The reason behind being shipped off to Pearl by the gods every time you die seems a bit sketchy at best.
If there is a closer temple on your current island, shouldn't the god prefer to send you there?
Would be both logical.. and an asset to gameplay.
Death and Temples
Death and Temples
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
Re: Death and Temples
IMHO, a nearby shrine just doesn't cut it compared to your home temple. I can see the interest in getting right back into the battle, but I don't know if that is reason enough. Why is the closest temple to where you died the most logical if distance doesn't hinder the gods?
Let's hear some more suggestions and opinions in regards to the process of death in Shattered Isles.
Let's hear some more suggestions and opinions in regards to the process of death in Shattered Isles.
- Kody_Oakborne
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 209
- Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2014 1:35 am
Re: Death and Temples
As the academy is a place of learning and not intended to be a place to live forever, I could get behind the idea of anyone with the STUDENT flag to be transported to the shrines within the academy. Getting culture shocked into being thrown into Pearl after the terror of dying your first time doesn't seem appropriate to me. They'd be somewhere they've never been, and have to find their way back, with the potential of a 15 minute+ delay due to the Ferry as well. All of the temples put aside their differences to provide the academy, shouldn't the Gods be in the same category and be supporting the growth of Pearl's citizens by not further hindering their progress while they're still a student?Austere wrote:IMHO, a nearby shrine just doesn't cut it compared to your home temple. I can see the interest in getting right back into the battle, but I don't know if that is reason enough. Why is the closest temple to where you died the most logical if distance doesn't hinder the gods?
Let's hear some more suggestions and opinions in regards to the process of death in Shattered Isles.
If this is about another island... disregard!
Edit: If this is already implemented, disregard. It's been a long while since I was a student.
Last edited by Kody_Oakborne on Wed Apr 13, 2016 11:20 pm, edited 1 time in total.
May the trees guard you, and house you, and guide you.
Kody
Kody
Re: Death and Temples
The thing is, why does the game get to decide where your home temple is?
Why does your 'fealty' or home island, get to be set by other than the player?
Supposedly Academy has people that live there, even if they aren't students, like the various shopkeepers and teachers.
It is all based on a potentially false assumption.
Why does your 'fealty' or home island, get to be set by other than the player?
Supposedly Academy has people that live there, even if they aren't students, like the various shopkeepers and teachers.
It is all based on a potentially false assumption.
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
-
Shattered Mind
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 125
- Joined: Wed Dec 24, 2014 9:18 pm
Re: Death and Temples
Simple answer is: There is currently only one temple for each religion in the game. The academy only has shrines.Vexing wrote:The thing is, why does the game get to decide where your home temple is?
If you want to argue shrines vs. temples, go ahead, but IMO the Gods make the decisions about what they want to do, not some puny mortal, and I think a God is going to do his or her every day type of business at the largest place of worship in the area.
Also, while it may seem inconvenient to have to take the ferry back to AI it really isn't that time consuming and the ferry runs a heckuva lot faster and more often than is likely in real life. To the staff: I am not asking for reality here. Please do not slow down the ferry.
It could be worse. Maybe the Gods will only resurrect you back on the island named after the God, when they open up. As much as that would suck for the player(s) I could see a God doing that. I don't think where a PC gets resurrected should be determined by the PC. A PC should just be dang happy his/her God is willing to resurrect them in the first place.
I understand your point here. However, just like in real life, those people take the ferry to do things and get things which they cannot do or get on AI, whether that is worshiping at a Temple or shopping for certain goods not available on AI.Vexing wrote:Why does your 'fealty' or home island, get to be set by other than the player?
Supposedly Academy has people that live there, even if they aren't students, like the various shopkeepers and teachers.
An even more extreme example of this would be the residents of Dolorous Island (which if you know your history used to be part of AI until a recent large earthquake caused it to become separated from AI). These folks are heavily dependent on a ferry.
I assume that as more islands open up, and that some of those islands are going to be islands other than the major islands named after the Gods, that this "problem" may get even more "extreme".
I do not see any potentially false assumption regarding all of this.Vexing wrote:It is all based on a potentially false assumption.
-
CoralScribe
- Citizen of Archai
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Mon Jan 20, 2014 6:11 pm
Re: Death and Temples
At this time, there's no reason to change how death mechanics work. Yes, the loss of student status and rezzing on the main isle feels more like a game gimmick than a part of the religion, but you are playing a game and you have to allow for some suspension of disbelief, especially when the game mechanics have to supersede realism or lore.
That said, I would like it if we had the ability to attune or simply just ask our god to return us to a certain temple should anything happen. I don't think the Academy shrines should ever be attunable in this way, but future temples added to far off places, be they the big Isles of the Gods or just small isles like what Dolorous has become, should allow us that option rather than simply being a 'closest temple' mechanic or worse, a 'greatest temple' mechanic. I know other games have used a favor system for this in the past, sacrificing items and/or money in order for currency used for such religious mechanics - ie, favors, from the god.
Until such time as we have a world and population big enough to support multiple temples of Kaleith or what have you, though, I wouldn't bother exploring it at this time.
That said, I would like it if we had the ability to attune or simply just ask our god to return us to a certain temple should anything happen. I don't think the Academy shrines should ever be attunable in this way, but future temples added to far off places, be they the big Isles of the Gods or just small isles like what Dolorous has become, should allow us that option rather than simply being a 'closest temple' mechanic or worse, a 'greatest temple' mechanic. I know other games have used a favor system for this in the past, sacrificing items and/or money in order for currency used for such religious mechanics - ie, favors, from the god.
Until such time as we have a world and population big enough to support multiple temples of Kaleith or what have you, though, I wouldn't bother exploring it at this time.
......./\.......
____/__\____
..../......\.....
**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**
____/__\____
..../......\.....
**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**