[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
http://www.shatteredisles.com • Hiding, Pilfering, and Sneaking (oh my?)
Page 1 of 1

Hiding, Pilfering, and Sneaking (oh my?)

Posted: Fri Oct 12, 2012 12:51 pm
by
I wanted to expand on the recent updates regarding these three skills, and thieves in general. Pilfering has been out for awhile now, but it has always been full of issues. I can't tell you how many times I have revisited this skill and spent all night working on it, only to end up pretty much where I started. It pains me to put out anything thief related that isn't working correctly, combat issues aside. Sneaking was an even worse situation. I had all but given up on this skill. I think the problem is I was trying too hard to recreate an ability from another game that I enjoyed, instead of trying to create something new.

After the last two nights of SI-ing, I feel pretty good about both skills. There's always going to be tweaking of success rates, but the structure is there for both. Pilfering now appropriately reveals you from being hidden if you blow your pilfer attempt, or if you are spotted and attacked. Basically Pilfer has two events that can happen if you aren't successful, and two that happen if you are successful. Either way, you have a chance to reveal or a chance to stay hidden. Your overall success rate comes from your skill level, but whether you reveal or not is based on your wisdom (until a later date when an Awareness stat is added), plus another stat you don't see that increases with your hide and sneak skills. Certain races and classes start off higher in this detection stat than others. The amount you steal needs more work to vary more. There's no real advantage currently to hiding while pilfering unless you are targeting a PC. The guards aren't responsive enough yet to catch these things, and we've only barely begun to expand on what the guards can do. Some of you may have seen npc's screaming for help and nearby guards coming to their rescue. I believe I'd also want to see the blown attempts cause your target to attack. There's not much risk there if you fail. These are things to be ironed out as we get into a law system. We've played around with some law functions, but nothing too complex yet. That's a story for another day.

As for sneaking, the big change was making it no longer require you to be hidden. I also took out the rehide attempt once you've moved, making that instead a choice you as a player can make. Sneaking's main purpose is to move into and out of rooms without being detected. Instead of seeing "Thief arrives from the west", a successful sneak displays no message to those around you. If you are successful, you will see a message about quietly moving in a direction. That means your exit and entrance will not be detected. If you fail, you simply move as you normally would, and display the same. No one knows it was a botched sneaking attempt. I'm interested to see if that plays out well, or if I'll need to draw more attention to unsuccessful attempts. Unfortunately, if you are hidden before you sneak, you will reveal yourself from hiding, which everyone will see. It's on the list, but will require some more trial and error.

I think these three skills should now work pretty well with each other. I welcome any readers out there that favor thieves to roll one up and try out these things. We've built a small harbor in the academy that is good for pilfering. Go through the motions and see what seems out of place. Use the BUG command if something seems wrong, IDEA command if you think something needs improvement, and PRAISE command if you like how things currently are. Your feedback is how we get these things right. Thanks to players like Vetis, Kais, and Geel who have been excellent in leaving us detailed notes when they come across things that don't seem right.

My apologies if any 'Snaeks' worked their way into the sneaking details.

Re: Hiding, Pilfering, and Sneaking (oh my?)

Posted: Tue Sep 17, 2013 11:22 pm
by
It's probably no surprise to anyone that the first character I've made is a thief! I've worked mostly with pilfering, hiding, sneaking and close combat thus far. I've been using both the docks and the academy practice yard mostly for this purpose.

I'm finding that NPC perception seems to be a bit high - while only level 8 pilfering at this writting, I seem to get cought by npc's almost every attemp, while the few player picks i've attempted have gone mostly unnoticed (only been cought once so far vs a player - and i've probably picked just about everyone in game at least once, save the one other thief i've met and the few other followers of Itzal floating around). In addition to getting cought by npc's frequently, I seem to rarely even succeed at the attempt, meaning no coins or no 'you come up empty' message. Every player attempt has either resulted in coins or 'you come up empty.' I spend more time leaving and returning to rooms than actually picking the npc pockets. If this is 'working as intended' due to my low level, I could accept that, it just seems that for a low-level training area, npc's should be easier to steal from. Also, the stamina cost on pilfering seems a bit harsh - 3 stamina per attempt while i can swing my dagger all day long and not use any seems wrong.

The issue I have with sneak is that it still doesnt seem to keep the player hidden when moving room to room. Jumping out of the shadows then stealthily leaving seems counter-productive. I'm only level 6 Sneak as of this writting, but have yet to remain hidden when moving room to room - is this my level, or still a known issue with sneak (your original post is almost a year old afterall)?

Re: Hiding, Pilfering, and Sneaking (oh my?)

Posted: Wed Sep 18, 2013 12:45 pm
by
W'ere debating adding a perception stat to players and npcs to better fine tune how skills like pilfer, hide, and sneak work. I've got Hide and Sneak on the list to revisit because of success rate. I'll add Pilfer in too and see if there isn't something universal to the three that I can adjust.