Utility Spell Duration

Comment on the latest changes, State of the Isles addresses, game suggestions, or anything else you'd like to share with the creators and designers of Shattered Isles!
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Utility Spell Duration

Post by Blink »

How about increasing the duration of utility and defense spells based on the level of the spell? Perhaps by 5's or 10's.
User avatar
SquallScribe
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 165
Joined: Fri Sep 20, 2013 9:51 am

Re: Utility Spell Duration

Post by SquallScribe »

I'm not sure how I feel about this. On the one hand, I agree that it would be nice to see some sort of spell improvement based on the strength and effectiveness of the spell at - possibly 10 level - increments (aside from the casting failure reduction) but *duration* can be problematic. Many of our spells I believe increase in potency, at least our attack spells do, as we level them. This is expected. If my third tier attack spell did the same damage at level 50 as it did at level 1 I'd be pretty annoyed, even with the casting failure stabilization. However, utility spell effects work no matter what (there is no variable value of effectiveness for them like damage output) if they are cast successfully and not resisted. Because even a successful cast of a utility spell will still fail on a MOB or PC if it is resisted, unlike halved damage for attack spells on a resist.

A number of our utility spells last at least a minute, and I know the shield spell lasts up to four or five so far. I think this is an acceptable capping duration for any utility spell, unless the duration increments reduce and the level at which they are gained increases past a certain level - just for those die-hards that want to raise a ward spell or a wall spell to level 100 (kill me now, please). I'd also advocate utility spell duration starting off on the lower end (somewhere around a variable of 20 - 30 seconds for the first ten levels) if spell durations were to 'increase' with level of the spell. As it is, successful utility casts appear to already cast at their intended duration no matter the level - within a range of course. The slow spell, for example, will last anywhere from 60 - 90 seconds no matter the level of the spell, though I'm sure higher level spell stabilizes this variable. It's not something I tested, as I only just had the pleasure of using it in PvP for the first time last week.

Furthermore, for someone like priests who currently have no capability to 'dispel' or negate a prayer, and must level certain prayers by waiting for them to wear off, higher spell duration can be excruciating for them. If mage shield/wall spells last four to five minutes, and theirs does as well, then they are waiting four to five minutes to recast and gain uses in that prayer (a worse leveling experience than crafting). Obviously the issue here is not duration, but the fact that priests need an ability to cancel a prayer

Overall, I think utility spell duration increase would be fine if they began at lower durations at lower level (as is not currently the case), and capped at around four to five minutes with the possibility of increasing it maybe by another minute at top level. Let's say four to five minute duration stabilizes at level 50 or 60. Level 75 might provide an additional 10 seconds of duration, level 85 might provide another 10 seconds of additional duration level 95 might provide a third addition, but at 20 seconds of improved duration and finally level 100 would see the last installment of 20 second duration increase for a total of another minute added between levels 75 and 100. So at level 100 you would have a six minute duration utility spell, which I think is appropriate for balancing purposes. You could be more generous and increase top level by two or three more minutes of duration, but I'm not sure how that would affect overall balance and it would have to be considered at a point where we have both melee and casters at that level for real-world application testing.
User avatar
Aumnren
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 245
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2013 8:18 pm

Re: Utility Spell Duration

Post by Aumnren »

Furthermore, for someone like priests who currently have no capability to 'dispel' or negate a prayer, and must level certain prayers by waiting for them to wear off, higher spell duration can be excruciating for them.
Holy shield lasts 9 minutes, which I'm pretty sure is not intentional. That duration makes it a pain in the rear to level, especially since we don't have a 'dispell' prayer.
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Utility Spell Duration

Post by Blink »

They are adding a dispel prayer they said.

Actually, I'd like to see the long term defense spells like air shield go longer than 5 minutes. That's the main one that bothers me. It's forever dropping at inconvenient times on me.
User avatar
Aumnren
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 245
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2013 8:18 pm

Re: Utility Spell Duration

Post by Aumnren »

I don't have many utility prayers at the moment, but having shield last for longer than six minutes seems like a high level spell.

I like Squall's idea on a short duration to begin - shorter even than where it's at now, and a steady increase. Say a minute to start. Every level it could increase 3 seconds to a total of thirty seconds every 10, ending at 6 minutes at level 100.

I suppose the duration should be linked to the potency of the shield. Right now, it seems like the shield (I'm guessing all the shields - mages included) is about 30 DR, increasing very slightly every level (although it's hard for me to tell because my how my DR displays when there's a shield on me is buggy). If it's an additional 1 or 2 every few levels, that brings us to a grand sum of about 70ish DR buff at 100. That's about 12 levels of CC for a combat class made up with a level 100 spell - and the bonus would be nearly negligible in PvP, and vaguely helpful in PvE. A boost that low should probably last for a longer duration - maybe the nine minutes shield currently does.

If shield were more potent, I could see shorter durations. Less potent, longer. One thing is for sure though, to make shield an effective spell, it's DR boost will probably have to go up. I'm guessing AR / DR progression for mages is around 3 / 3 or 4 / 4. Perhaps, starting with your base level of shield, you could add -1 of what the mage would have gotten for DR had they leveled a weapon. So, if the mages' progression is 3 / 3, every level of Shield will raise the base DR buff by 2. If 4 / 4, then 3. Meaning that, at level 100, with a 3 / 3 progression, the DR buff would amount to 200 + base shield buff + weapon. In total, and I'm guessing here, a mage could have a DR of 200 - 300 with everything included.

If a warrior has a 6/6 progression, then at level 100 they'd have 600 + base, so probably near 650. A mage with lvl 100 shield and (if they really invested this much time into a weapon) lvl 100 CC would have 500 DR, maybe up to 550 or so. Honestly though, mages probably won't work CC as much, so I'd expect that number to be about 300 - 400.

Looking at that in perspective, a mage with lvl 100 shield could have the DR to give a level 60 warrior a hard time - and that's with a decently leveled weapon. After that, the mage would only be buying itself time.
User avatar
Blink
Conclave Representative
Posts: 1170
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:51 pm

Re: Utility Spell Duration

Post by Blink »

A mage with max everything could get around 480 dr I estimate. 3/3 progression, and +1 every 2 levels of shield with a base of around 30. 80 base about for race/stats.

I don't think it's intended to ever make the air shield stronger, because it does combine with CC. To me it's not about being more powerful from a higher duration. It's just less irritation from them dropping on me while I hunt.
User avatar
Aumnren
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 245
Joined: Mon Sep 30, 2013 8:18 pm

Re: Utility Spell Duration

Post by Aumnren »

If the shield stays at its current effectiveness, then I wouldn't disagree with an increase in time. But if the time were to decrease, I'd have to argue for an increase in the effectiveness of the shield, else the shield just becomes something you throw on to unlock new spells, or just hunt with.

I'm not sure how this might be affected with absorption spells. I hadn't factored that into my previous calculations. I don't think a mages' DR should anywhere near match the progressions of CC based classes, as AR / DR should probably be the main weakness for spell casters. But it would be nice to see a bump in its effectiveness to make it a viable tool both for PvP and PvE.
User avatar
Swamp Ape
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 341
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 8:50 pm

Re: Utility Spell Duration

Post by Swamp Ape »

I've been holding off on my comments for prayers at least until the prayer update goes in.

Doxx
Doxx ~
Anselm
Posts: 131
Joined: Mon Jan 02, 2012 12:46 am

Re: Utility Spell Duration

Post by Anselm »

Blink wrote:A mage with max everything could get around 480 dr I estimate. 3/3 progression, and +1 every 2 levels of shield with a base of around 30. 80 base about for race/stats.

I don't think it's intended to ever make the air shield stronger, because it does combine with CC. To me it's not about being more powerful from a higher duration. It's just less irritation from them dropping on me while I hunt.
Heya mate,

Doesn't adding a bit of duration make it more powerful, though? Less time to stop and recast, longer periods without sittin'. And always good to remember is that for casters, spells droppin' on ya is part of ya vulnerability, adding to the balance of the game.

I can certainly understand it's an inconvenience or seen as irritatin', course, but ya know you're supposed to have those in high-level huntin'. Gotta be mindful of ya situation, and there's gonna be risk. We're never gonna make high-level areas that don't have some kind of risk.

I can't say whether we'd increase or shorten the duration for shields, it'll be somethin' we discuss, but in the meantime I'd suggest either makin' a recast trigger if ya don't have one, or makin' a timer countdown for yaself.
Teef
Citizen of Archai
Posts: 291
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2013 10:39 pm

Re: Utility Spell Duration

Post by Teef »

Blink wrote: It's just less irritation from them dropping on me while I hunt.
I was about to suggest making triggers or a countdown when I saw this too. I have triggers that auto cast on my mage. So I don't see this as a pressing issue. You're gonna have to stop periodically anyways to either heal up or vig up or go sell or go repair.

If you need help you should post in the client section what you're using and see if anyone is using the same client/app and has suggestions or have already done what you need.
Post Reply