Page 1 of 1
weapon dmg
Posted: Fri Jan 13, 2012 4:33 am
by
after testing out an iron two handed bludgeon i started noticing something. when compared to other weapons blunt weapons seem to be suffering and i am not sure what is really causing this.
i have been monitoring my dmg out put intensively for awhile. and at first i just thought the wpn rng dmg was huge, then i started noticing that different mobs result in different dmg out put. now i am not really sure the cause of this, but some of the mobs i hunted with my new two hander i was doing constantly between 3-30 pts of dmg.
but then on other things, even mobs that are sopposed to be weaker i wasn't breaking 15, and was avg 1-12 and this is after spending literally hours in each area testing it out. all over the place on numerous mobs
now i dont really know mechanics and things like that but i will say the numbers just don't add up. and i am not sure if it has to do with mobs natural armour values, the fact that it is blunt damage and not some type of piercing/cutting dmg but something clearly isn't set right.
and for me it really isn't all about the numbers and i know hunting areas have been worked on alot recently and people are putting in alot of time and effort to make things right
Re: weapon dmg
Posted: Fri Jan 13, 2012 8:43 am
by
I thought different mobs were affected differently by the different weapon types. For example a blunt would do more damage to a skeleton. I am not sure if this is true or not but for some reason I think I remember hearing that someplace.
Re: weapon dmg
Posted: Fri Jan 13, 2012 10:36 am
by
I think right now it is more about what you are hunting than the weapons themselves. You all started with weapons that were clearly doing too much damage so changes had to be made. We scaled down the damage of all the weapons and got them into an order we like, but that alone doesn't fix the problem. We're working our way through the mobs now to get them in line with this damage so I'm not surprised that you are seeing these results.
We've started on the low end of mobs and are working toward the top. Even with the changes we've already done we're seeing places we have to go back and make adjustments. I know that's not a lot of encouragement for those of you out there hunting now, but I believe the end result will be worth it. We're finally getting some order to our weapons and our mobs and from there it will be a lot easier to make minor adjustments to each. Getting all these weapons stored in our system so we can make changes that impact all types of that weapon, not just one, has been the biggest gain. This means that if you spend a lot of money on a weapon that isn't up to spec yet, you don't have to throw it away or get a new one. When the changes are made, your weapon will be affected same as the ones still in the stores.
Same goes for the mobs. Just getting them in a working order from golems to ice trolls has been beneficial and now as we go forward, the changes we make affect all copies of the same mob, not just one.
Something to keep in mind however is that you all are in the 20 and under range as far as your combative abilities go. That's a long way from 100 and your max potential. So while I understand the frustration of having to deal with constant changes to your weapon damage, some stuff may not be as off as you think. We'll know more by next wednesday's scheduled update and will be constantly working on the mobs up until then.
Re: weapon dmg
Posted: Fri Jan 13, 2012 10:47 am
by
Can you clear up some confusion that I have regarding weapon levels and combative ability level, what's the difference?
Does weapon level affect damage and combative ability affects OR/DR? I'm not exactly clear how the two are supposed to work. I've had some pretty wonky OR/DR raises that seemed out of place. I am not at home, so I don't have the exact numbers in front of me but it was not following the standard 6OR/4DR that Barbarians appear to be getting.
Re: weapon dmg
Posted: Fri Jan 13, 2012 10:57 am
by
Your AR/DR comes directly from your Combative Ability. Raising your individual weapons factors into your success rate, but this only means a successful chance to hit, instead of a flat out failure from the start. After that you still have your AR vs your target's DR that factors into your hit and skills like dodge, parry, and shield block that can negate your successful attempt. Your stats (strength, dex) factor into that equation as well but I'm not sure I can properly explain that part. I'm not sure if that helps any, but the best way I can simplify it is by saying weapon skill gets you the successful chance to hit someone, and then your AR + stats against your opponents DR decides what kind of success that will end up being.
We've gone this route instead of AR/DR for individual weapon skills because swinging a weapon is swinging a weapon. It's always bothered me that I can hack with a sword and be really good at it, but then pick up a club and my AR (or OR in that case) was completely different. Sure the styles might be different, but I'm still swinging a weapon at someone.
As for the variety in your gains, I'm not really sure why that is but I can confidently say it's likely a buggy weapon or another error we've overlooked. It's certainly not intended. We're still ironing out some random stuff that seems to keep showing up, like weapons that lower or raise your AR.
Hope this helps!
Re: weapon dmg
Posted: Fri Jan 13, 2012 4:39 pm
by
think i am starting to understand it a bit more. though it sounds fairly complex i am starting to see how weapon skill ties in with the overallcombat ability.
kindah like if you master slashing weapons, your skill level will tie in to the overall factor and calculate out to more damage based on how well you hit them, though at the same time your ability on the field of battle still allows you to pick up ah club and beat faces if the need arises.
and i am sure the same goes for them, so the higher your DR vs their AR and weapon abilites determines how well they hit you and the mitigation of the armour takes care of the rest. starting to see the larger picture and understanding it a bit more helps knowing how things work. hehe,
though i certainly didn't mean to sound like such a whine ass in my first post. guess thats what i get for posting after a few strong drinks. haha
Re: weapon dmg
Posted: Fri Jan 13, 2012 7:38 pm
by
In order to keep this all together with my previous thread; i'll add onto my previous comment here.
The following numbers are pulled from a Gavial Barbarian. I didnt pay much attention to it at the time, so I did not get the levels but here is the AR/DR progression I got probably starting around level 6 or so.
40/89 46/101 46/111 52/115 54/115
I also have a Vukasin Barbarian and so far, that character seems to be following an orderly 4/6 progression rate per combative level.
This is another example of something wonky. This is a newly rolled Vukasin Barbarian.
Strength : 25/25
Intelligence : 8 /25
Dexterity : 12/25
Constitution : 8 /25
Charisma : 16/25
Wisdom : 11/25
You are ##### the Novice, a male Vukasin Barbarian.
You are 7 feet 8 inches tall and weigh 263 pounds.
You are carrying 4 of a maximum 1659 pounds.
You are in perfect health.
You are fully rested.
You are in quiet mode.
Attack: 33 | Defense: 89 | Position: Standing
Is 33 AR normal for a freshy rolled character? Does getting a perfect strength roll have anything to do with that? What does quite mode mean?