Dragon Thoughts

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
CoralScribe
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 122
Joined: Mon Jan 20, 2014 6:11 pm

Dragon Thoughts

Post by CoralScribe »

It may be the year of the horse, but for SI it may yet be the year of the dragon. While looking at the general board post, I thought I'd write a little manifesto about dragons, but it went off topic for that thread, so I thought I'd start another thinking about how dragons might be implemented and the challenges that devs will have to face with a natural attack-based multiphase class. This is part suggestion, part thought process, so bear with me.


You Start Weak but End Strong (Mechanics)

Dragons as juveniles should be more limited or weaker than most other classes. Besides the fact that they represent a child in terms of the race, there needs to be some drawback to play a dragon, or you will have a glut of them. Starting with only bite is an excellent drawback. No magic, either. And they are of course limited in what they can do crafting-wise (but this should not be completely ignored or absolved, because dragons should have more than biting to interact with the world). It would be perfectly acceptable to say they cannot claw even if they have a quadruped form because the wing muscles are heavy and they prevent you from adequately stabilizing your foreclaws, or that the claws have not hardened because of what the gods or the Shattering did to them. In addition, I don’t think that flight is necessary at this stage and could be another drawback to being a dragon. It could be that dragons need magic to fly in some respect. Even if you go with a protodrake-styled dragon, having wings means you could still claw – with your talons, like every other bird of prey does. That form does not explain reasoning as to why they cannot claw and I think it is unnecessary to explain why a quadruped cannot hold weapons.

Passing from juvenile, dragons are sub-adults. We are starting to come into our own. We should be on equal footing with most classes at this point. We have now been committed to a god and may see some magic as a result, but it should still be quite limited. Perhaps we should have only a spell or two, and certainly nothing that can restore stamina. If we do not have flight due to lacking magic as described above, we should get it now. This may be the point where we get claw attacks as well. So, what would claws really get us? In most of the other games, a claw attack meant two attacks, one for both claw. In game terms, this would be dual-wield. The placement of when we get claw attacks will need to be determined not by levels, but by when we actually ascend (see All You Need Is Love), so this will require some careful consideration. Another option is to have claws unlock now, and that dual-claw attacks unlock in full adult phase. We may get a weak version of an elemental breath attack. Our natural armor should be around steel or higher at this phase.

Adult phase! What we’ve all been waiting for. At this point we now should exceed most classes individually. If we did not get dual-claw, we should get it now. We should probably get another attack, like tail-whip or wings, which work as compliment skills as we understand them today: high cost, but effective openers or something of that nature. Our spells should be much more advanced at this point, perhaps even including a stamina-restoring spell. Our natural armor should reach the highest level possible at this point. Our breath should be our strongest weapon now, the full version if we got a lesser version in the last form.

I have not played a character with natural attacks, so I do not know if they have any relationship between the natural attack and close combat. I do not believe they should, at the very least not work that way for dragons/wyverns, assuming they do. Not only would that mean that the dragons would have new skills that are immediately too useful, which makes no sense (I don’t know how to claw someone if I’ve been using my teeth this whole time!), it would leave a player with less he feels he can work on between phases. I know that many of these suggestions will be an excessive challenge to code, and I do not envy you for that, but I am hopeful that this is the direction the underlying skills are going.


All You Need is Love (Ascension and Community)

Shattered Isles is an RP game. No question of it. It is why I and I believe most of us love it. Ascension is not, and never should be, tied to the level of a character, but by his connection to other players and to the world at large. Not only does this mean you cannot powerlevel a dragon to sub-adult, it helps to build community and connections, and gives players time and incentive to interact with the world’s story at large, which is exceptionally healthy for a small population game.

That said, the timing of when ascensions come has to be considered for access to skills as well as for the wealth of social clout a dragon and his elven ascendant partner have in the community. I remember in Da-Gate, it was one year, minimum, for the first ascension. It is a lot of time, and I hope that similar time-restrictions are put into place and made public so that dragons know and understand their place in the world and not just see it as a means to power in the end. But on the other hand, dragon-players don’t want to feel weak and cuddly, and seeing there are dragon scale armor on the crafting site suggests that killing dragons might actually be profitable and useful for people in-game – so leaving them weak can also limit enjoyment as they are forced to hide and not interact with others for fear of being skinned alive. Suggestions for countering this latter concern may be that dragon scales aren’t strong enough until sub-adult, which gives juveniles breathing room and allows them to safely interact and learn who and who not to trust, etc. Once ascension occurs, though, they become free game. I imagine there will be some fun psychological games played by our ‘peds upon our dragons, and it could lead to good RP as well. Moreover, freeing juveniles from fear of being hunted also moves back the timer for game balance too – when they get enough skills to be equal to the classes that will hunt them, then it becomes a fair (mostly) contest.


Will You Buy Me a House of Gold? (Economy)

There’s a third tier to look at for dragons, and that is wealth accumulation. Dragons don’t buy armor or weapons. They don’t repair those things. They have no need for clothes or most decorative body wear. Perhaps this is why dragons are so rich in most fantasy settings!

So, how do we prevent Drag-flation in the economy? There needs to be some system in place that gets money out of dragons as well as bipeds. Having a hoard that can be paid into and linking that to certain skills like breath weapons or magic or even the toughness of a dragon’s scales, are some options that can help combat this scourge. I imagine this would/will be a coding nightmare however, unless devs can somehow create something like ranged combat with hoard points coming out instead of arrows.


How Would You Train Your Dragon?

These are some of the ideas and challenges that the devs have ahead of them, and I'm sure they've considered all of them by now, but it can't hurt to mention it and have a discussion as dragons will soon become the focus. Hope it is helpful.
......./\.......
____/__\____
..../......\.....

**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**
Verlon
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 23
Joined: Sun Jan 26, 2014 9:47 am

Re: Dragon Thoughts

Post by Verlon »

Firstly I have always seen dragons as quadruped's.

dragons phase 1: Give them wings or don't not really a big deal but they can not fly. No claw attack, no magic, no BW. Bite only, that's fine. However I believe that the ftg use for biting would need work to equal out with someone being able to use a dagger or low ftg use item. Maybe uber stamina or something?

dragons phase 2: They gain flight, and claws,

dragons phase 3: They gain magic and a breath weapon.

You could mix any of the abilities up anyway you want. It really wouldn't matter to me.

Another part of dragons I would love to have looked into is dragon kin.

Many different fantasy worlds there have been other dragon races as well. Anything from drakes to dracos independent of Dragons themselves. Nothing to do with phasing.

There are many possibilities.
User avatar
Aumnren
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 245
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2013 8:18 pm

Re: Dragon Thoughts

Post by Aumnren »

As others have said, I like the quadrupedal dragons to separate them from wyverns. If you need, you can give them smaller, skimpy arms like that of a T-Rex, so as to dodge the whole "claw attack". Their arms could be long enough to operate doors and chests, but not strong enough to constitute an attack - at least not in the early stages. Coral had a good idea above in that a claw attack could develop, but only after some time, and a lot of it.

And I have an idea for a way dragons could blend in while in a younger stage. Perhaps they could get "disguise" in order change themselves into a humanoid form and avoid detection. They could wear armor and hold weapons like a normal humanoid could, though they couldn't use the weapons - or only use Unarmed combat while in humanoid. This way, it would allow dragons to quietly scout out for a mage to reveal themselves to, while hiding from any wyverns and others who would love to skin them.

Along with this, it'd be nice to hide the dragon character from the WHO list, so no one is sure if there are any dragons present, and who they are.

In my opinion, the maturity curve for dragons should be close to what Coral suggested in that it takes a long time to fully mature the creature. By comparison, wyverns should be a lot quicker, and a lot more powerful in the early stages, only surpassed later when a dragon ascends and gains an element.

Are dragons planned to be an open class? Or will there be restrictions, such as an application much like the conclave, perhaps a minimum time requirement for playing, or both?
Teef
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 291
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:39 pm

Re: Dragon Thoughts

Post by Teef »

skimpy T-rex arms?

Image
User avatar
Aumnren
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 245
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2013 8:18 pm

Re: Dragon Thoughts

Post by Aumnren »

Yeah. Just like that.

Could be longer though, but still small and too frail to use as a weapon.
CoralScribe
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 122
Joined: Mon Jan 20, 2014 6:11 pm

Re: Dragon Thoughts

Post by CoralScribe »

I definitely agree that a disguise function should exist for a dragon, possibly in second stage when they start needing it, though it could be something they start training early. I suspect that humanoid disguise would be quite difficult to do code-wise, which is why they want to avoid letting dragons be able to equip weapons in the first place. I suspect the dragon 'disguise' may end up as some type of illusion spell, but we'll have to see what they come up with in this regard.

As for whether or not they are an open class, I certainly can't speak for the devs, but in the olden days of Da-Gate, they were open. Based on SI's website's description of the race, dragons only ascend into the next phase with the blessing of their God or Goddess - translation: GMs are the ones who decide when and if a dragon ascends, which is also how it used to be. As a result, you can keep it open just fine, but not everyone makes it to the end, and difficulty of class in early levels and the need for a partner race (elves) keeps the racial numbers a bit more balanced.
......./\.......
____/__\____
..../......\.....

**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**
User avatar
Snaek
SI Staff Member
Posts: 828
Joined: Wed Aug 25, 2010 4:36 pm

Re: Dragon Thoughts

Post by Snaek »

What a great faith restoring thread! Sometimes the bugs and fixing things so that no one gains an unfair advantage distract us from all the amazing things we set out to accomplish in the first place. I read through the other dragon topic in general discussion as well, but will address them both here in one place. It's certainly a topic I love to debate as much as you all and there's nothing wrong with a healthy discussion.

I can tell you that before we ever crossed the limitations of natural attacks, we did not want claws for dragons and we didn't want them wielding weapons. There's a lot of things we took away from previously played games that featured dragons, but not all of them are things we want to carry out here. each critical decision though we stop and ask why other games approached dragons the way they did and if we come to the same conclusion then so be it. We're not interested in carrying something over simply because it was popular elsewhere.

I am pleased to see so many think of dragons as we do; quadruped's with wings. Talons are to be expected, but we think of them the same as we do vukasin claws. More of an appearance feature than a mechanical one. Same with wing claws. This works better when your dragon only has two legs and uses its wings as a way climb and maneuver long the ground. Think Reign of Fire dragons. Ours would look more like Saphira from Eragon, if anyone has seen that. slightly less function with the foreclaws though. I think we can make it work as far as picking things up with them while still blocking hands and arms from being wearable locations. Much of the body slots on a dragon would end up being unwearable, though we of course want to leave some options so that you can stand out from other dragons. It's a thin line.

As far as skills go, bite is what we, and all of you, seem to imagine them starting with. Originally I was fine with also giving them flight, but I like the suggestions here and elsewhere of pushing that back as an ability gained. We'll have to see how it plays out. Magic is the easiest thing to develop with age. I'm personally still on the fence about spells as an unaligned juvenile. I feel like there would be just a couple of spells that would always be a part of dragons and depend less or not at all on the elements. Something from within. As you grow and become more connected with an element, your magical ability would also increase. Instead of claws, we really wanted their breathe attack to be the next milestone to achieve. We have the basic structure in place for fire, ice, gas, and lightning breath attacks. We have two versions of this. One for targeting a specific person, and one for unleashing your nasty breath on everyone in the room. This is all very manageable with what we currently have in place.

The tail lashing attack we wanted to limit to Wyverns, with an outside shot of Gavials though that may be a balancing issue in itself with them already having bite. A battle for another day. Wyverns would also have bite, but instead of magic we are pretty close to giving them mind based attacks and removing their ability to speak. They have no arms at all and only two legs to go with their wings. They face more difficult challenges as far as picking up loot goes, or anything else that requires hands. The up side is we have two round creators who lack arms and have been able to experience first hand what some of those limitations may be.

I do like the suggestions on ways to try and slow down the inevitable dragon riches. We absolutely plan to allow them to "build" their own lairs. We've got some areas in mind for this already. I think we could come up with a way to pay to increase their armor, though the IC explanation of that would be interesting.

As far as being hunted, A juvenile has more of a leathery skin than scales at that age, so they are of little worth to collectors and hunters. Now if you want to put the effort into trapping and keeping a dragon hostage until they are of age to slaughter, that's on you. Some more debate would be needed on how valuable and useful their newly developed scales would be as a sub-adult dragon.

We do plan to have npc dragons as well in various forms. Some more sentient than others. How exactly these dragons will react to PC dragons remains to be seen. Even how PC dragons deal with each other is an issue to debate. I personally would like to see more conflict and disputes over territory than any kind of mutual dragon kinship. There's exceptions to that of course and I dont mean to suggest a group of dragons (is there a name for a group of dragons? Is this an opportunity to come up with our own name for it for SI?) can't come together with a common interest, perhaps most easily done with dragons of the same element. We're all for conflict.

Of course wyverns and dragons do not get along, but we have not really gotten into why that is or what their connection is. It's something we are still piecing together as the behind the scenes history develops. Keep in mind that even though we've written hundred of pages of notes on our history and lore, things often change based on how they are perceived by the players. We often overlook a detail thinking it is not important to the story only to see players focusing on it like it's the most important part of all! This all goes into shaping their history. It wasn't until someone asked which races existed before the Shattering that we realized we didn't know when and where Wyverns came from.

Anyway, it's a topic I am most happy to discuss as is the rest of the staff. We have a solid idea of what we want, but we aren't quick to dismiss any of your suggestions. We may not see claws in our future, but that doesn't rule them out completely. They could very well come in those later stages in life. Who knows? Great topic. Hope to see it continue.
CoralScribe
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 122
Joined: Mon Jan 20, 2014 6:11 pm

Re: Dragon Thoughts

Post by CoralScribe »

I will admit, I am not certain why there is such a reluctance to look at adding claws to dragons, but it may have a little bit to do with the image problems I’m having. Saphira and the Reign of Fire dragons are rather different animals, dealing specifically with the placement of the wing. Saphira is the ‘traditional’ dragon – quadruped, wings on the back. The Reign of Fire dragon has wings on the forearms, much like a bat. These are incongruent images. I mentioned the WoW protodrakes, but Everquest also had a very similar animal to the Reign of Fire dragons, called Drakota. These are basically lesser dragons that were hatched quickly, but never became or could be considered true dragons. Obviously, SI is not either of these worlds, but there are likely to be many preconceived notions existent in players coming to the game looking to play a dragon. I am certainly guilty of this, and gladly so.

As for the breath weapons over claws in second form, that is fine with me and makes plenty of sense in this elemental-enriched world. Perhaps the change to this drakota-state occurred as part of the Shattering or the loss of the dragon’s powers, but the final ascension itself could be the return to the more Saphira-styled dragon, at which point they could claw.

And tail-lashing is fine to limit to wyverns for that reason. I could see psionic ways of picking things up for wyvern.

As for the spells, I personally want to say that there is innate magic in dragons and they are able to use some sort of magic off the bat, but in Shattered Isles, the story as I understand it thus far does not lend itself well to this idea. Magic and power (and possibly form) has been taken from dragons by the gods. Dragons have suffered a crushing blow to their pride and to their power, and now must be subservient to the gods in order for the hope of reclaiming what they have lost. I’ll admit, this kind of dragon will be exceptionally challenging for me to RP correctly, because dragons have since antiquity been conflated with the vices (or virtues!) of pride and greed. And for good reason! In most stories, dragons are godlike beings compared to most lesser-creatures.

That said, there’s room for them to have magic. The ‘hoard mages’ mentioned in the racial page help the earliest stages of ascension (pre-rolling of character it seems?), which means they must already been infused with some magic. And since this magic is likely to be from an arcanist or diviner - mixed elemental bags which may have been similar to how dragons were prior to Shattering - any type of magic or magic specific to dragons, could have already been infused into the dragon. So definitely have some sort of low level spells, but I can only speculate at the moment what those might be, as we lack firsthand knowledge of those two classes.

A group of dragons is a Flight of Dragons. /archaic reference~
......./\.......
____/__\____
..../......\.....

**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**
User avatar
Aumnren
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 245
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2013 8:18 pm

Re: Dragon Thoughts

Post by Aumnren »

Magic and power (and possibly form) has been taken from dragons by the gods. Dragons have suffered a crushing blow to their pride and to their power, and now must be subservient to the gods in order for the hope of reclaiming what they have lost. I’ll admit, this kind of dragon will be exceptionally challenging for me to RP correctly, because dragons have since antiquity been conflated with the vices (or virtues!) of pride and greed. And for good reason! In most stories, dragons are godlike beings compared to most lesser-creatures.
I thought the dragons were hunted down, almost to extinction - by hunters for their skins and by wyverns so they could feed off their magic. When they fled, the greater magic went with them, leaving the mages only as a shell of what they once were.

So it was less the gods who drive them out, and more the mortals, which would still be that crushing blow to the pride mentioned by Coral. I would prefer that the mortals casted dragons out - either in fear or greed Having gods do it seems a bit too…easy. And doesn't help to shape the character of the world as much. Perhaps the gods shielded the dragons from the mortal world until a time in which they could again be released - or maybe when the world needed them most (DUN DUN DUN).

I do think that dragons should get some basic magic. Seeing as with their leaving they took the greater magic, it means that the greater magic probably rests somewhere within them. It's no so far a stretch then to think they'd have some lingering magic still in their blood. As to what spells, I don't really think there could be any "neutral" aligned spells that all dragons get. You might be able to randomly assign them an elemental attack spell, and then a random vigor and shield. When they finally join up with a mage, they become fully aligned, loosing their affinity to the other elements, and gaining only one.

As for martial abilities, looks like:

wyverns get bite, (poisoned) tail slap, and psionic abilities
Dragons get bite, basic spells (more advanced later), breath weapon

(as a side note, having wyverns use psionic abilities to interact with the world and even communicate with others would be krunk)

Unless claw did something different from bite (rending damage?), I don't see much use mechanics-wise, in including it. I mean, you'd still get stamina raises, I suppose, every 5 lvls, and a shot at a stat raise. I could see use, however, if damage type and resistances were put in. For instance, bite could do piercing damage, claw could do slashing. Creatures resistant to slashing could be bitten; creatures resistant to piercing could be clawed.

As for the looks and keeping the dragons custom:

I would think that until a dragon picks an element, their skin/scales would be relatively gray, perhaps almost with multicolored hues. Small horns could probably be added, as well as eye color. Harnesses could be added if a dragon allows their companion mage to ride them, or anyone else if they feel particularly generous. If there is any armor made for dragons, it'd probably include only their head. If dragons do have dino arms, they could probably have "shirts" or other forms of rudimentary clothing - or at the least some riggings that have pouches on them where they keep their things.
CoralScribe
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 122
Joined: Mon Jan 20, 2014 6:11 pm

Re: Dragon Thoughts

Post by CoralScribe »

Aumnren wrote:
I thought the dragons were hunted down, almost to extinction - by hunters for their skins and by wyverns so they could feed off their magic. When they fled, the greater magic went with them, leaving the mages only as a shell of what they once were.

So it was less the gods who drive them out, and more the mortals, which would still be that crushing blow to the pride mentioned by Coral. I would prefer that the mortals casted dragons out - either in fear or greed Having gods do it seems a bit too…easy. And doesn't help to shape the character of the world as much. Perhaps the gods shielded the dragons from the mortal world until a time in which they could again be released - or maybe when the world needed them most (DUN DUN DUN).

If they took the great magic with them, what exactly is 'the great magic' and why do dragons have it in the first place? And if dragons were so powerful and had this magic, how did they get hunted down to extinction?

The latter question is usually answered by attrition in most fantasy settings - lack of children, long breeding cycles, and starving dragons to death by taking of their habitat and resources. While the Shattering might explain some of it, it may be a combination of factors, both mortals and gods, ganging up on the dragons that led to this outcome. But that begs the question of 'why would the dragons return at all when they could just abscond with elves at random?'

Some clarification on what the gods and/or mortals did to dragons would be exceptionally helpful if that doesn't give away any storyline. Devs?


As for claws, as I have mentioned they are usually dual-wield in other games, so - depending on how dual wield works - it could still be a bonus. I agree that the ability to select slashing over piercing will someday be useful as well, and is another good point.
......./\.......
____/__\____
..../......\.....

**The missive is marked with a crossed-out wave**
Post Reply