Crafting Economics 101 or Crazy Coraleth’s Parting Words
Posted: Tue Feb 25, 2014 9:57 pm
First off, some math! Because math is good.
To reach level 40, it requires about 153,400 uses (though this is reduced to around 150500 due to the early levels providing 3 and 2 points per use until 11). That’s a lot of uses! So, how long does this take? Well, if you are doing something like close combat or spell casting, let’s say you spend 5 seconds per use. That’s 752500 seconds, or 209 hours – roughly 8 to 9 days of pure grind-fest.
Now let’s go back the other way and use some algebra. What if what you need takes 120 seconds to get a point in a skill, and we have the same amount of time – how many uses will we have? The total comes to 6271ish – In other words, somewhere around level 12. Even if you had a skill that was say, 60 seconds, it would still put you only around 14, at 12541 uses.
Now, we can probably skip all this math and state the obvious: if you want to level faster, be an adventurer. But this comparison is important to make from an economic perspective as well. If both an adventurer and a crafter put in the same amount of time and get a different result, should they earn the same amount of money?
The answer is probably not. The interpretation of separate but equal didn’t work so well for segregation, and it doesn’t work so well here, either. There is some risk involved in adventuring, namely death. While death has no direct economic impact on a player, it does prevent the player from gaining money for a period of time. Gathering has overlap with adventuring in several places, but it is possible to hide in alcoves and run from battle, so as long as you pay attention you are generally fine, even though you are more likely to die than adventurer due to less armor, no weapons, and lower skill. Unfortunately, how much time and money is wasted running from the one vein of material you need cannot be so easily quantified in math, any more than the amount of money lost to spirit form is.
So the question becomes, how much does safety cost? Let’s use the above example of a level 40 adventurer and a level 12 stone sculptor. The stone sculptor makes 8 doubloons for his work, so with a 90% success rate, he is making 7 doubloons every minute if someone is feeding him resources, or around 4 if he has to mine for himself and has good luck with finding stone. On the other hand, a 40 adventurer can take down a statue in 45 seconds, and earn an average of 23 doubloons. Let’s assume the full time for a gather/crafter. Adjusted for time – in other words, the two kills that the adventurer would make at the same time it takes for a crafter to harvest and create – the final score is 4 to 46. The price of safety at current therefore equals 92%. In other terms, an adventure can make 11.5 times more than a crafter of equal time investment.
Now these times are estimated, of course, but even with the piddly skill I’ve gotten from fighting off orcs while mining, I can kill statues at a rate of about 1-2 minutes. This means that if I had spent as much time adventuring as I had crafting these last two months, I would be able to slaughter them with relative ease and make over 1000% more profit than if I had been a crafter.
I was going to post a crafting guide, but after doing the math, it didn’t add up for me to do so.
When the time comes, I hope the devs will look back at this math and realize just how much work a crafter has to put in for so far less of a result. Unfortunately, this will be the last time I give my suggestions and advice here on these forums. It has come to my attention that my presence here is causing more problems than it is solving, and that puts me in the unconscionable position of having to decide between playing a game I have enjoyed and harming my friends, and leaving and hoping that things get better for them. My choice is clear.
I want to thank everyone I’ve met here, you have been awesome and the RP has been stellar. I want to thank the devs for the game and the chance to help, even though I must apologize that I muddied everything up.
I leave behind a road map. I am hopeful that it will be followed and that this world and I might meet up again someday, but I know all too well that we each must choose our own path in life.
I leave you with a sense of what I mean.
Two roads diverged in a yellow wood,
And sorry I could not travel both
And be one traveler, long I stood
And looked down one as far as I could
To where it bent in the undergrowth
Then took the other, as just as fair,
And having perhaps the better claim,
Because it was grassy and wanted wear;
Though as for that the passing there
Had worn them really about the same,
And both that morning equally lay
In leaves no step had trodden black.
Oh, I kept the first for another day!
Yet knowing how way leads on to way,
I doubted if I should ever come back.
I shall be telling this with a sigh
Somewhere ages and ages hence:
Two roads diverged in a wood, and I –
I took the one less traveled by,
And that has made all the difference.
-Robert Frost
To reach level 40, it requires about 153,400 uses (though this is reduced to around 150500 due to the early levels providing 3 and 2 points per use until 11). That’s a lot of uses! So, how long does this take? Well, if you are doing something like close combat or spell casting, let’s say you spend 5 seconds per use. That’s 752500 seconds, or 209 hours – roughly 8 to 9 days of pure grind-fest.
Now let’s go back the other way and use some algebra. What if what you need takes 120 seconds to get a point in a skill, and we have the same amount of time – how many uses will we have? The total comes to 6271ish – In other words, somewhere around level 12. Even if you had a skill that was say, 60 seconds, it would still put you only around 14, at 12541 uses.
Now, we can probably skip all this math and state the obvious: if you want to level faster, be an adventurer. But this comparison is important to make from an economic perspective as well. If both an adventurer and a crafter put in the same amount of time and get a different result, should they earn the same amount of money?
The answer is probably not. The interpretation of separate but equal didn’t work so well for segregation, and it doesn’t work so well here, either. There is some risk involved in adventuring, namely death. While death has no direct economic impact on a player, it does prevent the player from gaining money for a period of time. Gathering has overlap with adventuring in several places, but it is possible to hide in alcoves and run from battle, so as long as you pay attention you are generally fine, even though you are more likely to die than adventurer due to less armor, no weapons, and lower skill. Unfortunately, how much time and money is wasted running from the one vein of material you need cannot be so easily quantified in math, any more than the amount of money lost to spirit form is.
So the question becomes, how much does safety cost? Let’s use the above example of a level 40 adventurer and a level 12 stone sculptor. The stone sculptor makes 8 doubloons for his work, so with a 90% success rate, he is making 7 doubloons every minute if someone is feeding him resources, or around 4 if he has to mine for himself and has good luck with finding stone. On the other hand, a 40 adventurer can take down a statue in 45 seconds, and earn an average of 23 doubloons. Let’s assume the full time for a gather/crafter. Adjusted for time – in other words, the two kills that the adventurer would make at the same time it takes for a crafter to harvest and create – the final score is 4 to 46. The price of safety at current therefore equals 92%. In other terms, an adventure can make 11.5 times more than a crafter of equal time investment.
Now these times are estimated, of course, but even with the piddly skill I’ve gotten from fighting off orcs while mining, I can kill statues at a rate of about 1-2 minutes. This means that if I had spent as much time adventuring as I had crafting these last two months, I would be able to slaughter them with relative ease and make over 1000% more profit than if I had been a crafter.
I was going to post a crafting guide, but after doing the math, it didn’t add up for me to do so.
When the time comes, I hope the devs will look back at this math and realize just how much work a crafter has to put in for so far less of a result. Unfortunately, this will be the last time I give my suggestions and advice here on these forums. It has come to my attention that my presence here is causing more problems than it is solving, and that puts me in the unconscionable position of having to decide between playing a game I have enjoyed and harming my friends, and leaving and hoping that things get better for them. My choice is clear.
I want to thank everyone I’ve met here, you have been awesome and the RP has been stellar. I want to thank the devs for the game and the chance to help, even though I must apologize that I muddied everything up.
I leave behind a road map. I am hopeful that it will be followed and that this world and I might meet up again someday, but I know all too well that we each must choose our own path in life.
I leave you with a sense of what I mean.
Two roads diverged in a yellow wood,
And sorry I could not travel both
And be one traveler, long I stood
And looked down one as far as I could
To where it bent in the undergrowth
Then took the other, as just as fair,
And having perhaps the better claim,
Because it was grassy and wanted wear;
Though as for that the passing there
Had worn them really about the same,
And both that morning equally lay
In leaves no step had trodden black.
Oh, I kept the first for another day!
Yet knowing how way leads on to way,
I doubted if I should ever come back.
I shall be telling this with a sigh
Somewhere ages and ages hence:
Two roads diverged in a wood, and I –
I took the one less traveled by,
And that has made all the difference.
-Robert Frost