Suspension of Disbelief

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
Post Reply
User avatar
Vexing
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 204
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 2:17 am

Suspension of Disbelief

Post by Vexing »

Is an ideal often quoted when dealing with MUDs.
I realize there are some limitations, but some of the actual examples we deal with seem absurd.

Take squirrels for example:

I mean, sure a rabid squirrel might attack you... by why do all the others?
But it is still just a foot long rodent at best.
One good swipe from any edges weapon should be cutting them in half, or at least cutting off the tail. Even from the farmer's wife.
In RL they are best shot, trapped, or lured into an ambush.
Yet it ends up being that the poor wildlife critter totally forgets its instincts of fight or flight, and decides to sock it out one on one in an attrition battle.
Does bleeding even do anything?
I imagine these fights with squirrels would really have you running all over the yard and climbing up trees just trying to corner them to get a swipe.

starting off like the orcs eventually learn to do.
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
Bocon L
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 214
Joined: Sat May 31, 2014 5:04 pm

Re: Suspension of Disbelief

Post by Bocon L »

They are special squirrels.
CoralScribe
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 122
Joined: Mon Jan 20, 2014 6:11 pm

Re: Suspension of Disbelief

Post by CoralScribe »

About a decade or so ago, I was visiting a friends' house. They had a pool, but I was actually there to play Warhammer 40k, cause I was (am) a certifiable nerd. It was the first time either of us had played the game, and I was having a lot of fun, but it sure took awhile compared to the games I had been playing online with him. But it was fine by me. There was soda and chips and great company. I'd been friends with this guy since middle school and any chance to hang out was a good one.

Towards the end of the day, his mother comes in the house. She had been cleaning the pool and found that a squirrel had fallen into the water and was swept up into the gutter. Though the thing was half-drown and exhausted, it was still alive. I figured, okay - just let it catch its breath and release it. No harm in that, right? Well, thing is, they lived in a desert. With snakes. Having squirrels nearby meant that the chances for a rattlesnake slithering into the back yard and attacking their dog or them became pretty high. So my friend, being the man of the house as the dad was out, was called upon to take a shovel and end the poor thing's life. Actually took two hits to do it, was rather mortifying to the young kid I used to be. He's still one of my closest friends, but I never forgot this incident and how willing he was to do this - even if it was necessary. Even today, if I were asked to do the same thing, I don't know that I'd have it in me.

What's the point of this story? It's to give you some context - real world context that requires no suspension of disbelief - to try to help you understand why I am far less reticent to kill squirrels in a game than I am in real life. I understand that squirrels, and the other cute forestland critters that I brutally murder in the forest to practice my skinning, are not real. They are bits of data on a computer server somewhere, and the act of killing them, at most, turns those bits of data off for a little bit while they respawn. I can cruelly track them down and destroy them without care or remorse like the darkest psychopath, and it ultimately means nothing, because I am not actually harming anything and could never imagine doing so in real life.

Coraleth, however, takes after me a little bit, in that he doesn't like to harm things. And this is where suspension of disbelief first begins. We know that these things are not real, but Coraleth, being a character in the world, made of essentially the same bits of data, does not. I must put aside my understanding of the real world and try to view things through the character's eyes, suspend my disbelief in their worth and their true value. Therefore bits of data become a squirrel. And like me and a real squirrel, Coraleth gets a bit queasy when he thinks of having to kill them - but he does them anyway, much like my friend, because it is necessary.

So he throws daggers of ice at them, and he swings his weapon, and sometimes he misses - again, I know the game has rolled low, and therefore I am not allowed to damage the squirrel because the numbers say I can't. But again, I suspend my disbelief and replace my understanding of the numbers with something that does make sense - the squirrel is running around, scurrying up a tree, snapping at me desperately to stop when I get too close, and though it may attempt to flee, my longer gait and my projectile weapons of ice prevent it from getting too far. If I were a stronger character, I could end this squirrel in two or three hits, but unlike the half-drowned squirrel my friend put down, these ones are quick, so I can't hit anything vital until, at last, the creature finally suffers a hit that brings it down.

Suspension of disbelief is vital in books, text based games, and even graphical games, because tricking the mind allows it to become immersed in the world - to stop seeing it as ones and zeroes or letters in a book and become real. It is imagination unbound, and it allows us to visit the darkest reaches of space, the deepest oceans, or the villa on the hill. To live without it is to know just how horrible the world really is, and to be unable to imagine a world changed for the better. Some have a higher tolerance necessary for suspension of disbelief. You may be one of them. All I can suggest is to try to see the world of SI through your character's eyes and see the systems that exist the same as we see gravity or inertia in our world - facts of life that are to be accepted as normal, because they are. And if you try this, and you can't make that world come to life they way you want it to, you should probably try to find something else that does. There's thousands upon thousands of worlds out there you can become engaged in, not just MUDs, but books and other games as well, and surely at least one of them will meet the requirements you place upon your personal suspension of disbelief.

I wish you all the best.
......./\.......
____/__\____
..../......\.....

**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**
User avatar
Vexing
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 204
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 2:17 am

Re: Suspension of Disbelief

Post by Vexing »

I agree with all that you said, but sometimes the disbelief is too blatant and stacks too high.
When is enough enough?

If the story becomes too nonsensical it then becomes a thing solely for children.
I want to play an adult game, where things can be addressed and people can be held accountable.
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
User avatar
KschilanT
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 57
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2013 4:39 pm

Re: Suspension of Disbelief

Post by KschilanT »

Vexing wrote: If the story becomes too nonsensical it then becomes a thing solely for children.
I want to play an adult game, where things can be addressed and people can be held accountable.
I'm not sure entirely what you're driving at, the squirrel hunting interaction (as you said) is an example, and it feels to me like it is masking the true issue at hand.

Things are addressed in these forums all the time, and I do believe the staff takes notice. Granted, some issues rank higher on the "fix now" scale, and again I hold faith that staff are doing what they can, as quick as they can, considering this is a free-to-play game and any/all work they do is during their free time.

When I saw the phrase "holding people accountable", my assumption (correct me if I am wrong, please) is that something people are doing in game, is bothering you. Is this an RP issue? Is it mechanics abuse? These things should be reported. If it's a grey area (my pet-peeve is the sometimes nonchalant attitude towards death), you might have to roll with it a bit, until enough people make a civilized complaint to the staff about RP enforcement. I've tried via RP to communicate certain points like this prior to writing a grievance, and sometimes it does help shape the world and characters you interact with.

If I've read too much into this, then I apologize for my tangent.

-Kschilan's player
User avatar
Vexing
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 204
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 2:17 am

Re: Suspension of Disbelief

Post by Vexing »

Well in general I was talking about staff, thought not necessarily those here.
They design the code that forces us to suspend the disbelief.
Other games I have played at, the staff held themselves above reproach.
I did not mean to implicate anyone at SI.
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
User avatar
Austere
SI Staff Member
Posts: 389
Joined: Fri Jan 21, 2011 1:12 am

Believe

Post by Austere »

I can confirm most every hunting ground has a story to go along with it, even the squirrels. There was the bee fiasco sometime around 432 which led to Pearlean laws that prohibited harvesting your own honey. It was a sticky mess that precious few could recall. Judging by the squirrels' behavior these days, I think they aim to quell any two-legged threat to their territory; yes, even Geels. It is my opinion that they all show signs of rabies, but some are far worse off. I consider it likely that those rare ones are responsible for infecting the droves of squirrels that would tell you to leave if they could speak. So, if folks didn't hunt there, the squirrels could win.

I don't think we're aiming to make anything nonsensical, we're players too. You're welcome to bring those things to our attention as we can make mistakes like anyone else.
User avatar
Vexing
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 204
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 2:17 am

Re: Suspension of Disbelief

Post by Vexing »

Whether or not a story has been made up to go along with it seems irrelevant.
Usually it is justification without changing fact.
Making excuses is a lot easier than making sense.
If we would all just concede the point when a given argument was defeated, this whole communication/civilization thing would work a lot smoother.
User avatar
KschilanT
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 57
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2013 4:39 pm

Re: Suspension of Disbelief

Post by KschilanT »

What I'm reading then is coming across thusly:

You want the frailty (and also inherent agility) that is present in certain NPCs in reality, to be reflected in SI.

This way, when one is swinging a razor sharp sword at an NPC (like the squirrels in discussion), one would have an extremely hard time chasing after and killing one. If that same NPC was aggressively pursuing you, it would obviously be easier to hit, as it is relinquishing its normal advantage of being able to outrun you.

Contrariwise, if one stood back and used a bow, it would be easier to kill such an NPC at range, when it cannot sense the more imminent threat of something physically chasing it. If that same NPC closed the distance while aggressively attacking the player, it would be harder to use that bow in close combat.

Leaving the idea of tactical distancing within a room out of this discussion at this time, the suggestion of implementing the code to adapt each NPC's (or PC's) defense rating to the attacker's weapon choice is... daunting. Not that it cannot be done, but speaking for myself (and I'm sure many others) I'd rather see coding work go towards other issues at this time.

-Kschilan's player
Kschilan Tehekchen
Apprentice to Merchant Elmere Manske
Post Reply