[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
http://www.shatteredisles.com • Open and Closed Conclave Meeting notes, 1/22 and 1/29.
Page 1 of 1

Open and Closed Conclave Meeting notes, 1/22 and 1/29.

Posted: Thu Jan 30, 2014 9:19 pm
by
The following are the notes for both the open and closed Conclave meetings.

Open Meeting, the twenty-second day of the first month in the year four-hundred and thirty-six in the Age of Mortals:
The meeting opened with the swearing in of Emissaries Fairuz-Taqqi and Loriel Fisher, of Kaleith and Aerthane, who took their seats at the Conclave table.

Knight Marshal Ydeliah then took the floor and explained the purpose of the meeting, and called upon citizens to bring forth any issues or proposals they had to present.

Citizen Visyn Eldur approached the emissaries and spoke on a proposal for him to help organize tours, hunting activities, and events within the Academy isle. He expressed a desire to generate increased revenue in the grand city of Pearl.

Citizen Blink Walkabout took the floor next and had several petitions for law changes, taking well over an hour to present them all.

His first proposal included a demand that citizens not be required to submit to questioning or follow the Knight Marshals to jail unless they themselves wished, and a desire to see the law codified. Also within was a call that any questioning without a crime being committed require Conclave approval, and if approved the citizen being questioned be given the right to have an emissary, lawyer, or both present during. The third section of the first proposal was an expanded detailing of the second, but demanded no citizen be alone with any member of the guard unless they wished to be under their own volition. Finally, it was requested a requirement for all members of the guard to answer yes or no if asked by any citizen, or lawyer asking on behalf of a citizen, if a crime has been committed.
Citizen Walkabout attempted to blame the entire debacle with executed criminal Geel Brin attempting to murder Knight Marshal Rzolak Verskanst, before the since executed Geel Brin fled, on alleged mistreatment and confusion over the questioning of Zarchang Carnevor. Citizen Walkabout spoke with conviction that if Zarchang Carnevor had not been put in the stocks, executed criminal Geel Brin would have been able to control himself.

Citizen Walkabout said these measures would make the city safer. Knight Marshal Ydeliah questioned whether it was a conflict of interest for citizen Walkabout to be clamoring over any alleged unsafe environment while he represented an admitted attempted murderer.
Citizen Walkabout then demanded the city guard not add persons of interest to wanted posters, and alleged the guard were harassing civilians, this in his second proposal.

The third document presented by citizen Walkabout was a request for burial rites for all prisoners to be executed, to be taken care of by their faith and if they weren't claimed by a faith, to be disposed of in an efficient and proper manner. He demanded the corpse was not consumed, continuing his rumor-spreading about guards eating people. He said this applied only to jail prisoners, and he didn't want to try to stop wide-spread sentient eating of others in the grand city of Pearl.

Finally, citizen Walkabout presented his last two proposals. The first calling for the Conclave to be able to have more leeway on lessening or altering sentences, the only leeway for treason-level crimes to be that of permanent banishment from the city, instead of death or a life in the dungeons. For the defense to be provided evidence by the guard which is to be used against the accused, and for the defense to be given a reasonable amount of time (three days) once the evidence be given, and in those three days be allowed five hours per day with their client alone, without oversight from the city guard.

The second of them called for conclave to be able to decide who are or aren't credible witnesses in appeal hearings.

Citizen Walkabout ended his presentation by saying he only wished to protect accused criminals, not actual ones. Knight Marshal Ydeliah thanked him for his efforts, most of which centered around examples using executed criminal Geel Brin, an admitted attempted-murderer.

Next citizen Wren Sparkler-Raka took the floor, and brought to the conversation the topic of a bath house, an idea she has apparently been collaborating on with Emissaries Tian Tietjen and Faran Fairuz-Taqqi.

Last, citizen Draven Raka approached the emissaries and requested a place within the city guard. He was told this isn't the decision of the Conclave, and he would need to meet with Knight Marshal Ydeliah at a later time.


Closed Meeting, the twenty-ninth day of the first month in the year four-hundred and thirty-six in the Age of Mortals:

The closed meeting began with the first section of the first proposal submitted by citizen Blink Walkabout. Emissary Eleanora O'Hara expressed confusion over the laws being codified, noting all it requires from the citizens is common sense. Several emissaries pointed out that for the sake of the more confused civilians of the populace, it'd make the lives of both the Knight Marshals and citizens easier to have the laws at the very least loosely defined. This modified request, asking for a loose definition of the laws to be codified, passed 5-1-1 with the following vote:

In favor: Emissary Faran Fairuz-Taqqi of Kaleith, Emissary Eleanora O'Hara of Astraeva, Emissary Loriel Fisher of Aerthane, Emissary Isvela Molanhkur of Kaleith, and Emissary Ayderias Clarveu of Aerthane.

Abstained: Emissary Ernest Bouldermoore of Itzal.

Against: Emissary Baelric Makennin of Pyrous.

The next motion to come up for discussion was the second section of citizen Walkabout's first proposal, demanding all questioning by the Knight Marshals be approved by the Conclave, and all citizens being questioned be allowed to have an Emissary, a lawyer, or both present during.

The Conclave agreed there was no way they'd be able to hear all cases for every single questioning, and thus it was scrapped from the proposal. It was further modified to allow for an emissary alone, no lawyers, be allowed in questioning only if immediately available and requested by the citizen. It was passed 6-1 with the following vote:

In favor: Emissaries Loriel Fisher and Ayderias Clarveu of Aerthane, Emissaries Faran Fairuz-Taqqi and Isvela Molanhkur of Kaleith, Emissary Ernest Bouldermoore of Itzal, and Emissary Baelric Makennin of Pyrous.

Against: Emissary Eleanora O'Hara of Astraeva.

Coming next to the table for conversation was the matter of never allowing a citizen to be alone with a member of the city guard unless the civilian wishes. The measure was quickly denied 0-6-1 with the following vote:

Against: Emissaries Ayderias Clarveu and Loriel Fisher of Aerthane, Emissaries Faran Fairuz-Taqqi and Isvela Molanhkur of Kaleith, Emissary Baelric Makennin of Pyrous, and Emissary Eleanora O'Hara of Astraeva.

Abstain: Emissary Ernest Bouldermoore of Itzal.

After this vote, the fourth section of the first proposal from citizen Walkabout was brought up, demanding the guards answer yes or no to any citizen asking whether a civilian being questioned has committed a crime. The Conclave agreed the measure as it stood would be disruptive to a Knight Marshal's investigation and only hinder them. Thus, it was modified for the guard to only answer this question when asked by the citizen being charged or an emissary. The measure passed 6-0-1 with the following vote:

In favor: Emissaries Isvela Molanhkur and Faran Fairuz-Taqqi of Kaleith, Emissaries Ayderias Clarveu and Loriel Fisher of Aerthane, Emissary Baelric Makennin of Pyrous, and Emissary Eleanora O'Hara of Astraeva.

Abstain: Emissary Ernest Bouldermoore of Itzal.


Up next was the second proposal, the issue of burial rites. Emissary Clarveu asked if this was not already in practice, pointing to the process with executed criminal Geel Brin. Emissary Molanhkur told him it isn't required and that Emissary Tian Tietjen, who was detained and unable to make the closed meeting, had to request it in the case of executed criminal Geel Brin. The measure quickly passed 6-0-1 with the following vote:

In favor: Emissary Eleanora O'Hara of Astraeva, Emissary Baelric Makennin of Pyrous, Emissaries Faran Fairuz-Taqqi and Isvela Molanhkur of Kaleith, and Emissaries Loriel Fisher and Ayderias Clarveu of Aerthane.

Abstain: Emissary Ernest Bouldermoore of Itzal.

The Conclave debated the proposal of removing known associates from wanted posters next, in addition to the alleged harassment of these same known associates. Emissary O'Hara asked for the wanted poster for executed criminal Geel Brin, and Emissary Fairuz-Taqqi handed one she had on her to the rest of the conclave to view. Emissary O'Hara expressed confusion, stating it was clear that executed criminal Geel Brin was the only one who was wanted, and it had distinguished the people listed under him were only associates and not criminals themselves.

It was suggested the proposal be modified and requested, since this cannot be a law enforced, that the Knight Marshals instead list the known associates on a separate note set beneath the wanted posters for future criminals. This measure to request of the Knight Marshals passed 6-0-1 with the following vote:

In favor: Emissary Baelric Makennin of Pyrous, Emissary Eleanora O'Hara of Astraeva, Emissaries Loriel Fisher and Ayderias Clarveu of Aerthane, and Emissaries Faran Fairuz-Taqqi and Isvela Molanhkur of Kaleith.

Abstain: Emissary Ernest Bouldermoore of Itzal.


While discussing the next topic, giving the Knight Marshals a suggestion of permanent banishment as a punishment from which to choose in addition to the already given ones of death or long-term stays in the dungeon, Emissary Ernest Bouldermoore stormed out of the room. He was thanked for the foundation moving contributions he had given during the meeting.

After some discussion and disagreement, the measure was modified to request of the Knight Marshals to consider thinking of permanent banishment and taking the recommendation of the Conclave under request. It passed 4-0-2 with the following vote:

In favor: Emissaries Faran Fairuz-Taqqi and Isvela Molanhkur of Kaleith, Emissary Loriel Fisher of Aerthane, and Emissary Baelric Makennin of Pyrous.

Abstain: Emissary Eleanora O'Hara of Astraeva and Emissary Ayderias Clarveu of Aerthane.


The final issue brought up and voted on was the matter of witnesses approved by the conclave to be called on during appeal hearings. As presented it wasn't possible, so modification took place. Emissary Faran Fairuz-Taqqi suggested the Conclave request the Knight Marshal in charge of each investigation make a report, if it doesn't interfere with the investigation, of all witnesses interviewed, the questions asked, and their responses and present it to the Conclave. Emissary Loriel Fisher suggested the Conclave be allowed the testimony of the criminal charged, the Knight Marshal running the investigation, and any associates listed beneath the wanted posters of the criminal.

Upon conclusion of some further debate and discussion, one which found Emissary Makennin leaving in fury as a perceived slight, this modified proposal as fixed by Emissaries Fairuz-Taqqi and Fisher passed 5-0 with the following vote:

In favor: Emissaries Loriel Fisher and Ayderias Clarveu of Aerthane, Emissaries Faran Fairuz-Taqqi and Isvela Molanhkur of Kaleith, and Emissary Eleanora O'Hara of Astraeva.


Ending the meeting there was discussion on citizen Visyn Eldur's proposal, which does not need approval from the Conclave as this is anything the common man can do for their fellow citizens.

It was again noted citizen Draven would need to speak directly to Knight Marshal Ydeliah about joining the guard, this was not a Conclave matter.

Emissary Fairuz-Taqqi briefly mentioned the bath house she is involved in with citizen Sparkler-Raka and Emissary Tietjen, before presenting plans and an inventory she had sketched and detailed on behalf of Jaegis, son of the butcher in the academy, and his request to open a business selling houseware. It was noted the butcher's family already has permission to do business, and as there were no objections to these sketches and the request, all that is left is for the plans to be brought to Merchant Ernest Bouldermoore so he might start construction. It was also suggested Emissary Fairuz-Taqqi, Emissary Tietjen, and citizen Sparkler-Raka meet with Merchant Bouldermoore to discuss the bath house plans, which would be built by and for the city.


This concluded the closed meeting.

-Scribe no. 025 of the Conclave Scribe Office

Re: Open and Closed Conclave Meeting notes, 1/22 and 1/29.

Posted: Fri Jan 31, 2014 3:04 pm
by
The third document presented by citizen Walkabout was a request for burial rites for all prisoners to be executed, to be taken care of by their faith and if they weren't claimed by a faith, to be disposed of in an efficient and proper manner. He demanded the corpse was not consumed, continuing his rumor-spreading about guards eating people. He said this applied only to jail prisoners, and he didn't want to try to stop wide-spread sentient eating of others in the grand city of Pearl.
To clarify, I am opposed to the eating of sentients in the city of Pearl, not only that I am the foremost advocate against it. Indeed, it will be the next piece of legal activism I take up, a ban on the practice in the great city of Pearl. I wrote this law narrowly in order to make sure that it passed, as it was an important religious matter. I did not want the law torn down by an argument on the wider issue of the practice in the city.

dispatched by the law offices of Blink Walkabout