Page 1 of 3
Stamina
Posted: Thu Oct 03, 2013 9:49 pm
by
Ok, I already made a post about the stamina cost of combat, but I also just noticed that the stamina cost to pilfering has actually been INCREASED to 4 per attempt. I strongly suggest lowering of all stamina costs across the board. Sitting around waiting on stamina regen slows down all gameplay for everyone, and in the cases of PVP, gives a clear advantage to anyone with access to a vigor spell.
Re: Stamina
Posted: Thu Oct 03, 2013 10:02 pm
by
Then why have classes that get a vigor spell? There are checks and balances. The checks are in place we just need to find the balance. Offering different weapons that use different amounts of stamina might be a better solution then lowering stamina across the board.
Re: Stamina
Posted: Thu Oct 03, 2013 10:06 pm
by
2 stamina per swing in combat, 4 per attempt at pilfering, 3 per attempt at hiding, 3 per room sneaking... I'm dead in the water half the time. I'm not advocating removing all stamina costs. Lowering across the board, even for casters would balance things out a bit. I can't even hunt or practice abilities effectively right now. It's pretty harsh as things stand right now.
Re: Stamina
Posted: Thu Oct 03, 2013 10:23 pm
by
Disguise has a pretty hefty stamina cost as well. I believe it was either 5 or 10. Four to pilfer is a lot. Climbing has 4 or 5. A cost of 2 for a 2-hander is fine just don't see a dagger with the same drain.
IMO, getting daggers to 1 or no ftg needs to be pretty high on the to-do list. Not very newbie friendly at the moment.
Re: Stamina
Posted: Thu Oct 03, 2013 10:27 pm
by
diguise is indeed 10 per attempt. I thought that was pretty harsh too.
Re: Stamina
Posted: Thu Oct 03, 2013 10:47 pm
by
For something like pilfering I can see a high penalty when you pilfer from a PC. Victims of theft currently have no recourse to take against a thief. The thief has virtually nothing to fear from stealing from someone. A long delay or high stamina cost should be in place.
However, against an NPC I do not think that is practical to levy a harsh penalty because it makes the skill impossible to train effectively. Can PC's and NPC's be treated differently when it comes to something like pilfering? Can there be two sets of rules coded into the game?
Re: Stamina
Posted: Fri Oct 04, 2013 10:45 am
by
Basic melee combat with small or medium-sized weapons really shouldn't be that fatiguing to an experienced user. Swinging a giant airplane wing for big damage should be more tiring. Any 'special' attacks, such as Shadowstrike, Backstab, etc should carry a stamina drain. The trade-off being, higher damage potential or more potent skills are more taxing on your body therefore must be used more judiciously.
Example: I was in PVP last night with Doxx and we stood toe-to-toe beating on one another for a good 10 minutes. I'm not entirely sure what skill he was using to hit me, but it looked like martial arts and/or divine magic, while I was swinging a Simple Iron Sword. I had to stop and pick my nose every 60-90 seconds or so to let my stamina regen so I could continue the fight, meanwhile, he would run out, cast a vig spell, and start beating on me again. As it turns out, both of our damage outputs were pretty pathetic, so neither of us were in any real danger of dying, but the point is, I literally had to stand there and do nothing for half the fight.
All classes should have a basic, low damage, form of combat that requires zero stamina. As it stands now, there really is no efficient way to train and hunting has become excruciating. I agree with a differential on bigger weapons requiring more energy or more specialized skills requiring more significant effort. Close Combat with a dagger or one-handed sword really wouldnt be that taxing to an experienced weapons-user. A compromise might be to have a level-based reduction on stamina use for various skills. Low level spells should become easier to cast at higher levels; a high level fighter should have the stamina to carry on a fight for a prolonged period of time with judicious use of basic combat and specialized abilities.
In the case of Pilfering now costing 4 stamina per attempt, I agree that there should be some limitting factor in my ability to pull coins from your pocket but 4 stamina per attempt is not it. Higher delay would be a great trade-off, unfortunately, as the current system stands, I can still move/walk while in delay from a given skill because of the front-loaded nature of delay in this game. After a certain point, training pickpocketting-like skills in a game like this one becomes quite inefficient without another player, so making the stamina cost only for pvp picks hurts training. Anyone who was part of the thief community in dragon's gate will remember our 'picking circles.' And at high levels, a 'circle' was no longer needed, just a partner. Without those, however, no one would have ever gotten past about level 15 or 20 because it would have been horribly inefficient. My suggestion for this would be to increase the delay AFTER the action has taken place. That way, when you catch me, you have a few seconds to react before I can run off (for the record, thus far I've been a pretty good sport and let my victims have some restitution by standing and fighting and even killing me in 1 case!). Maybe give pilfering a reduction to delay at higher levels.
I'm just not a fan of frustrating barriers to levelling, and the current stamina cost to all skills across the board is just that. I almost didnt sign up for this game because I remember just how many hours I stared a scrolling screen while running through several thousands of uses in various skills in my previous text gaming endeavors. High stamina costs raises that time exponentially. I know you'll all say this is a Role-Playing Game first and we dont need to powertrain to RP, but without mechanics and levels, we might as well not have a game at all and just play out all our interactions on the boards. Also, as someone who classically plays characters that frequently get into conflict with other players, I need to have skills to back up my actions and role play. Conflict is part of role playing; conflict resolution often requires a mechanical means of resolution. Standing around panting, while you beat on me because I'm so exhausted I can't defend myself, is just not fun for either of us. We don't all play heroes that work well with others to save the world! Some of us really enjoy the guile and intrigue of the underworld, making our way by more dasterdly and shady means! Someone's gotta be the villain!
Re: Stamina
Posted: Fri Oct 04, 2013 11:09 am
by
Good post by Natari. For the record I am a Priest and I was using holy strike and yes my damage is pathetic. The thrill and rush you get from PvP was missing from the encounter that Natari is referring to because there was literally no danger to either one of us. Quite frankly I am glad an Orc wandered in because it gave me an "out" to end the the conflict.
Player of Doxx
Re: Stamina
Posted: Fri Oct 04, 2013 1:59 pm
by
I don't think pilfer and disguise should have a stamina penalty at all. I can't think of a reason why putting a hand in a pocket would be more tiring than swinging a long sword. If these abilities need some kind of balancing, then perhaps delays are the better way. Losing a few coins doesn't sound that scary. Now if it was items that would be another matter.
As for weapons and fatigue. The only problem with zero stamna daggers is that you are encouraging people to go sit in skeletons a few hundred hours to train weapons. I'd suggest low cost and high vigor restorative items instead. And they can be tailored exactly to how hard the staff wants things to be for melee users. I'd also suggest they be consumables like herbs or roots or something. This is simply because it's less irritating for melee users, as they don't have a bunch of empty bottles to drop.
Re: Stamina
Posted: Fri Oct 04, 2013 2:37 pm
by
I'd be in support of consumables that restore ftg but I would caution against them being too convienient or effective so they do not interfere with the niche of spellcasters that get a vigor spell. I'd hate to see vigor spells be rendered obsolete due to consumables being too effective or too readily available.
Keep in mind vigor spells fail quite often and vigor potions do not. You could potentially have a melee'r that is more efficient at keeping himself vigored using potions or consumables than a caster using his spells or prayers.