[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
http://www.shatteredisles.com • Priest feedback based on the fights last night
Page 1 of 1

Priest feedback based on the fights last night

Posted: Fri Mar 07, 2014 2:46 pm
by
So based off of last nights fights, I've got some feedback for priests and some suggestions.

During the team fights, Requiem was putting out a constant stream of damage in the mid teens, as was Morley. However, I was able to keep pace and simply heal it away. I'm not saying this isn't something a priest should be able to do, but I am saying it's something I don't think I should be able to do right now at my current levels.

I don't know what Requiem or Morley's CC levels are at, but I can guess they are pretty high up there compared to my heal level. Frankly, 1v1, neither Morley nor Requiem could kill me; they simply couldn't put out damage fast enough to outpace my heal. 2v2 is a different story, but at my current levels, I should still get smacked around 1v1.

I have a couple suggestions to try and even this out, as well as general suggestions for the class:

1. My first, and probably most controversial, is to remove shield block from priests, but continue to allow them to wear armor, and still have them unlock defend in some manner. In conjunction to this, however, priests would unlock defensive prayers at a much earlier rate then mages, and at a higher effectiveness.

2. I'd suggest that divine and elemental spells be separated. In other words, a elemental dispell won't work on a divine prayer, and a divine dispell won't work on an elemental spell. In conjunction to this, I would add that the spells of different types (divine or elemental) be allowed to stack. Ex. A mage casts a shield on themselves. A priest could then cast a holy shield over that, but two elemental shields cannot stack, and two divine shields cannot stack. I think this allows priests to work with other casters, as well putting in an interesting strategy that calls for a priest or templar to combat divine magics, and mages to combat elemental ones.

There could be, however, a level in which the two classes unlock a second dispel. This dispel would probably take longer to cast, but work on the type of magic/prayer that their original dispel could not.

3. As I mentioned, a priests' defensive prayers should probably have an increased effectiveness compared to mages - with or without having shield block removed. As a support class, the priests currently do very little supporting. The shield spell in general probably needs a bump, as it has minimal use in PvE, and no use in PvP.

4. As there are different tiers of attack spells, there should be different tiers of healing, as well as storm heals or mass heals in addition to more buffs/debuffs - I'd probably guess most of this is probably in the works for the coming updates?

5. Can priests please, please, please get a dispell prayer in the meantime while we wait for any other update? Currently, I get 1 use every 9 minutes from my shield T_T. That's a whopping 6 and a half uses per hour for a skill that adds around 25 DR. And as of now, it should probably work vs mage spells, as mage dispells currently work vs divine prayers.

6. Defend in PvP seems to be an almost useless thing because a PC can do what mobs cannot: retarget. I'd like to see defend force a target to attack the defending PC for a certain amount of time, which would increase based on level. A rough suggestion of this could be that at level 1, defend works for 3 combat rounds, or 12 seconds. Every five levels, it increases by one round (4 seconds), maxing out at 23 rounds, or 92 seconds which is about a minute and a half. It could also increase by a half round (2 secs) every five levels, mounting to a full round (4 secs) every ten. This would mean at level 1, defend would still work for 3 rounds, 12 secs, and increase to a max of 13 rounds, or 52 seconds at level 100.

Of course, this defend will only work on a single target like it currently does; one couldn't defend a PC from two characters using the skill. It would be, then, nice to be able to target your defend, i.e. use the command "defend [character] [attacker]"

The skill in PvE works with only the slight bugs in them, which have been brought up before, but it seems to be lacking in PvP utility, and such a move can add a usefulness and depth to the classes that have it - as well as integrating them into a team setting.

Re: Priest feedback based on the fights last night

Posted: Fri Mar 07, 2014 3:26 pm
by
I'm not sure how to respond to this without sounding like I am being biased simply because I play a priest as well. Quite frankly I'm not sure why you'd even make some of these suggestions. I see nothing wrong with keeping pace with healing damage in 1v1 pvp and without shield block we'd be sitting ducks against melee but I will reserve judgment until the prayer update goes in.

Re: Priest feedback based on the fights last night

Posted: Fri Mar 07, 2014 3:54 pm
by
I think it was Requiem (I could be mistaken) that I fought in the fight club a few weeks back and I can tell you I got my ass handed to me. I kept pace for awhile with my healing but I would not have been able to keep up. I would have been killed. I was probably mid 20's heal at the time. To have any chance to extend the fight I'd have to do nothing but pray heal non-stop without any offense. I find it hard to believe Morley could not kill you.

Re: Priest feedback based on the fights last night

Posted: Fri Mar 07, 2014 4:58 pm
by
When Blink and Requiem were attacking me, I could keep pace and heal as long I as focused all my attention on it. And even though Blink might have only been a mage, his attacks are more effective against me than they would be against a CC character, and they also soaked up a defense as well, allowing for Requiem to land hits with less interruption from my shield.

When Morley was attacking me in the last fight, he couldn't get me anywhere near a danger zone as long as I kept the heal going.

Like I said, it's not that I don't think a priest should be able to out heal melee 1v1, and I'm not bragging that I'm some invincible tank, I'm saying that the heal rates probably need to be looked at as the game progresses. My heal is level 20. I find it hard to believe I should be able to survive 1v1 against high level melee for a great amount of time. Perhaps we didn't fight for long enough, but from the rate that the battle was going, it seemed like I could survive indefinitely even against the higher level CC characters.

Basically, it was like me 1v1 soloing vampires. The vampires hit me a little less often then Morley or Requiem, but they had similar damage outputs. I can out heal a single vampire's damage all day every day even at level 20 heal - and thanks to the holy strike damage buff against them, I can kill them as well, though it takes some time balancing the damage and heals.

You're probably right in that it wasn't the best idea to remove shield block, but I didn't intend for it to get removed without having effective prayers to make up for the loss of the defense. That was the tradeoff: no passive, but stronger defensive prayers. It's not that I assume all of these to be golden ideas, but they were food for thought to consider different ways of balancing a class that might not have been previously considered.

Edited to add: Perhaps in the OOC games we can hash some of this out. I'd like to really see just how long I can withstand a high level CC bashing on me. It could be I'm completely off base here, but I've noted the heal rates to seem a bit wonky. I don't think they are too far off from where they should be, but I'm not sure they are where they should be at now. Dunno. There's not much to the priest class right now, so it's hard to consider what may or may not need to change.

Re: Priest feedback based on the fights last night

Posted: Fri Mar 07, 2014 6:33 pm
by
The fastest way to bring high level CC in line with casting is unlocking faster swing rates. 3 sec at 50 and 2 sec at 75. That way you don't have to nerf Priests. Why tear down when you can build up.

Re: Priest feedback based on the fights last night

Posted: Fri Mar 07, 2014 6:53 pm
by
Teef wrote:The fastest way to bring high level CC in line with casting is unlocking faster swing rates. 3 sec at 50 and 2 sec at 75. That way you don't have to nerf Priests. Why tear down when you can build up.
I support this idea.

Never liked being stuck at 4 seconds indefinitely.

Re: Priest feedback based on the fights last night

Posted: Fri Mar 07, 2014 7:11 pm
by
I do like that idea. As someone with more than a little combat experience IRL, most people just starting out will be slow. As you progress, you get more proficient and you get faster.

There is nothing I do that takes 4 seconds. That much time wasted is usually fatal, anyway.

Re: Priest feedback based on the fights last night

Posted: Fri Mar 07, 2014 11:29 pm
by
Aumnren wrote:So based off of last nights fights, I've got some feedback for priests and some suggestions.

During the team fights, Requiem was putting out a constant stream of damage in the mid teens, as was Morley. However, I was able to keep pace and simply heal it away. I'm not saying this isn't something a priest should be able to do, but I am saying it's something I don't think I should be able to do right now at my current levels.

I don't know what Requiem or Morley's CC levels are at, but I can guess they are pretty high up there compared to my heal level. Frankly, 1v1, neither Morley nor Requiem could kill me; they simply couldn't put out damage fast enough to outpace my heal. 2v2 is a different story, but at my current levels, I should still get smacked around 1v1.
Heya mate (or as I originally wrote - hey meta),

You're right, your heal return at that level against those kind of players probably isn't where we want it. Like I said in another post, however, I'm wary of judging solely based off a controlled event.

Aumnren wrote:1. My first, and probably most controversial, is to remove shield block from priests, but continue to allow them to wear armor, and still have them unlock defend in some manner. In conjunction to this, however, priests would unlock defensive prayers at a much earlier rate then mages, and at a higher effectiveness.
Much like with mages, we're unlikely to ever remove shield block from them. One versus one someone will probably never beat a priest, or it'll be a very long-drawn out affair. Two versus one, and where we want it, however, is probably an entirely different matter.
Aumnren wrote:2. I'd suggest that divine and elemental spells be separated. In other words, a elemental dispell won't work on a divine prayer, and a divine dispell won't work on an elemental spell. In conjunction to this, I would add that the spells of different types (divine or elemental) be allowed to stack. Ex. A mage casts a shield on themselves. A priest could then cast a holy shield over that, but two elemental shields cannot stack, and two divine shields cannot stack. I think this allows priests to work with other casters, as well putting in an interesting strategy that calls for a priest or templar to combat divine magics, and mages to combat elemental ones.

There could be, however, a level in which the two classes unlock a second dispel. This dispel would probably take longer to cast, but work on the type of magic/prayer that their original dispel could not.
I think that's definitely an interesting idea, though stacking shields of the same exact purpose (DR for example), likely isn't balanced. But I, personally, like the idea of separating the 'schools' of magic/casting if you will.

I also like the idea of a second dispel, unlocking across the two lines, but that's a very tricky thing work out. Would a mage, for example, be able to dispel a pulsing heal spell in the future, if there's one? A priest might be able to dispel a pulsing damage spell because we could argue it'd be considered a disease or curse, but would they for example be able to dispel the buffs on a mage?
Aumnren wrote:3. As I mentioned, a priests' defensive prayers should probably have an increased effectiveness compared to mages - with or without having shield block removed. As a support class, the priests currently do very little supporting. The shield spell in general probably needs a bump, as it has minimal use in PvE, and no use in PvP.
I think that's a good suggestion, as well. Mages are more hybrid, where a priest is primarily support. I wouldn't put it TOO much over mages in the end, but I do think a good percentage over wouldn't be out of the norm. This would especially be true in the case of absorption spells when (please, fingers crossed) are implemented.

Aumnren wrote:4. As there are different tiers of attack spells, there should be different tiers of healing, as well as storm heals or mass heals in addition to more buffs/debuffs - I'd probably guess most of this is probably in the works for the coming updates?
Different tiers of healing spells would be ideal, definitely. As for group heals (which I think is what you're trying to suggest with storm heals/mass heals), I'm not sure if that's possible (though if some mage spells are theoretically groupable then I suppose healing spells might be too), but I think that's a grand idea and I'm sure at least a tad few of us are familiar with them from other text games.
Aumnren wrote:5. Can priests please, please, please get a dispell prayer in the meantime while we wait for any other update? Currently, I get 1 use every 9 minutes from my shield T_T. That's a whopping 6 and a half uses per hour for a skill that adds around 25 DR. And as of now, it should probably work vs mage spells, as mage dispells currently work vs divine prayers.
I'd suggest using the IDEA command for this one, mate. I can't promise it'll speed it along, but I'd agree it'd really help out the other caster class (priests, obviously) out.
Aumnren wrote:6. Defend in PvP seems to be an almost useless thing because a PC can do what mobs cannot: retarget. I'd like to see defend force a target to attack the defending PC for a certain amount of time, which would increase based on level. A rough suggestion of this could be that at level 1, defend works for 3 combat rounds, or 12 seconds. Every five levels, it increases by one round (4 seconds), maxing out at 23 rounds, or 92 seconds which is about a minute and a half. It could also increase by a half round (2 secs) every five levels, mounting to a full round (4 secs) every ten. This would mean at level 1, defend would still work for 3 rounds, 12 secs, and increase to a max of 13 rounds, or 52 seconds at level 100.

Of course, this defend will only work on a single target like it currently does; one couldn't defend a PC from two characters using the skill. It would be, then, nice to be able to target your defend, i.e. use the command "defend [character] [attacker]"

The skill in PvE works with only the slight bugs in them, which have been brought up before, but it seems to be lacking in PvP utility, and such a move can add a usefulness and depth to the classes that have it - as well as integrating them into a team setting.
I'm not sure about such a length even at level one hundred, but I am 110% onboard for being allowed to defend
[character] [attacker/mob]. I'm just not sure it's doable at this moment, it's such a wonky skill. You're familiar with the bugs/discrepancies in it, even in PVE with just using DEFEND instead of DEFEND <name>. I'd really like to see a few attacks be defended against PCs, nothing overly long, but even two or three - and maybe on an internal cooldown of like two minutes if possible, then resetting and allowing two or so again. Nothing huge, but a nice little addition to make it a short, yet still useful, PVP skill as well.

Cheers!

Re: Priest feedback based on the fights last night

Posted: Fri Mar 07, 2014 11:30 pm
by
Also, heya other mates,

It's unlikely we'll ever see staggered delay drops. It just isn't possible at the moment, code wise.

Cheers.

Re: Priest feedback based on the fights last night

Posted: Sat Mar 08, 2014 12:35 pm
by
Have a new attack skill unlock that has a lower delay... Fast Attack