[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/viewtopic.php on line 2067: Undefined array key "author"
http://www.shatteredisles.com • Race Q&A Results
Page 1 of 1

Race Q&A Results

Posted: Fri Feb 17, 2012 11:50 am
by
Creators in attendance were Snaek, Austere, and Anselm.


Tollkirsche: Concerning Gavialians and the shattering. and the time afterwards. I noticed on the website they mention desert oasis's and swamp/wetland areas.

Snaek: What is it you're wanting to know about those things?

Tollkirsche: I am trying to figure out how the shattering affected there habitat and spread. Like how is they became so spread out after the shattering, and for that need to know about how the shattering affected them.

Snaek: Before the shattering, Gavials followed the four elements of earth, fire, air, and water. The shattering didn't change their diverse climates. If a gavial is raised in a wetland environment, that's where they thrive. It doesn't mean that one particular gavial would do well in all climate types. All the shattering did was put some distance between the different groups of gavials that live in those climates.

Aanak: A gavial that lives in a swamp would not do well in a desert?

Snaek nods to Aanak.

Snaek: A gavial's element is also their preferred climate type.

Snaek: Those that follow Pyrous would be your desert dwelling gavials, while swamp gavials might live in swampland areas.


Milo: Do you think having Vukasin be aloof is going to lead to them not being chosen by good roleplayers?

Asensa: Aloof is exceptionally difficult to RP.

Milo: If you play it right, you're just a loner that people don't interact with much. Hard to tell a loner from a good RPer.

Snaek: It's worth looking into as they develop. Vukasins are every bit as diverse as humans so there's really a lot of ways for them to go. I don't think that one trait will limit them.

Anselm: When I think of aloof I don't necessarily think as being a loner showcasing whether they're roleplaying or not, but how they express their aloofness and distaste of others in interactions.

Tollkirsche: Yah, when I think aloof I think those that don't readily get mixed up with mundane things.

Milo: I think that'll make it a bit more difficult for people to get involved in group stuff. It's something to watch.

Snaek: You've got to be of some value to that particular Vukasin for them to show any interest in you or your cause.

Snaek: We'll definitely see how it develops. I can tell you I've already seen a vukasin show minimal effort in a city function, and another get involved just for a prize. it's all about what motivates each vukasin.

Aanak: A Vukasin sounds ideal for a player that wants to play solo and does not have as much interest in group playing.

Snaek: I agree. They aren't limited to that, but it's a great excuse for those that prefer to do their own thing.

Milo: I am having some trouble since I want to get involved in RP that goes on but also balance that out against my character not wanting to get involved.

Snaek: Something will come along that gives you cause to get involved for your own selfish reasons.

Milo: Perhaps they could be a bit territorial so would have some reason to defend their cities?

Snaek: It's a dangerous slope toward forming packs of vukasin. I'm not against that, but I'd prefer to let the players go that route than steer them there.


Aanak: Will solo players have ever opportunity that group players will have to advance their character? I have seen in other games group playing was encouraged to the point that is was detrimental to be a solo player.

Snaek: Of course we want to encourage group events of any kind, but a healthy balance is the dream.

Snaek: To better answer your question, I don't think a solo player will be limited in how well they can do. A class like scouts is set up with that kind of player in mind.

Aanak: I guess a better question would have been in regards to hunting and making money. will a solo player be able to advance his bank account without being forced to group hunt?

Tollkirsche: I don't think it will be that difficult, from what I've seen once tactical skills go in and other class skills.

Tollkirsche: I think fluffing ones bank account is more on the ability of a person to windlessly smash shit into pieces.

Aanak: and I dont mean being a hermit and not RPing with the other players. I am strictly talking in a money making sense.

Anselm: I believe, if I may, Aanak is referring to previous games where there was a sizable difference between the top-end solo hunting grounds coin-earning wise compared to areas that required a group.

Tollkirsche: From what I've seen I think that is true for the most part anywhere for balance issues. there is always going to be areas designed for groups and other areas for skilled solo players. though if done well they even out.

Snaek: You're always going to do better hunting with someone else. We're not going to go out of our way to discourage solo hunting though and I think anyone that puts the effort into their skills will be able to compete just fine with group hunters.

Aanak: the trade skills that are being implemented will probably make up for any difference in hunting area payouts.

Milo: It will be always a difficult balance because group hunting areas have to be difficult and have to reward. Solo hunters always will have to settle for either a lower-level hunt or much slower hunting.

Anselm: I think while as Snaek said it is reasonable that people who group hunt will always earn more than a single hunter when compared side to side for time commitment, we will certainly work so it maintains a balance and the difference doesn't become ridiculous.

Anselm: And doesn't totally negate even entertaining the idea of hunting solo to have any hope of maintaining in the same playing field, economic wise, as group hunters.

Tollkirsche: I think the biggest thing on that is still going to be the time each is willing to put into actually hunting.

Asensa: I don't think anyone really gets pidgeon holed into one category all the time anyway, I'm less of an RPer and I group hunt when I can find a group and solo when I want to mindlessly train. Often times there's a give and take in choosing less coin for more uses or whatever the goal may be.



Aanak: Maybe off topic for a race Q&A but is there any plans for Monks?

Snaek: It's not impossible. We've still got plans to add one more class for sake of balance, but there's a lot of different ways to go there.



Tollkirsche: Are Templars still going to be a viable class option for Gavialians?

Tollkirsche: I assume Gavialians are hatched yes?

Snaek: In gavialian society there is room for a head religious figure, and given their aggressive nature, it's more fitting for that gavial to be a templar rather than a cleric.

Snaek: A Gavial templar would be fairly rare. There wouldn't be much need for more than a couple within each group of gavials.

Snaek: I should point out that gavials of different religions do not instantly get along because of some unspoken brotherhood bond.

Tollkirsche: I was kindah thinking the templar would be like the village head or shaman. the one who pretty much holds the hilt of the weapon so to put it.

Snaek: It's entirely possible for gavials of different elements to be at odds.

Aanak: I hope they do not turn into Montanians. Gavials seem to have plenty of infighting that the Montanians lacked.

Snaek: I would like to see them get a fair shot at something new, which is why we've tried to leave a lot open there. The big thing being room for them to be against one another.

Tollkirsche: From what I've read, because of their culture and how the elements work I think it will be totaly feesiable for clans to be at odds with one another.

Tollkirsche: Though I still think overall like any culture that is at odds with the beleaves of its other kind. when threatened by something bigger and badder they can kill it first before getting back to killing one another.

Snaek: Your element really is everything, and that will be a common theme throughout every race.

Aanak: I'd prefer to see them at odds occasionally rather than blindly siding with one another because they are the same race. I think the Vukasin better fit that descriptuion of sticking up for their race.

Anselm: There is always someone who has a price within every group, perhaps even multiples working together.

Snaek: If there is an issue that impacts vukasins as a whole, absolutely. They would then all have the same common interest and desire to work together.

Tollkirsche: Granted I loved how in dgate monitanians where about hte only race that was 100% solid within itself because of the iron claw of the female hiearchy. this is a different game with different elements and think it wouldn't be doing the race justice to try and fully smash it into another.


Aanak: how would a Bolinau regard collecting magical treasure?

Snaek: They'd be all over it. Not to use it mind you, but for its trade value.

Snaek says to Aanak, "they make up for that by having thicker skin than most, good strength, and the ability to fly."

Aanak: Will it be poor RP for a Bolinau to use magical items?"

Snaek: It would be if they were purposely doing so, if that makes sense. It's a thin line but I could see Bolinaus using enchanted weapons and just being happy that using it seems to make them hit better or whatever the enchantment may be. Does that make sense?

Aanak: So a magic wand that throws fireballs is frowned upon. an enchanted blade is ok.

Snaek: It's not a concrete yes or no, but it's something that an aware community would enforce itself.

Snaek: From a pure mechanical standpoint, everyone wants to be able to use something that gives them an advantage. If a bolinau can make that work through an enchanted weapon or item that isn't an obvious display of magic, then they've earned the right to use that item I think.





Milo: What's the timeline for race and class skills?

Snaek: No specific length of time is set, but our hunting areas are reaching a point where they are good for testing, and we're full focus on crafting right now. Once that is in a similar state we'll start pressing tactical skills full force.




Aanak: Does Gargoyle poor blood circulation have any mechanical impact or it is added for RP purposes only?

Snaek: They tend to have lower health points than races of similar size, and eventually will regen health and stamina slower as a result.

Snaek: They make up for that by having thicker skin than most, good strength, and the ability to fly.


Snaek: Let me ask you all a race question. Given the limited amount of information out there, do you think the 4 different elven races would get along?

Tollkirsche: Yes and no. From the little I've read I think some of the inherit differences will make it damn near impossiable for some of them to get along as a whole, without extreme special circumstances.

Asensa: No.

Aanak: How large of a playerbase will we need to even support 4 eleven races? i think because of their rarity they should be at the very least tolerable of each other.

Tollkirsche: Much bigger. Although this game mechanicly speaking has the abilites for even NPC's to be more real.

Snaek: It shouldn't matter. Everything points toward your element, so each elven race is just another addition to that.

Snaek: The general rule is Pyrous and Aerthane get along, Kaleith and Tetherias get along, Pryous and kaleith strongly dislike each other, and aerthane and Tetherias dont agree on anything.

Aanak: So instead of not getting along based on their race it should be based on their element.

Snaek: In the case of the elven races, their race is their element. They are the most connected and passionate about it.

Aanak: A devalin and an avardi would get along but throw in a Verdani and all bets are off.



Asensa: So I guess as go the elves so to go the dragons that are effected by their elements?

Snaek nods to Asensa.

Snaek: Dragons never believed in the gods until the shattering. After the gods revealed themselves, it was no longer a question. Furthermore, the gods took their immortality and their magic, requiring that they gain it back through the acceptance of their power. So once a dragon is assisted by an elemental mage, they are forever linked to that element.



Milo: As religion is so crucial, should people have god marks?

Tollkirsche: I kindah don't like the idea of god marks. I know if people want to show their religion they can wear items that shows the faith they follow. I am thinking for like the spys and snaeky folks. infiltrating enemy religions broadcasting it is kindah meh. or those that are not strongly influenced by their element.

Snaek: We're still debating it. It may be something that has to be done, but if there is a way to pull it off without making it visible, we'll go that route. We've experimented with aura spells that reveal that kind of information. I think going this route would create more RP opportunities than putting it right out in the open.

Snaek: If there are ways to prevent it by the players, then thieves deserve a chance to slip by it.

Aanak: Maybe have members of the same religion see a godmark of those that have the same religion. Maybe only allow clerics sense a godmark. To promote cross-temple conflict, having visible godmarks might be the way to go.

Milo: Or a sense of connection.

Tollkirsche: For me I think that is where the RP comes from. For those that are overzealouse in their faith it will certainly be noticeable by their playstyle. Like a cleric going around speaking the praise of their element.

Aanak: If this games conflict has a lot of influence from religions; I think it is important to see godmarks.

Snaek: It's a reality vs game-play debate for sure. Realistically, you would not always know someone's religion by looking at them. but like you said, since it is the centerpiece of our worldly conflict, it may just have to happen.

Anselm: It also provides opportunities for friendly interactions and bonding as well. A starting point for conversation, if you will.

Milo: We also don't have gods walking down the street here.

Tollkirsche: I am still of the frame of mind that it being important is up to people to RP, I think godmarks tend to be a bit of a forceful approch. there is alot of ingame things that can be done to show ones center of faith.

Aanak: I dont think that is a reality. you might be able to pull it off or joeRPer might be able to pull it off too but I do not think it is fair to assume our entire playerbase can pull off RPing his religion.

Snaek: We'll give it some more debate before deciding one way or the other. Perhaps take it to the forums and hopefully get some others to weigh in.

Tollkirsche: That point I will have to agree with you on, Aanak. I understand its something that is easier for someone that is more familiar with RP and RP based games to to do.

Aanak: If religious conflict wasnt the centerpiece of the games conflict, I might be leaning more in your court but I can't help to think the playerbase will need to be nudged in the right direction when it comes to what another players religion is.

Snaek: we'll do what needs to be done to make sure religious conflict is the focus. It's not the only form of conflict out there though, just the most world effecting.

Snaek: Two things we will not have is a godless option, and changing religions. Although I shouldn't rule out converting completely. It would be rare if possible.

Aanak: I have a hard time believing your average RPer is going to put the time or even have the time to determine someones religion and weather or not they should be hunting with them.

Tollkirsche: what about optional tattoo god marks?

Tollkirsche: Perhaps something that can be done at roll up as well as later on?

Milo: Roll-up needs to stress gods more, I think.

Snaek: Agreed. Part of the reason behind this and future Q&As is so we can flesh this stuff out more and get the information in the right places.

Milo: I'd like to see rooms at roll-up that give you background on gods, class and the world history. With a way to shortcut, as well. Of course, having more of this info subtly woven into the world is good, too.

Snaek: We're working on a way to work a brief recap of world changing events into the creation process. the trick is making it informative without taking too long. Most players make it all the way through it so that's an accomplishment in itself. The main academy building will also be a huge source of information as well. It wont always be the empty building it is now.


Aanak: Are different weapon types more effecteive on certain types of armor? If not, are there plans to make it that way?

Snaek: Currently no, but that is the direction we are heading and it's definitely something we are currently capable of doing.



Aanak: How are goblins viewed by the other races? are they rescpected at any level?

Austere: Life is tough for a goblin. I almost wouldn't be surprised if one was helping an orc mine. I can not tell you how well they will be received, that may depend on how crafty they can become.

Snaek: Another race that deserves a fair chance at a fresh start. I would like to see our goblins be able to think more than 5 minutes into the future and act accordingly. They should be crafty enough to plot things out, even if done so poorly.

Snaek: As far as being respected, History shows that Itzal respected them for their ability to fight as a race.



Tollkirsche: I would like to hear some of the back lore that isn't posted.

Snaek: This isn't official, but it is shaping up very nicely for dwarves and bolinaus to not get along. They seem to have absolutely nothing in common. Though they can both follow Astraeva as both races sided with her in the battle that led to the shattering.




Aanak: what is the staffs stance of races with flight flying up and raining arrows down on NPC's as a way to level? will there be checks put into place to keep this from happening? I dont think flight works that way yet but in the future when they can fly out of melee range.

Snaek: Flight will likely never have different elevations to it. I can't rule it out completely but it's not a current goal. We want to add depth with range within the room, but not height.

Aanak: Interesting. what is the purpose of flight then?

Milo: Getting around fast. :).

Snaek: Flight in battle can negate things like bind and trip, but it's also a means of transportation. Wings can take you places flying spells cannot, and get you to other places faster.

Anselm: Yes, there is a whole series of sky rooms.

Snaek: There may come a day when we want to add another variable to combat and we consider elevation within a room, but it's just not int he cards right now.




Tollkirsche: I know this doesn't really fit the racial and history part...but what about mounts and rideable creatures? Just wondering if say a dragon and their mage are hunting, would it be fesiable for the mage to ride on the dragon? or riding a horse. perhaps even intercity carriages. pay a fee and get brought to a larger city or center of commorce.

>
Snaek: we've done some minor work with pets and have plans for them. Depending on how they go we'll look at mounts and mounted combat. I highly doubt you'll ever see a situation where you can ride a player dragon.




Tollkirsche: My final question is a bit for kindah general and broad for everyone player wise in the room. How is everyone liking things so far and the potential within this game in itself?

Milo: Wound mending is awesome.

Snaek: awful.

Austere gasps.

Anselm: I hate the staff.

Aanak: I wish I had more time to play."

Milo: The tradeskills currently invite huge scripting because of the time investment necessary to raise them. Also, they haven't yet hinted at any potential to make money from them.

Tollkirsche: actually from what I've seen the potential to make money is there...alot of it happens to be the small merchant selection in this area. I managed to dig up some silver ore, and made a good amount off it. and when the merchants actually don't have a resource they pay well for it. the biggest problem I am seeing from the merchants is because of the msall playerbase inventories get clogged up fast on the merchants so the price given for things becomes laughable.

Aanak: How many tradeskills are available to be unlocked?"

Snaek: Around 30 I'd say. One comes before the other. Filling in their values is an easy, time consuming project. Before that though the skills need to function properly.




Aanak: Does combative ability unlock stuff too? I cant remember getting anything from it yet.

Milo: Yes, quite a lot. Dodge, parry, shield block, disarm.

Aanak: Maybe I need to just pay more attention.

Snaek: It's not always a skill, but leveling combative is how you raise your AR and DR, which is a gain in itself.

Aanak: I thought I started with those.

Tollkirsche: The starting levels are very rewarding. After 20 your efforts become less rewarding outside of AR/DR.

Milo: Combat... Have to wait and see... Tweaks are needed. Parry/dodge/block are overpowered at this level, in my opinion.

Tollkirsche: I don't know what level your talking about but I can barely get them to function. Unless your an ORC warrior.

Milo: Try in a room with 5-7 creatures attacking. You'll block quite a lot of them.



Aanak: Will bite be the same across the races that can use it or will anyone race be better at it?

Snaek: Same skill, but your racial damage will make it different.




Aanak: Do stats affect starting AR

Snaek shakes his head from side to side.

Aanak: So a barb with 30 AR at rollup was a bug?

Snaek: Yes, or a gift, depends on how you look at it. There's always balancing issues, but we wouldn't know about most of them without you all putting in the work of discovering them."




Tollkirsche: I would like to thank all the memembers of staff, and other players for taken the time to be here.

Milo: Seconded.


Snaek: Thank you all for coming. We'll get these questions cleaned up and on the website as soon as we can.

Anselm: I'd like to thank you all for your dedication to continue playing in early alpha. I know early alpha is usually the roughest, most barren time for the player experience. We've been trying to add as much staff-run interaction as possible, but I can understand it is still hard to get involved. Especially when many of you come from a different system mechanics wise, adjusting can often be intimidating or uncomfortable. It is very much appreciated from the staff that you all continue logging in. We hope to continue to improve your alpha experience, and continue to improve as well as make adjustments. All feedback is welcome in any form - here, the forums, or email. Thank you very much for your help and dedication. We hope to have some peddles coming up in the future, if there is something you'd care to see please don't hesitate to make suggestions.

Tollkirsche: on that note I will honestly say I am impressed so far about the IC interactions I've had. I also like the fact that not everyone seems to try and play kiss ass on CRC's. We the players also appreciate the dedication from you staffers.

Nikolas: The Nikolas character is an IC way for you to get your last name added to the who list, by the way. Least it's one of its responsibilities; so if ya are rolling up alts or run into new players that'll need that sort of thing please let'em know to find a Knight Marshal.

Milo: Should we be looking at bringing others in yet?

Snaek: That's a judgment call on your part. We're avoiding a post on the dgate forums until the tactical skills go in. Most people I know I am waiting until then as well. If you know someone well enough to discuss a text-based game with them and you think they are alpha material, please invite them.

Anselm: Early alpha is pretty rough, and again this system does take some adjusting to so it is easy to get discouraged and overwhelmed. Which is why those of you who have stuck around are much, much appreciated.

Snaek: we're all in this together. We all want to have a place to hang out once again. A place to create something new and be a part of it all, no matter how small a role we take on.