Magic System Questions, Comparisons, and Feedback/Solutions
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2013 4:26 am
Disclaimer: THIS POST IS LONG
Questions:
1. When engaged in combat, does the monsters resistance/damage taken go off of the current spell level of the spell being cast?
2. Is the horrific failure rate on low level spells supposed to be that bad? If so, when does it get better?
3. Does failure rate go up, depending on the difficulty of what you are casting on?
Comparisons VS Melee/Non-Caster:
I feel that the game has an extremely strong bias toward melee classes right now. Looking at skill sets and mechanics, it's pretty hard not to notice. I also understand that Mages are not finished, not that it matters much. I'll explain.
There is 1 basic skill that rules your AR/DR as a melee class. Close Combat. This skill, when raised, will open up new and exciting abilities. However, you will still get uses, AR and DR, from close combat when normally killing whatever. You also get weapons and armor to boost your AR/DR progression. So the better your gear, the better your character. The boosts of these items are pretty significant. So no matter what new skill you get, you are not being majorly penalized for using it, since most of your rolls are vs your close combat and AR. You can miss a swing and there might even be a monster that dodges and parries once in a blue moon.
I'm not sure if there are level restrictions on gear right now, but someone can give a level 1 the best sword and armor they can buy and they can go and hunt stuff that they sure as hell shouldn't be. This might not be rampant now, but it sure will be in the future.
As a Mage, I get to start at level 1 every single time I get a new spell, and let me tell you, my spells branch off like a 500 year old family tree.....This means I get to fail my cast about 60% or more of the time, no matter if I have 300 other combined levels in magic spells. Not only do I fail my casts, I also get to deal with monster natural resistances and resistance saving throws.
This is basically the equivalent of you getting your AR reset every time you equip a new weapon or gain a new ability. It's pure misery.
This applies to all of my other "Utility" spells as well. While I obviously have not unlocked a ton of the later spells, all the utility spells I have right now are basically worthless, minus my FTG spell.
I highly doubt that the utility abilities that melee are unlocking right now, are even close to being as bad as what I'm seeing. There are absolutely 0 reasons for me to go back to my old spells, the ones that unlocked the newer spells. They are now just clutter taking up my spell list.
Armor raising my DR means almost nothing. No Mage is going to sit and level close combat to get horrible DR returns, instead of casting magic. Mage shields are giving .5DR per level and do not absorb any damage.
I have nothing to use to boost my main form of attack.
::EDIT:: Faran brings up a point that I totally forgot about(thanks). Thanks to no movement in combat, Mages are forced to sit there and just take hit, after hit, after hit, while melee get to dodge and parry/shield and have high DR to make the MOB miss. This, coupled with not being able to wear any decent armor, is so crippling, that I can't even begin the fathom how badly I'm going to get destroyed in later levels.
Feedback on other issues:
1. Spell trees are far too big and I don't know why they branch off into 10 different categories. If this stays the way it is, I'll be leveling at least quadruple the number of skills that non-casters have to level. Which means faaaaaaaar more time invested, for less pay out.....
2. Spells fail way too much compared to how often a melee of the same level misses. This is probably due to me casting my new level 5 DD, even though I have 30+ levels in other DD's.
3. Armor is absorbing far too much damage. The 200 DB bronze armor was absorbing roughly 50% of my damage or 14-15 points of it. Not sure if it goes off % or a static number. But going from 24 damage to 12 damage for just 200 seems really, really, off to me.
Possible solutions:
1. Condense all spells into only a few schools and fix the way new, higher level spells, act vs mobs and players.
2. Make spells evolve once they reach the new branch. There's no reason why I should have 30 lesser versions of my DD.
3. If you think the spell trees re-starting us at level 1 every time we get something new is OK, then give us a weapon to wield that lowers our spell failure rates.
4. Fix armor damage absorption and make materials that armor and weapons are made from, require a certain level of proficiency to use. Cause it's going to get abused.
5. At some point, most people are going to have an encounter with human PvP. Either from a player, or an NPC in a scenario. With no tact or anything else, I don't even see how a caster can even survive a non-caster class at this point in time. I honestly have no solutions to this, other than the person who is losing is going to have to room dodge in order to not die.
::In response to EDIT::6. If no form of combat movement is going to be coded for combat, Mages are going to need a ton of crowd control spells in order to mitigate similar damage that other non-casting classes have. If you think this will negatively effect PvP, then make the spells PvE only.
Thanks for reading. Any suggestions are welcomed.
Questions:
1. When engaged in combat, does the monsters resistance/damage taken go off of the current spell level of the spell being cast?
2. Is the horrific failure rate on low level spells supposed to be that bad? If so, when does it get better?
3. Does failure rate go up, depending on the difficulty of what you are casting on?
Comparisons VS Melee/Non-Caster:
I feel that the game has an extremely strong bias toward melee classes right now. Looking at skill sets and mechanics, it's pretty hard not to notice. I also understand that Mages are not finished, not that it matters much. I'll explain.
There is 1 basic skill that rules your AR/DR as a melee class. Close Combat. This skill, when raised, will open up new and exciting abilities. However, you will still get uses, AR and DR, from close combat when normally killing whatever. You also get weapons and armor to boost your AR/DR progression. So the better your gear, the better your character. The boosts of these items are pretty significant. So no matter what new skill you get, you are not being majorly penalized for using it, since most of your rolls are vs your close combat and AR. You can miss a swing and there might even be a monster that dodges and parries once in a blue moon.
I'm not sure if there are level restrictions on gear right now, but someone can give a level 1 the best sword and armor they can buy and they can go and hunt stuff that they sure as hell shouldn't be. This might not be rampant now, but it sure will be in the future.
As a Mage, I get to start at level 1 every single time I get a new spell, and let me tell you, my spells branch off like a 500 year old family tree.....This means I get to fail my cast about 60% or more of the time, no matter if I have 300 other combined levels in magic spells. Not only do I fail my casts, I also get to deal with monster natural resistances and resistance saving throws.
This is basically the equivalent of you getting your AR reset every time you equip a new weapon or gain a new ability. It's pure misery.
This applies to all of my other "Utility" spells as well. While I obviously have not unlocked a ton of the later spells, all the utility spells I have right now are basically worthless, minus my FTG spell.
I highly doubt that the utility abilities that melee are unlocking right now, are even close to being as bad as what I'm seeing. There are absolutely 0 reasons for me to go back to my old spells, the ones that unlocked the newer spells. They are now just clutter taking up my spell list.
Armor raising my DR means almost nothing. No Mage is going to sit and level close combat to get horrible DR returns, instead of casting magic. Mage shields are giving .5DR per level and do not absorb any damage.
I have nothing to use to boost my main form of attack.
::EDIT:: Faran brings up a point that I totally forgot about(thanks). Thanks to no movement in combat, Mages are forced to sit there and just take hit, after hit, after hit, while melee get to dodge and parry/shield and have high DR to make the MOB miss. This, coupled with not being able to wear any decent armor, is so crippling, that I can't even begin the fathom how badly I'm going to get destroyed in later levels.
Feedback on other issues:
1. Spell trees are far too big and I don't know why they branch off into 10 different categories. If this stays the way it is, I'll be leveling at least quadruple the number of skills that non-casters have to level. Which means faaaaaaaar more time invested, for less pay out.....
2. Spells fail way too much compared to how often a melee of the same level misses. This is probably due to me casting my new level 5 DD, even though I have 30+ levels in other DD's.
3. Armor is absorbing far too much damage. The 200 DB bronze armor was absorbing roughly 50% of my damage or 14-15 points of it. Not sure if it goes off % or a static number. But going from 24 damage to 12 damage for just 200 seems really, really, off to me.
Possible solutions:
1. Condense all spells into only a few schools and fix the way new, higher level spells, act vs mobs and players.
2. Make spells evolve once they reach the new branch. There's no reason why I should have 30 lesser versions of my DD.
3. If you think the spell trees re-starting us at level 1 every time we get something new is OK, then give us a weapon to wield that lowers our spell failure rates.
4. Fix armor damage absorption and make materials that armor and weapons are made from, require a certain level of proficiency to use. Cause it's going to get abused.
5. At some point, most people are going to have an encounter with human PvP. Either from a player, or an NPC in a scenario. With no tact or anything else, I don't even see how a caster can even survive a non-caster class at this point in time. I honestly have no solutions to this, other than the person who is losing is going to have to room dodge in order to not die.
::In response to EDIT::6. If no form of combat movement is going to be coded for combat, Mages are going to need a ton of crowd control spells in order to mitigate similar damage that other non-casting classes have. If you think this will negatively effect PvP, then make the spells PvE only.
Thanks for reading. Any suggestions are welcomed.