[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
http://www.shatteredisles.com • Resource Cost Review
Page 1 of 1

Resource Cost Review

Posted: Mon Feb 17, 2014 8:01 pm
by
As requested, I'd like to evaluate some of the resource costs in the crafts; however, I only have any real access to the mining professions. If you are more versed in the other crafts, please add your notes here. If I don't get help with this, it will take quite a while to unlock and level the other crafts.





Stone Sculpting

Everything listed thus far makes sense logically and by game mechanics. Moreover, the prices are standardized, which leads me to believe this is your intended system for craft. Just keep up the good work here as you add more recipes.



Blacksmithy

Resource costs are good here logically and realistically with a few possible exceptions. The shovel costs 1 metal right now, and if it is a shovel like I'm used to (metal spade with wooden shaft), then this cost makes sense. However, since we supply no wood, this might be a 2-resource item made completely of metal.

Likewise, unless this pitcher is huge and I don't know it, pitchers should probably be 1 resource in cost.



Jewel Crafting

I really don't know where to start here... There is not a single item on this list that costs 1 metal (that i have thusfar unlocked). Everything is 2 metal or more. It requires -8- metal to make a diadem! I looked it up on Wikipedia, and a diadem is little more than a circlet with maybe a few fringe metal ribbons. There is no way more than a single bar of metal material went into making one!

Prices are all over the map in jewel crafting, but maybe the reason why it costs so much metal is to allow the final cost to be "higher" - I put that in quotes because it sells for around 16 doubloons per metal. When the jewel craft code gets a fail chance implemented or fixed, that'll still be a huge risk to make.

I recommend cutting all resource costs across the board to be in line with other crafts and pure rational sense.