[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
http://www.shatteredisles.com • The VOICE: A Point of View Article-The Plight of the Goblins
Page 1 of 2

The VOICE: A Point of View Article-The Plight of the Goblins

Posted: Mon Aug 03, 2015 7:15 pm
by
Bihi the Cartographer's outspoken critiques of the Knight Marshals-- both in their inability to come to his aide during his confrontation
with "King" Yiri, and in their subsequent collective punishment of the Goblins of Three Bridges as retribution for "King" Yiri's rampages--
seems to have gone without response. The Knight Marshals have not arrested Bihi, or even threatened to do so. Nor have they gone on
a rampage of hanging or caging random Bonilau. Even our beloved Conclave must have been aware of this.

Thus the Conclave's practically unanimous vote to ignore the plight of the Goblins of Three Bridges seems not to be motivated by any fear
of retribution from the Marshals, but rather their own sincere distaste for Goblin rights within the Realm. Even Itzal's representatives--
the dominate religion of the Goblins-- voted against raising concerns about Goblin abuses with the King. The action of the Conclave
raises an important question: does it actually represent all the King's subjects? Is it functioning as intended? Or is it intended that goblins
be without any voice within the Realm beyond a mere Bonilau scribbler and an insane, murderous pretender? How would such a situation
impact the peace and good order of the Island?

Will the Conclave's open prejudice be good for the Peace of the Realm in the long run? And more importantly to some, will it be good for
business? How might an open rebellion in Three Bridges impact commerce--- not only with the Goblins there-- but with Outlast or
Rum Village, or access to the resources of the Ravenswood?

How much profit is the ATC willing to lose just to indulge Conclave's petty bigotries?

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Do YOU have a Point of View?
If you wish to have your thoughts published anonymously,
please contact this paper and we will make sure your Voice is heard!

* The views and opinions expressed in this article are strictly those of it's author.
* The VOICE assumes no responsibility legally or otherwise for any content herein.


This community message is humbly brought to you by
++++++++++The VOICE of Pearl!++++++++++
As always, stay Free... and get yourself Published!

Re: The VOICE: A Point of View Article-The Plight of the Gob

Posted: Tue Aug 04, 2015 3:24 pm
by
Dear writer of The Voice,

I can not speak for how other members of conclave felt about Citizen Bihi's proposal. I will however give you my reasoning for voting against sending a missive to King Sauntere. The simple truth is that Citizen Bihi came forth with little information regarding the situation of the goblins in question. He merely complained about how the Knight Marshals were unjustly caging and lynching goblins in three bridges. The Knight Marshals office may have a valid reason for such actions. He gave no information to support his opinion that it is unjust. Were there letters written to the Knight Marshals office requesting such information? Did he make any attempt to find out for himself if there were valid reasons? I cannot in good conscience vote to approve a missive to the King that is based on conjecture. Furthermore he didn't even bother to put forth enough effort to submit a written statement. We all are aware of his abilities with the scribes around the city. If such a thing was important enough for Conclave as a whole to send a missive to his royal majesty King Sauntere then it should have been worth the time and effort to put any information he had on paper. He certainly had enough time to paint a picture of King Sauntere himself.

If citizen Bihi wishes conclave to revisit such a request I suggest he put forth more effort in finding facts and less time grandstanding.

Sincerely,
Emissary Rochiriel Azahar

Re: The VOICE: A Point of View Article-The Plight of the Gob

Posted: Tue Aug 04, 2015 6:27 pm
by
To the editor:

I have read Emissary Rochiriel Azahar's response to your editorial, and find it despicable.

I was there, as were most of the other Emissaries, when--two public meetings ago-- a member of the Conclave asked the Knight Marshal in attendance what was being done to capture Yiri. The Knight Marshal's own response was that they were rounding up goblins in Three Bridges for retribution. If Emissary Rochiriel's memory doesn't serve to remind her of the Knight Marshals taking direct responsibility for the injustices, any of the other Emissaries present could have reminded her. If they themselves were not aware of the injustices being inflicted on the goblins of Three Bridges-- The corpse then hanging from the scaffold in the center square of Three Bridges, or the caged goblins being guarded by uniformed marshals-- the only reason could be dereliction of duty. Emissary Rochiriel's rather desperate attempt in her letter to you to avoid her personal-- and professional-- responsibilities, is so transparent it only reinforces the contention that her prejudices-- as well as the prejudices of the other Emissaries-- are severely interfering with their responsibilities. Does she claim confusion on whether the lynching and caging are legal acts of the Marshals? Where are the arrest warrants then? When was the Capital Trial conducted? Why was the execution not publicly announced. Emissary's Rochiriel's bigotry blinds her. As a mere cartographer; it is unreasonable to demand I bring sight to the intentionally blind.

No, I did not bring my own written request to the Conclave. I didn't need to because another already had. I quoted from His Majesty's written directive to the same Conclave. I shall do so again: "As the voice of the people, it is your job to pass these concerns of misconduct on to your king for judgment. " (viewtopic.php?t=1121) If Emissary Rochiriel feels she needs a WRITTEN request from a citizen before she feels obliged to follow the WRITTEN request of HIS MAJESTY, I suggest she is not being sincere with your readers. Rather she has replaced her duty to The King with her own bigotry. She knows she is doing so, and is hoping to deceive your readers in a desperate attempt to hide her own guilt.

Emissary Rochiriel: Do Your Job.

Sincerely,

Re: The VOICE: A Point of View Article-The Plight of the Gob

Posted: Tue Aug 04, 2015 8:00 pm
by
I only write for my self here as well, not other Emissaries.

As a bare minimum, to vote to bring this matter to the attention of King Sauntere, I'd need to know for certain if these Goblins are Pearl citizens, who are the people we work for. From what I can gather, they are not and that area is not in Pearl's sphere of influence. In fact, it's a town notorious for outlaws fleeing to it. Not one of them has come forward as a citizen of Pearl to ask our help on this matter, or any other matters, such as if they are on the run for a crime.

It is not our duty to bring every concern to the attention of King Sauntere, in particular when it regards non citizens, who we don't even represent. King Sauntere trusts the Conclave to only bring the most important matters to his attention and matters that concern our mission statement, which is to represent the citizens of Pearl.

We recently requested King Sauntere intervene in a case involving Xiija the Sylph. He listened to us in this matter. What you are asking of us is to risk that King Sauntere won't listen to us in the cases of future citizens in trouble. That is why the bar is so high, at least as far as my vote goes.

Blink Walkabout

Re: The VOICE: A Point of View Article-The Plight of the Gob

Posted: Tue Aug 04, 2015 8:53 pm
by
To the editor:

Apparently Emissary Blink concedes that injustices are occurring, but they are of no consequence because no one on Conclave is responsible to the People of Three Bridges. If that is the case, the Marshals are committing Acts of War against another community.

When was this war declared? If no war has been declared against Three Bridges, then we are again confronted with the Knights Marshal committing an injustice: an injustice not only against the people of Three Bridges, but against the King's subjects-- risking bringing Pearl to War without formal declaration from the King. And again, I can only repeat what the Knight Marshal reported to Conclave a few months ago: the lynching and cages are in retribution for Yiri's rampages in Pearl: no mention of a declaration of war was ever proffered.

I can only repeat the King's charge to the Conclave: "As the voice of the people, it is your job to pass these concerns of misconduct on to your king for judgment." What Emissary Blink is describing-- ridiculous as it sounds-- is still misconduct, and in no way justifies Conclave's inaction.

Now that this pathetic excuse for Conclave's inaction has been debunked, I imagine your readers will soon be subject to a variety of increasingly absurd justifications. Such is always the case when bigots are pressed to justify their bigotry.

Sincerely,

Re: The VOICE: A Point of View Article-The Plight of the Gob

Posted: Tue Aug 04, 2015 10:00 pm
by
Apparently Emissary Blink concedes that injustices are occurring, but they are of no consequence because no one on Conclave is responsible to the People of Three Bridges. If that is the case, the Marshals are committing Acts of War against another community.

When was this war declared? If no war has been declared against Three Bridges, then we are again confronted with the Knights Marshal committing an injustice: an injustice not only against the people of Three Bridges, but against the King's subjects-- risking bringing Pearl to War without formal declaration from the King. And again, I can only repeat what the Knight Marshal reported to Conclave a few months ago: the lynching and cages are in retribution for Yiri's rampages in Pearl: no mention of a declaration of war was ever proffered.

I can only repeat the King's charge to the Conclave: "As the voice of the people, it is your job to pass these concerns of misconduct on to your king for judgment." What Emissary Blink is describing-- ridiculous as it sounds-- is still misconduct, and in no way justifies Conclave's inaction.

Now that this pathetic excuse for Conclave's inaction has been debunked, I imagine your readers will soon be subject to a variety of increasingly absurd justifications. Such is always the case when bigots are pressed to justify their bigotry.
I conceded nothing of the sort. We know little about why this was done. It is unlikely to be a war, since the town is so small and no real threat to the mighty Pearl.

Not one, but two Emissaries have responded to your concerns and told you how you can gain our vote in this matter. You don't seem interested, which only leaves you the Knight Marshals to deal with. Good luck with that. Your eagerness to burn bridges tells me you are not really concerned about this issue at all. You just want to fling mud in the papers and feel righteous. It will go exactly no where. Our temples support us and nothing you say changes that. If Temple Aerthane were to ask me to step down and allow you to take my place on Conclave, I'd agree in an instant. But we both know that will not happen.

Quoting words out of context will get you no where either. You're a complete idiot if you do not realize it isn't our duty to bring every concern of misconduct directly to the king. In that very quote "these concerns of misconduct" are a reference to a concerns that were going on at that particular time. I don't believe you're an idiot, however. I believe you are dishonest.

Blink Walkabout

Re: The VOICE: A Point of View Article-The Plight of the Gob

Posted: Tue Aug 04, 2015 10:54 pm
by
To the editor:

I predicted in an earlier letter that the Conclave's excuses would grow more absurd as time passed, but I did not expect them to become so absurd so quickly.

"You're a complete idiot if you do not realize it isn't our duty to bring every concern of misconduct directly to the king." Emissary Blink contends. The question then presents itself as to exactly WHAT misconduct is severe enough to be worthy of the King's attention? I again repeat the King's charge to Conclave: "As the voice of the people, it is your job to pass these concerns of misconduct on to your king for judgment." I would contend that Knights Marshal lynching and caging people without just cause qualifies-- if anything is ever to qualify.

Emissary Blink does not. Why not? I contend it's because the lynching and caging of goblins who have not been charged or convicted of any crime is-- in Emissary Blink's opinion-- not a matter sufficiently grave to merit the Conclave's attention for no better reason than because they are goblins. If these injustices were being carried out against any other race, Emissary Blink and the rest of Conclave would have acted without waiting for a written petition from a concerned subject. Emissary Blink's latest response only provides even more evidence that the Conclave is putting their personal bigotries ahead of their duty to obey the King.

Sincerely,

Re: The VOICE: A Point of View Article-The Plight of the Gob

Posted: Wed Aug 05, 2015 12:09 am
by
There appears to be some dispute over the responsibilities of the Conclave with respect to potential or actual misconduct by the Knights Marshal. A single sentence has been cited by both Bihi and Blink to justify their different views on this matter. It might be better to start with the paragraph in which the problematic sentence appears.
Therefore, by issue of royal decree, I give full authority of issuing and enforcing new law to the Lord Marshal's office, as it should always have been. Furthermore, I revoke Conclave's privilege of introducing a new law without my prior approval. As the voice of the people, it is your job to pass these concerns of misconduct on to your king for judgment. Not serve as judge in my stead.
One source of confusion seems to be Bihi's view that the Conclave is to report misconduct on the part of the KM to the King. The passage gives the Conclave the job of passing on concerns of misconduct only. Moreover, the Conclave has this job in its role as the voice of the people. One may then infer that the Conclave is to pass on the concerns of the people of misconduct by the Knights Marshal. And in doing so, it is to leave judgement regarding such alleged misconduct to the King, and the King alone.

It is not, then, the alleged severity of the possible misconduct that is to trigger a report to the King, but concerns of the people of Pearl over said possible misconduct. The role of the Conclave is to assess whether or not the concerns of the people of Pearl are sufficient to warrant a report to the King. One might well argue that a complaint by a single citizen of Pearl, unsupported at the time by any other residents of Pearl, simply is not sufficient to warrant a report by the Conclave to the King. The subject matter of the complaint would then be irrelevant. Put another way, Bihi failed to make the case that this was a matter of serious concern to the people of Pearl.

Bihi could, of course, respond that while this may not be a matter of concern to the people of Pearl, it should be a matter of concern to them, and further that the Conclave, as prominent subjects of the King and citizens of Pearl, ought to take the lead in making this a matter of concern for the people. Should Bihi adopt this course, he might consider refraining from directly insulting the Conclave, either individually or collectively.

--Aruskin

Re: The VOICE: A Point of View Article-The Plight of the Gob

Posted: Wed Aug 05, 2015 1:11 am
by
I predicted in an earlier letter that the Conclave's excuses would grow more absurd as time passed, but I did not expect them to become so absurd so quickly.

"You're a complete idiot if you do not realize it isn't our duty to bring every concern of misconduct directly to the king." Emissary Blink contends. The question then presents itself as to exactly WHAT misconduct is severe enough to be worthy of the King's attention? I again repeat the King's charge to Conclave: "As the voice of the people, it is your job to pass these concerns of misconduct on to your king for judgment." I would contend that Knights Marshal lynching and caging people without just cause qualifies-- if anything is ever to qualify.

Emissary Blink does not. Why not? I contend it's because the lynching and caging of goblins who have not been charged or convicted of any crime is-- in Emissary Blink's opinion-- not a matter sufficiently grave to merit the Conclave's attention for no better reason than because they are goblins. If these injustices were being carried out against any other race, Emissary Blink and the rest of Conclave would have acted without waiting for a written petition from a concerned subject. Emissary Blink's latest response only provides even more evidence that the Conclave is putting their personal bigotries ahead of their duty to obey the King.
Once again, that King's letter you are quoting is from over a year ago, nearly two years now. One of the main concerns King Sauntere was referring to in that letter I believe was a Gavial citizen that was put into the stocks and struck by a pole-arm by a Knight Marshal. I was not an Emissary at the time, but I wanted the King to be made aware of what I saw as an injustice. And I succeeded in doing so by bringing great attention to it during an appeal where I was the defense lawyer.

The difference here is the Gavial, named Zarchang, was clearly a citizen. All evidence we have points to these Goblins not being citizens of Pearl. Pearl does have Goblin citizens, believe it or not. If you have evidence that any of these Goblins are citizens, please bring it forward. Or if any of them are former citizens who have been outlawed, I'd be happy to look at their case and file an appeal for them. You wish to make this an issue of race, but that is only your own faulty reasoning. Although I later came to like them, I had no special reason to stand up for a Gavial at the time. I stood up for Zarchang because it was the right thing to do and I believed I had a good case. In contrast, you have a terrible case, because you can't seem to prove that the people killed were citizens. I risked my freedom and life in speaking out on the Zarchang matter, and I would never have done so if I felt I had a poor case.

You seem upset that the scope of Conclave is limited to representing and finding justice for citizens of Pearl. But it's really hard to argue we aren't doing our jobs because we don't represent non citizens. We don't represent any of the various pirates floating around the seas either, but it doesn't mean we aren't working hard for citizens of Pearl, who we represent. Also, I think it is a noble quest to work for the citizens of Pearl this way. The person who decides they will find justice for the entire planet is a fool who will in the end accomplish nothing. My work in Pearl as a lawyer and Emissary may be limited to citizens of a single city, but the results are real and have had an impact on real lives.

If your case is so damn strong, then go do what I did in the Zarchang matter. Go make a big ruckus in the Pearl posts. Perhaps you know your case is weak, or perhaps you are just a coward. Claiming several knight marshals are traitors is dangerous indeed. Doing so with pathetic evidence is madness. To a degree even you know this, which is why you are simply whining in an out of the way post and demanding others take risks that you yourself will not take.

Bring us some evidence that citizens are being harmed by the knights. Barring that, grow a pair of balls and make your accusations at the knights yourself.

Blink Walkabout

Re: The VOICE: A Point of View Article-The Plight of the Gob

Posted: Wed Aug 05, 2015 1:17 am
by
There appears to be some dispute over the responsibilities of the Conclave with respect to potential or actual misconduct by the Knights Marshal. A single sentence has been cited by both Bihi and Blink to justify their different views on this matter. It might be better to start with the paragraph in which the problematic sentence appears.

Quote:
Therefore, by issue of royal decree, I give full authority of issuing and enforcing new law to the Lord Marshal's office, as it should always have been. Furthermore, I revoke Conclave's privilege of introducing a new law without my prior approval. As the voice of the people, it is your job to pass these concerns of misconduct on to your king for judgment. Not serve as judge in my stead.


One source of confusion seems to be Bihi's view that the Conclave is to report misconduct on the part of the KM to the King. The passage gives the Conclave the job of passing on concerns of misconduct only. Moreover, the Conclave has this job in its role as the voice of the people. One may then infer that the Conclave is to pass on the concerns of the people of misconduct by the Knights Marshal. And in doing so, it is to leave judgement regarding such alleged misconduct to the King, and the King alone.

It is not, then, the alleged severity of the possible misconduct that is to trigger a report to the King, but concerns of the people of Pearl over said possible misconduct. The role of the Conclave is to assess whether or not the concerns of the people of Pearl are sufficient to warrant a report to the King. One might well argue that a complaint by a single citizen of Pearl, unsupported at the time by any other residents of Pearl, simply is not sufficient to warrant a report by the Conclave to the King. The subject matter of the complaint would then be irrelevant. Put another way, Bihi failed to make the case that this was a matter of serious concern to the people of Pearl.

Bihi could, of course, respond that while this may not be a matter of concern to the people of Pearl, it should be a matter of concern to them, and further that the Conclave, as prominent subjects of the King and citizens of Pearl, ought to take the lead in making this a matter of concern for the people. Should Bihi adopt this course, he might consider refraining from directly insulting the Conclave, either individually or collectively.
There are two issues here. One, if King Sauntere feels we wasted his time with a complaint, he may do nothing, but he also may begin to view the Conclave as fools not worth listening to. It may have an impact on future requests and appeals from Conclave to the Crown. And conversely, if we are wise about what concerns the Conclave points out the King, when do have a legitimate concern with strong evidence, then the King is more likely to listen to us, since we haven't wasted his time in the past. Unless there is some legitimate security threat involved, I feel that bringing concerns about non citizens to the King's attention is the very definition of wasting his time. And it's laughable to think there is a legitimate security threat to Pearl from the tiny village of Three Bridges.

The second issue it is simply dangerous to make claims of treason against Knight Marshals based on flimsy evidence. They have their jobs for a reason. The King trusts them with a lot of power and responsibility. They are seen by the law as his direct representatives, as both law enforcers and judges. Even I don't speak out against a Knight Marshal lightly, and I'm someone who actually has. I certainly don't do so with flimsy evidence.

Bihi is playing with fire and wishes to try to use public opinion to force us to play with fire as well. No thanks.

Blink Walkabout