Besides, some classes hunt easier than others, or have certain complementary abilities that allow them to raise certain skills faster. I think it'd be a mite unfair form someone to pour in time with a with a character who could raise a skill quickly, and then port over to a new character to benefit from the saved time.
Yeah, Warrior. Possibly Barb too, but mostly the former. That's two classes. Trust me, I took that into consideration when I first found out about the reset, and I don't think that's reason enough. I've considered swapping Wren from Assassin to Thief before, but it's not a decision I'd make lightly and I shouldn't lose all those
months of work if I did decide to do it, especially since I'm really not gaining any kind of advantage by doing so. I could understand if things like Pilfer would have no carry-over ability and would have to be raised from 0. That's fine, but all those levels of CC, Ranged, and Unarmed I worked my butt off to get? Not to mention the stealth abilities? No, that's too harsh.
I don't necessarily think players should be able to simply shift on a whim and carry over their skills. There are some MUDs built to accommodate this, but I don't think SI is one of them.
I don't think it should be done on a whim either. As to whether SI can accommodate this, I'm sure it's possible to manually set someone's levels. They changed my Parry level when we lost Dodge, for example. Again I really don't mean to imply I think this should be something people can do just because they happen to feel like being something else that day, but if there's reason enough for it especially IC, I don't see why it would have to severely cripple their character.
If anything, it'd probably be a good idea to reserve such a request for RP purposes, and to work the class change, and subsequent removal of skills, into a specific event that helps to grow your character.
Certain new skills that make the class what it is, definitely, but basic CC and the like? Why would they suddenly not remember how to fight properly?
For instance, I'm saving my class change for some event that might have Loriel regain his connection to wind magics, if I ever decide playing a priest isn't really the class I want. Or perhaps he might get jailed one time, go insane and feral and become a barbarian.
In the case of the latter, level resets would make sense because Loriel was never a melee fighter to begin with. If I decided to make Wren a mage, or Arcanist in the future, then I could understand the resets because it would actually make
sense. She's never used magic in her life! Probably for good reason.
How would melee transfer to mage or mage to melee? There's no good set way to equate this.
I feel like it's a case by case thing, or should be. Inter-melee changes and inter-mage changes will obviously be easier than swapping one for the other, but I'm sure it could be figured out. At least with humans and vukasin they can be any of the mages so it would be a matter of changing religions IC. The elemental elves are obviously stuck with their religion/mage type.
Probably rambling by this point. Just don't want to see players suffer such a heavy blow if their choice has good enough reasons IC and OOC!