[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
http://www.shatteredisles.com • Mining and Digging
Page 1 of 1

Mining and Digging

Posted: Sun Mar 20, 2016 4:43 pm
by
I was cruising around the forums as I'm wont to do, and I found this quote from Snaek under the planned updates sticky:

" Mining and Digging are being merged into one skill so that the skill tree is more obvious as you unlock related trade skills such as glass blowing, pottery, blacksmithing, smelting, jewelry crafting, and steel armorsmithing. Once this is done, in-character information will be added to better explain the different paths you can take with crafting. "

Now, I don't know what this will look like or if this is still true, but I'm somewhat against the idea. If you want to allow for earlier specialization, just have mining unlock at the same time digging does, which should require far less effort and accomplish the same thing. As it stands, I think the paths are fairly self explanatory, though which unlocks first might be a question. Having NPCs that might suggest which unlocks where (without directly telling us of course) I think is a good idea, though.

Re: Mining and Digging

Posted: Sun Mar 20, 2016 6:21 pm
by
I don't see why these branch out from foraging, other then the fact that they are all gathering crafts.

Foraging implies plant knowledge. Botany.
I say that because otherwise a failure would give us some useless bits of foliage.
But how does knowing the dandelions make you pee help me to dig a hole?
The use of a digging stick to collect roots is the only connection I can find, and that seems a stretch.
I see Farming and Gardening branching out from it instead. Maybe Animal Husbandry.

Digging and mining are both forms of strenuous manual labor more concerned with throughput than finesse.
Short of being able to read the exposed surface for some clue of local minerals (geology) random luck would be the biggest decider of what you get.
But that would be a skill more held by the foreman of the crew, he tells the workers where to dig and ensures the structural stability of the tunnel (architecture).
Swinging the shovel/pick is just grunt work with little skill behind it beyond efficiency of motion.

Now, if digging and mining were just two activities based of a geology skill, i would agree the combining is the way to go.
Does this mean that the cumulative reps for each skill will be added together when the merger happens?

Re: Mining and Digging

Posted: Sun Mar 20, 2016 7:07 pm
by
Foraging unlocks digging and eventually mining because that's how survival games do it!

Seriously though, that progression does make sense in survival games because usually they depict a lower level of development, and going through the route makes sense both in terms of the logical time period and also for game progression. For SI, though, which is in a Low to Middle Ages, it would make sense to just outright start with mining and digging - but I'm going to argue against doing so. First of all, there's the economic implications of being able to immediately access mining and such - believe me when I say I know how easy it is to tip the economy here ;p

But I think the real concern is the experience of new players and player psychology. First, new players, whether to SI or MUDs in general, don't really want to be overwhelmed with all the things they can do all at once. The unlocking of skills over time ensures that a player isn't immediately overwhelmed by too much stuff, which can cause them to shut down and be afraid of the game and eventually wander away to something seen to be less threatening. The other half is meeting the needs of achievers - the goal or achievement style of player. By breaking up the skills, a sense of accomplishment can come upon unlocking the new skills. This is the proverbial "ding." This is especially important in a game like SI, which is extremely slow paced compared to modern games; it will take months or even years to master some skills, and dings become few and far in between as time progresses. Having them occur early on is good, even if logic may take a bit of a back seat to it. In short, the earlier unlocks help to bait the hook while the RP, world, and sheer momentum of leveling is the rod to keep reeling the player back.

My only concern with the merging of the two skills is that it might obfuscate the paths as exist now; it makes sense that if you collect sand and clay with one skill, it would unlock glassblowing and pottery. Unless this new dig-mine skill is heavily backed up by NPCs explaining the process of unlocking and where these skills unlock changes to be much more immediate, it could just muddy up waters that aren't at all necessary to muddy up. Nothing frustrates me more than seeing people create unnecessary work for themselves.

Re: Mining and Digging

Posted: Sun Mar 20, 2016 7:41 pm
by
If the issue is just one of overwhelming players with possibilities...
Take the same route as the equipment command.
For the empty slots (or skills still at 0), display nothing.

As for the economical concerns.... well, that is a problem intrinsic to all MUDs.
The issue is that your resources are only as limited as the RNG odds of finding them.
And those odds tend to be inflated for the sake of gameplay, which leads to a rich playerbase.

The economy is definitely something to consider.
But I get far more frustrated when i have to grind for over a RL day to learn how to do the most entry level work in modern times.
Talk about unnecessary work.