Mend Wounds Feedback.
Posted: Sun Feb 16, 2014 11:09 am
This is my minimal experience with mend wounds.
The first thing that I feel we should base opinions of this skill off of are that it is not meant to be a replacement for actual healing classes/potions/spells in the game.
Also, in another thread we are discussing PvP and whether adjustments need to be made to defensive skills. I think the major issue is Mend Wounds. To me, Mend Wounds should be an emergency or after combat skill. Right now, you can sit down and basically keep pace (along with defensive skills) incoming damage (this is more to PvP than PvE).
Mends wounds should not be able to keep pace with incoming damage from 1 or 2 sources (factoring in defensive skills) until very high levels somewhere 75+. I think the success/fail rates are pretty close to dialed in.
My suggestion is the delay. The primary reason mend wounds works so well is due to the delay. It should not be a lower delay than an actual heal prayer (which is 4 seconds). As a matter of fact, at low levels it should be much higher and this would counterbalance all of the issues above. Somewhere in the 8 to 10 second delay range at low levels.
I am not sure that skills have the ability to lower the delay the higher you get in levels with the current code base, so if not then it should go to a 5 second base delay. There should also be a critical fail chance at lower levels, decreasing as you level, that you actually make your wound worse than making them better. Part of the fun of these games is the RNG and chance, and this would add another surprise (for me).
I understand that when playing solo this hinders our ability and slows down our gaming experience. I am one of those that prefers to hunt alone or with my wife and we usually don't have a healer around. But I think we are focusing on defensive skills, when really Mend Wounds is too good in it's current state.
The first thing that I feel we should base opinions of this skill off of are that it is not meant to be a replacement for actual healing classes/potions/spells in the game.
Also, in another thread we are discussing PvP and whether adjustments need to be made to defensive skills. I think the major issue is Mend Wounds. To me, Mend Wounds should be an emergency or after combat skill. Right now, you can sit down and basically keep pace (along with defensive skills) incoming damage (this is more to PvP than PvE).
Mends wounds should not be able to keep pace with incoming damage from 1 or 2 sources (factoring in defensive skills) until very high levels somewhere 75+. I think the success/fail rates are pretty close to dialed in.
My suggestion is the delay. The primary reason mend wounds works so well is due to the delay. It should not be a lower delay than an actual heal prayer (which is 4 seconds). As a matter of fact, at low levels it should be much higher and this would counterbalance all of the issues above. Somewhere in the 8 to 10 second delay range at low levels.
I am not sure that skills have the ability to lower the delay the higher you get in levels with the current code base, so if not then it should go to a 5 second base delay. There should also be a critical fail chance at lower levels, decreasing as you level, that you actually make your wound worse than making them better. Part of the fun of these games is the RNG and chance, and this would add another surprise (for me).
I understand that when playing solo this hinders our ability and slows down our gaming experience. I am one of those that prefers to hunt alone or with my wife and we usually don't have a healer around. But I think we are focusing on defensive skills, when really Mend Wounds is too good in it's current state.