghost could be pretty cool, especially if a priest (or someone extremely religious) can see and hear you. Instead of being auto-rezzed, maybe have a command like 'resurrect' or something could be used to begin the resurrection process.

I would love to be able to donate directly to my character's god, gain favor, and use that favor for being brought back to life or prayer induced boons. My main character is extremely religious, and regularly prays and leaves money or valuables at her temple altar. I'd love to see characters gain something substantial for devoting themselves like that.

Re: player death

Posted: Thu Jun 11, 2015 10:30 pm
by
Yeah, that's really rough on religions that don't have large numbers, that's the biggest problem with it working right now. It kinda favors both numbers and temples that happen to have a wealthy member or two.

I'd like to see quests that let you help your religion though, not necessarily just handing over gold.

I'm all for ghost roleplay. I've enjoyed some of my times spying as a ghost. It'd be cool if priests could talk to you. It wouldn't be quite as isolating if some characters had powers that let them interact with ghosts.

Yeah, and elemental elves can't change gods, ever. Humans apparently can, as it's been done, and I imagine you need Creator help.

Re: player death

Posted: Fri Jun 12, 2015 1:11 pm
by
Shadowbane wrote:I'm not keen on being stuck dead because I don't have anyone of my faith online, or in the case of Itzalites, in existence. That's unfair to players who have characters following a less popular religion (it's all Aerthane and Tetherias these days, after all), and pretty much screws everyone else. This is a small game. Besides that, I don't see how relying on other players to bring you back to life can build a good community. Getting better gear as a new player is nearly impossible at peddles with the characters we have.
I'm really concerned about how the proposal would effect people with few other faith followers. I was thinking that the investment necessary to revive someone be proportional to the number of active players of that faith, but how does one define "active player"? If we could all come to some consensus on what an active player is (certainly mine is a poor example of such) then I think that issue could be fixed. (People who have made a contribution to their temple in the last month?) On your question of community building: if I want to bring my character back after death, I'll need close friends I can rely on to sacrifice for me if I do die. The best way to create such friends is by being a good friend to them while alive. But it doesn't help me much in that regard to be a friend to someone of another religion.
Shadowbane wrote: I am also not a fan of permanent character death if the player of the character doesn't choose it. It's one thing if I decide to kill Kaiah off and not go along with a revival after she's killed or executed. It's something entirely different if the players of the turncoat characters she sees around her decides for me. No thanks.
The point of the threat of permanent character death is to add a whole new aspect of fear and realism to role play. Bihi might recklessly go after Yiri in the game without regard for his own safety, because I (who control Bihi) know I can just revive him in a few moments if I get Bihi killed. If I don't have that reassurance, I probably would be much more afraid of Yiri, and my roleplay will be more realistic for it.
Shadowbane wrote: Also, no forced religion changes just because someone else from a different religion prayed for you. That's just asking for trolling, and if Menfanous died (for example) Kaiah wouldn't be able to pray for her friend because that would result in her god claiming him against his will. She wants to bring strong, willing, devoted followers to Itzal, not weak-willed people who were conned or bought.
I saw forced religion changes as mostly affecting prominent NPCs in the game. It would also be a very difficult and costly process: not something that appeals to trolls. But I saw lots of opportunities for voluntary religious changes: visiting and donating to the targeted temple, letting close friends of that temple know they need to pray for you there if ever you die: A long, and risky process. For example. Giel might decide he wants to convert to Seren's religion. He'd need to put a lot of effort into cultivating friendships among those of Seren's religion, contributing to that temple... a long term roleplay vector for him. No zeal like that of the converted, they say. So it might be fun to watch Giel cater to the new faith in a way that might even irritate the old-timers.

For me, right now this game seems too one-dimensional: spam killing to boost stats seems the dominate activity. I'm trying to dream up new aspects to broaden the kinds of stories we tell here.
Shadowbane wrote: I do, however, want the option to chose the time of my rebirth. Rping as a wraith or ghost could be pretty cool, especially if a priest (or someone extremely religious) can see and hear you. Instead of being auto-rezzed, maybe have a command like 'resurrect' or something could be used to begin the resurrection process.
I agree. I'd even advocate for a "purgatory" area be built just for the 'dead.' Someplace where you might even acquire a few unique "skills" having to do with once being so close to your god. However I understand how swamped the staff are as it is.
Shadowbane wrote: I would love to be able to donate directly to my character's god, gain favor, and use that favor for being brought back to life or prayer induced boons. My main character is extremely religious, and regularly prays and leaves money or valuables at her temple altar. I'd love to see characters gain something substantial for devoting themselves like that.
Bihi too.

Re: player death

Posted: Fri Jun 12, 2015 1:24 pm
by
Blink wrote:Yeah, that's really rough on religions that don't have large numbers, that's the biggest problem with it working right now. It kinda favors both numbers and temples that happen to have a wealthy member or two.

I'd like to see quests that let you help your religion though, not necessarily just handing over gold.

I'm all for ghost roleplay. I've enjoyed some of my times spying as a ghost. It'd be cool if priests could talk to you. It wouldn't be quite as isolating if some characters had powers that let them interact with ghosts.

Yeah, and elemental elves can't change gods, ever. Humans apparently can, as it's been done, and I imagine you need Creator help.
My best idea for equality between religions at the moment is to keep a running tab on how many contributed to their temple in the last month. When you die, some base number is multiplied by number of 'active followers' and that number is used as a target for a resurrection. But yes. It's something that must be addressed.

In the past, I kind of made my own 'quests': bringing stacks of raw materials to the prelate. Such quests can be organized entirely by players.

Re: player death

Posted: Sun Jun 14, 2015 4:04 pm
by
ditchhook wrote:I'm really concerned about how the proposal would effect people with few other faith followers. I was thinking that the investment necessary to revive someone be proportional to the number of active players of that faith, but how does one define "active player"? If we could all come to some consensus on what an active player is (certainly mine is a poor example of such) then I think that issue could be fixed. (People who have made a contribution to their temple in the last month?) On your question of community building: if I want to bring my character back after death, I'll need close friends I can rely on to sacrifice for me if I do die. The best way to create such friends is by being a good friend to them while alive. But it doesn't help me much in that regard to be a friend to someone of another religion.
That would be great, if making friends IC in Shattered Isles meant anything. Because convenient friends is a trend in a game like this, and conflict is encouraged in spite of friendly interaction, some of SI's characters can't actually count on anyone no matter what they do. It's just the nature of the game. Those of us who play antagonistic characters are usually left to fend for ourselves.

If there are only two active characters in a religion, then what? Or, at one of the extremes, what if they both die (accidentally or otherwise)? Sounds like a good way to put someone in a bind.
ditchhook wrote:The point of the threat of permanent character death is to add a whole new aspect of fear and realism to role play. Bihi might recklessly go after Yiri in the game without regard for his own safety, because I (who control Bihi) know I can just revive him in a few moments if I get Bihi killed. If I don't have that reassurance, I probably would be much more afraid of Yiri, and my roleplay will be more realistic for it.
If someone requires game mechanics to make their RP realistic or believable (treating death seriously, considering certain people likely threats, eating bad food, etc. etc.), then it's not the game that needs something, it's the player. The point behind roleplay is to put yourself in a different role. You are acting. If you cannot act convincingly and you use OOC knowledge that affects your character, such as knowing the worst that might happen to your toon upon death is a couple thousand skill uses tacked onto a random skill, then the issue actually isn't game mechanics, it's player ability to separate themselves from their character and not metagame.
ditchhook wrote:I saw forced religion changes as mostly affecting prominent NPCs in the game. It would also be a very difficult and costly process: not something that appeals to trolls. But I saw lots of opportunities for voluntary religious changes: visiting and donating to the targeted temple, letting close friends of that temple know they need to pray for you there if ever you die: A long, and risky process. For example. Giel might decide he wants to convert to Seren's religion. He'd need to put a lot of effort into cultivating friendships among those of Seren's religion, contributing to that temple... a long term roleplay vector for him. No zeal like that of the converted, they say. So it might be fun to watch Giel cater to the new faith in a way that might even irritate the old-timers.

For me, right now this game seems too one-dimensional: spam killing to boost stats seems the dominate activity. I'm trying to dream up new aspects to broaden the kinds of stories we tell here.
There is a process required for changing religions in the game in an IC manner. Nikolas has done it. How the character does it is ultimately up to the player and the nature of the character, and if making generous donations and cultivating friendships is part of it, great. However, that doesn't mean having however many active characters of a religion praying for their return to life should be what does it. Have it as part of the transition story, that would be great, but as a mechanic? That's what it sounded like to me, and I don't believe it would serve well as a game mechanic.

There are a lot of stories being told by various characters, it's really a matter of either watching or being around to witness it. I think you'd be surprised what other people might be up to. I know my own character is busy, despite staying low and even being absent entirely.

Re: player death

Posted: Mon Jun 15, 2015 1:41 pm
by
Shadowbane wrote:
If someone requires game mechanics to make their RP realistic or believable (treating death seriously, considering certain people likely threats, eating bad food, etc. etc.), then it's not the game that needs something, it's the player. The point behind roleplay is to put yourself in a different role. You are acting. If you cannot act convincingly and you use OOC knowledge that affects your character, such as knowing the worst that might happen to your toon upon death is a couple thousand skill uses tacked onto a random skill, then the issue actually isn't game mechanics, it's player ability to separate themselves from their character and not metagame.
I don't believe that's a valid argument. Why do we have coded skill increases to determine our chances of success? Are we bad players because we rely on the code to tell us our success rates for various tasks based on our character's past experience with that task? Are we bad players because we rely on code to determine if a thief can steal from us, or a murderer kill us, instead of our ability to put ourselves into a different role'? Does the existence of all that code we have indicate we as players come up short and need something?

I might argue yes. Indeed we as players DO need occasional regulation and guidance. We do need occasional coded consequences for bad actions. There is nothing wrong with admitting I roleplay better if there is code to there to guide me. I would never argue that a sport-- like soccer-- needs referees because the players are immature, and soccer players are some of the most intense professionals in the world. If I wouldn't expect such 'purity' from professional soccer players, I certainly wouldn't demand it of a handful of anonymous participants putting some leisure time into an obscure, and obsolete, on-line game.

When we agree on-- and use code to enforce-- some rules and guidelines to our group activity, I believe indicates our maturity, not our immaturity, as roleplayers.

Re: player death

Posted: Mon Jun 15, 2015 4:30 pm
by
The point of the threat of permanent character death is to add a whole new aspect of fear and realism to role play. Bihi might recklessly go after Yiri in the game without regard for his own safety, because I (who control Bihi) know I can just revive him in a few moments if I get Bihi killed. If I don't have that reassurance, I probably would be much more afraid of Yiri, and my roleplay will be more realistic for it.
I need to chime in on this because I've roleplayed in other games before and I can't wrap my head around this argument at all. Take WoW for example. When you die, there is no penalty, you just have to run back to your body. There are multiple classes that have spells to resurrect you from the dead on the spot. Yet everyone I have ever encountered and RPed with in that game still treated death like the serious and undesirable outcome that it is. I can understand that some times steeper costs can create more of that realism feeling for you the player versus your character (who IMO should always operate under the assumption that death can be permanent, regardless of whether they're afraid of it or not), but I think that your ability to immerse yourself or be immersed by the situation, which largely depends on who you're interacting with and why I so strongly urge people to take things seriously because it affects us all with such a small community, is what's most important. I the player knew Wren would come back to life if she died, but my heart rate still sky rocketed when Nikolas attempted to kill her.

TLDR; We all enjoy RP differently so I don't want to come across as offensive, but you openly stated you who control Bihi know you can revive him if you get him killed and that this affects your roleplay, which I feel is a personal thing and not an issue with the game's code. Maybe others will disagree, and I think it's cool that you're throwing out new ideas for the game to help it grow and become more complex, but I would not want to see these kinds of changes to the death system.
Are we bad players because we rely on code to determine if a thief can steal from us, or a murderer kill us, instead of our ability to put ourselves into a different role'?
I don't understand this question. Yes code will affect our chance to land a hit or steal successfully, but that's the nature of RPing in an open PvP game and actually using commands instead of RPing out attempts to harm or kill each other. If you mean you're relying on it IC, as in laughing someone off IC because OOC you know they aren't as skilled in something as you, or that their class isn't as strong as yours, then yes I think that's bad form in roleplaying and breaks the immersion/realism of a situation.

Re: player death

Posted: Mon Jun 15, 2015 4:45 pm
by
ditchhook wrote:I don't believe that's a valid argument. Why do we have coded skill increases to determine our chances of success? Are we bad players because we rely on the code to tell us our success rates for various tasks based on our character's past experience with that task? Are we bad players because we rely on code to determine if a thief can steal from us, or a murderer kill us, instead of our ability to put ourselves into a different role'? Does the existence of all that code we have indicate we as players come up short and need something?
The reason we have coded skills to determine our combat success is because this is a game that's driven by conflict, and the average player cannot be trusted to play anything but a winner. Have you ever hung around one of those roleplay forums with a big population? I have. I've been an admin for one. Reading most 'fights' in those threads was like watching a fight scene out of Dragon Ball Z. No one wanted to lose, no one wanted to take the hit, and it was twenty pages of "I hit you!" and "you missed but I got a hit!" or "I countered!" along with "I dodged your counter!" Someone has to lose in a conflict, that is what the coding and skills are there for. Whoever puts the work into the skills is typically the one that gets the prize. Thankfully, in SI, the one short on skills can still win by bringing his friends along for the ride.

The code in the game puts us in a position that's reasonable for us to go along with in our roleplay. If you want your character to be able to back up their words, you put the time in to train and make sure those coded skills and abilities work in your favor. In my time as a roleplayer and a gamer, I have learned that without this sort of arrangement for any game heavily steeped in conflict, players cannot usually be trusted to lose. There is always a loser in a conflict. This same concept is used in table top RPGs, because there is a dungeon master there to ensure someone gets the butt kicking they've RPed themselves into.
ditchhook wrote:I might argue yes. Indeed we as players DO need occasional regulation and guidance. We do need occasional coded consequences for bad actions. There is nothing wrong with admitting I roleplay better if there is code to there to guide me. I would never argue that a sport-- like soccer-- needs referees because the players are immature, and soccer players are some of the most intense professionals in the world. If I wouldn't expect such 'purity' from professional soccer players, I certainly wouldn't demand it of a handful of anonymous participants putting some leisure time into an obscure, and obsolete, on-line game.

When we agree on-- and use code to enforce-- some rules and guidelines to our group activity, I believe indicates our maturity, not our immaturity, as roleplayers.
It's also not about maturity or a lack of it. Humans by nature just don't like to be on the losing end. In the natural world, when you lose, you die, so the behavior is understandable. There are times I don't like to lose, but there is a huge difference between coding used in conflict and death penalties for players. If a player risks permanent character death just because other players won't pray for them, it is no longer fun. I think the death penalty as it is (skill loss) is fine, maybe characters could suffer illness for a while if they die often enough within a certain period of time. But to not come back just because people don't pray for you, or because you're the only active player in your faith? That shouldn't ever be up to the coding to decide, permanent character death needs to stay completely in the hands of that character's player.

No one has the right to dictate when someone else's character permanently dies, ever.