Page 1 of 2
Claws
Posted: Tue Apr 19, 2016 11:54 am
by
Would it be possible if the races with a claw attack got to make use of those claws for other activities as well?
Skinning and lock picking come readily to mind.
Sewing as well.
If not directly, then perhaps through some manicuring techniques to shape them to better suit a given task.
Or claw tips so the could be effectively worn, if not be grafted/crimped into place.
Re: Claws
Posted: Tue Apr 19, 2016 2:49 pm
by
Vexing wrote:Would it be possible if the races with a claw attack got to make use of those claws for other activities as well?
Skinning and lock picking come readily to mind.
Sewing as well.
If not directly, then perhaps through some manicuring techniques to shape them to better suit a given task.
Or claw tips so the could be effectively worn, if not be grafted/crimped into place.
I'm not sure how someone with claws would have the manual dexterity to pick a lock with their claws. Generally lockpicking (in reality) requires a bimanual technique in which you have a tension wrench and a pick, and you apply gentle tension as you manipulate the pins with your pick. There are of course other ways to pick locks, but I'm not sure they'd employ claws any better than this method.
On that same note, I'm not sure how you'd thread a claw to sew with.
The only one I could see perhaps is skinning; and for that you'd have to use your least favorite term: SUSPENSION OF DISBELIEF! It's harder to make precision cuts with a handful of claws than it would be with a solid single blade.
In the event that you decided to manicure your claws to use them for specialized skills I'd have to suggest they're no longer functional for combat purposes.
Re: Claws
Posted: Tue Apr 19, 2016 11:22 pm
by
Nothing says you would be using all the claws at once. No one tries to skin with five blades at a time either, allow those clawed individuals to apply the same common sense.
As for the sewing, people used awls before they used needles, and a claw would serve quite well as an awl.
The could be used to do very fine carving in softer materials like wood and bone. Etching almost.
And I was more thinking of the
old single lever mortise locks, like those fancy farmhouse keys are used in.
They aren't the most secure and i could easily see some sturdy claws being used for this purpose, even if it requires a finger on each hand.
Animals are extraordinary escape artists as it it, add in the sentience to back it up and this seems squarely in the realm of plausible.
As for tool shaped claws not being weapons..... when shovels and pickaxes stop being weapons because they are tools, you might have a point.
They might be less effective, or they might be more, depending on how the attack is being accomplished.
The only suspension of disbelief required, is the one where people find need to poop on every idea i have, simply because it challenges the status quo.
Suggestions by their very nature imply change.
Why not find a way to improve the idea instead trying to find a way to dismiss it entirely?
Re: Claws
Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2016 2:36 am
by
Because sometimes, the best improvement is dismissal.
Re: Claws
Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2016 9:43 am
by
The act of treating something as unworthy of serious consideration; rejection.
Purely by the definition, how can that be an improvement?
We are all using the same language here folks.
Re: Claws
Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2016 11:07 am
by
Vexing wrote:
As for tool shaped claws not being weapons..... when shovels and pickaxes stop being weapons because they are tools, you might have a point.
They might be less effective, or they might be more, depending on how the attack is being accomplished.
I just don't see this being an effective weapon anymore. It's apples to oranges when you compare claws that have been whittled to specific tools to improvised, heavy, metal objects like shovels or pick axes.
Vexing wrote:The only suspension of disbelief required, is the one where people find need to poop on every idea i have, simply because it challenges the status quo.
Suggestions by their very nature imply change.
Why not find a way to improve the idea instead trying to find a way to dismiss it entirely?
I've supported a few of your ideas, but the majority of your ideas are entire revamps of the game, things that just aren't possible in the crunch to launch, or ideas that other players dislike or disagree with. This game has been in development for quite some time now, and a lot of hard work has gone into it. Perhaps saying something positive would change people's attitudes toward your ideas, as currently they all seem to say "I don't like this game. I'd prefer you make it into the game I would like."
So, sometimes there's not a way to improve your idea because I or someone else disagrees with it. Thus dismissal of the idea is our suggestion, and we should be equally respected for saying we disagree with your idea and don't see the benefit or don't think it would be an appropriate addition.
I took an approach of addressing each idea and as I said, the only one I could see myself supporting is using your claws for skinning. And now that I think it over, claws don't have a sharpened edge like a blade, so they'd literally tear the flesh rather than lacerated straight lines for precision skinning... So I'm not sure I support that idea either. I believe I'm allowed my opinion, and my opinion is allowed to be in disagreement with yours.
Re: Claws
Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2016 11:39 am
by
Well, If you want an apology for me sticking to the topic and not sucking up with a bunch of prose and compliments first, I don't know what to tell you.
The world isn't all flowers and candies and compliments.
This is a forum, usually short for a discussion forum, so the fact that a discussion is going to take place should be a given.
As is the likelihood of hearing ideas you way not agree with.
People need to take things with a grain of salt.
I have done my best to not specifically insult or denigrate anything with my suggestions (I can't help inference).
... but I'm not going try to inflate your ego first so you are more open to the discussion.
I also was not trying to single you out specifically Kody, but there seems to be a general tone of resistance to anything not put forth by an established member of the community.
Back to the topic.... those claws would be great for eye gouging or jabbing.
I will grant you that the form the attack must take is definitely changing.
But the ability to make an attack is not.
Human nails are more prone to cracking do to the elongated and flattened form they have taken, as opposed to the curved cone that most claws take on.
For the record, you only need one implement to pick locks with in the game at the moment anyway.
That that one implement is a claw is not that much more of a stretch.
Re: Claws
Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2016 1:06 pm
by
I can't speak for everyone but it is my opinion the way you present your ideas and suggestions is abrasive and you come across as a bit trollish. I have come to believe you are not doing this intentionally and you don't realize how your posts are taken by others.
Many of us that play SI remember a player we knew as Sweeney who we all played with on a few previous games. You have many traits and similarities to your communication style that he had, along with the challenges presented to you in terms of dialog with other players. Despite this, Sweeney was a valuable member of our community and it's troubling to me to think you feel singled out and not a part of the established community.
Re: Claws
Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2016 1:40 pm
by
You are not the first to call be a troll, but the term does imply intent to cause trouble, i am trying to help, however misguided my attempts.
As far as the abrasiveness... I own that as well.
I speak my mind and I don't pull any punches.
Honesty can be quite brutal and I make no apologies for that.
The sad thing is, I do realize how I come across.
But why is the onus on me to change who I am rather than on you to adjust your expectations?
It's not like I play favorites or make personal attacks.
Re: Claws
Posted: Wed Apr 20, 2016 6:34 pm
by
I kind of like the idea of integrating claws into other skills. I see some valid arguments for why claws wouldn't be effective for some tasks, such as lockpicking (which I agree with), but I think allowing skinning with a claw would be pretty cool. I could picture Requiem slicing the skin off of something with his claws. Maybe have it unlock from a high level in skinning before they are familiar enough with it to substitute a claw for a dagger?
Either way, I don't care. Goblins can't use claws.
Buff Goblins.